On Performance of Integrated Satellite HAPS Ground Communication: Aerial IRS Node vs Terrestrial IRS Node

Parvez Shaik, Kamal Garg, Praveen Kumar Singya, Vimal Bhatia, Mohamed‐Slim AlouiniIEEE Open J. Commun. Soc 2023

TL;DR

This paper provides a comprehensive performance analysis of hybrid satellite-terrestrial networks enhanced by Intelligent Reflecting Surfaces (IRS). By comparing two configurations—mounting the IRS on a High-Altitude Platform (HAP) versus placing it on the ground—the authors demonstrate that aerial IRS nodes significantly outperform terrestrial ones, offering a robust path toward achieving the ubiquitous, high-speed connectivity promised by 6G.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

As we move toward the 6G era, the goal is "ubiquitous connectivity"—meaning high-speed internet even in remote, infrastructure-deficient, or disaster-stricken areas. Traditional terrestrial networks can't reach everywhere, leading researchers to look toward Non-Terrestrial Networks (NTNs) involving satellites and High-Altitude Platforms (HAPs).

However, satellite-to-ground links face massive path loss and atmospheric interference. Intelligent Reflecting Surfaces (IRS)—arrays of small, software-controlled elements that reflect electromagnetic waves to "steer" signals—offer a solution to boost signal strength without the high power consumption of traditional relays. The core question this paper tackles is: Where should we put the IRS? Is it better to mount it on the HAP (Aerial IRS) or use it on the ground to reflect signals from a HAP relay (Terrestrial IRS)?

Methods

The authors develop and compare two distinct system models:

  • System Model 1 (Aerial IRS): A satellite sends a signal to an IRS mounted on a HAP, which reflects it directly to a ground user.
  • System Model 2 (Terrestrial IRS): A satellite sends a signal to a HAP acting as a decode-and-forward relay. The HAP then transmits to a ground-based IRS, which reflects the signal to the end user.

To make the analysis realistic, they use sophisticated statistical models for fading: Rician for line-of-sight satellite links, Shadowed Rician for the tricky transition between aerial and terrestrial environments, and Nakagami-$m$ for terrestrial paths.

The researchers derived exact, closed-form mathematical expressions for:

  1. Outage Probability: The likelihood the signal drops below a usable threshold.
  2. Ergodic Rate: The average maximum data rate the system can support.
  3. Average Symbol Error Rate (ASER): Performance across various complex modulation schemes (Square, Rectangular, Cross, and Hexagonal QAM).

Datasets

This is a theoretical and analytical study; therefore, no external datasets were used. The results were validated using extensive Monte-Carlo simulations performed in MATLAB and Mathematica to ensure the derived mathematical formulas matched simulated physical behavior.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Aerial Advantage: The Aerial IRS configuration (SM-1) generally outperforms the Terrestrial IRS setup (SM-2). In the terrestrial model, the system's performance is often bottlenecked by the initial satellite-to-HAP relay link, whereas the aerial IRS acts as a powerful direct "signal mirror."
  • The Power of Scale: Increasing the number of IRS elements ($N$) provides a massive boost. For example, in the aerial model, doubling the number of elements can increase the ergodic rate by approximately 2 bps/Hz.
  • Modulation Matters: The paper highlights that Hexagonal QAM (HQAM) is superior to standard Square QAM for high-speed 6G applications. Because HQAM packs constellation points more efficiently, it achieves a lower error rate for the same amount of transmit power (roughly a 1 dB gain at 1024-QAM).
  • Shadowing Sensitivity: The severity of "shadowing" (obstructions like trees or buildings) drastically shifts the power requirements. Moving from "heavy" to "light" shadowing can result in a transmit power gain of over 10 dB to maintain the same connection quality.

Key Results

  • Transmit Power Gains: For a target outage probability of $10^{-8}$, a system with 150 IRS elements requires roughly 35 dBm less transmit power than a system with only 30 elements.
  • Ergodic Rate: In the aerial IRS model, the system achieved rates ranging from 15 to 25 bps/Hz as the IRS array grew from 30 to 960 elements.
  • Relay vs. IRS: The study confirms that while HAP relays are useful, the "passive" gain provided by a large IRS array can achieve similar or better performance with significantly lower energy costs.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge a few simplifying assumptions that provide avenues for future research:

  • Single Antennas: The current model assumes all nodes (satellite, HAP, user) have a single antenna. Real-world 6G systems will likely use Massive MIMO (multiple antennas).
  • Perfect Phase Control: The analysis assumes the IRS can perfectly shift the phase of incoming waves. In practice, hardware limitations lead to "phase noise" or quantized phase shifts.
  • Static Users: The study focuses on stationary users. Future work could incorporate high-mobility scenarios, such as providing connectivity to high-speed trains or aircraft.

Summary updated

Abstract

With a motive of ubiquitous connectivity over the globe with enhanced spectral efficiency, intelligent reflecting surfaces (IRS) integrated satellite-terrestrial communications is a topic of research interest in an infrastructure-deficient remote terrains. In line with this vision, this paper entails the performance analysis of satellite-terrestrial networks leveraging both aerial and terrestrial IRS nodes, with the support of high altitude platforms over diverse fading channels including shadowed Rician, Rician, and Nakagami-$m$ fading channels. The merits of IRS in enhancing spectral efficiency is analyzed through closed-form expressions of outage probability and ergodic rate. Further, the average symbol error rate analysis for the higher-order quadrature amplitude modulation (QAM) schemes such as hexagonal QAM, rectangular QAM, cross QAM, and square QAM is performed. Practical constraints like antenna gains, path loss, and link fading are considered to characterize the satellite terrestrial links. Finally, a comparison between the high-altitude platforms based IRS node and terrestrial IRS nodes is performed and various insights are drawn under various fading scenarios and path loss conditions. This paper contribute towards understanding and potential implementation of IRS-integrated satellite-terrestrial networks for efficient and reliable communication.
BibTeX
@article{shaik2023performance,
  author = {Parvez Shaik and Kamal Garg and Praveen Kumar Singya and Vimal Bhatia and Mohamed‐Slim Alouini},
  title = {{On Performance of Integrated Satellite HAPS Ground Communication: Aerial IRS Node vs Terrestrial IRS Node}},
  journal = {IEEE Open J. Commun. Soc.},
  year = {2023},
}
Figure