ON-OFF receptive fields in auditory cortex diverge during development and contribute to directional sweep selectivity

Joseph Sollini, Gaëlle Chapuis, Claudia Clopath, Paul ChaddertonNature Communications 2018 · DOI

Abstract

Neurons in the auditory cortex exhibit distinct frequency tuning to the onset (ON) and offset (OFF) of sounds. While this organization is well-documented in adults, its developmental origins and functional significance have remained unclear. This study demonstrates that distinct ON and OFF frequency tuning is largely absent in the immature mouse auditory cortex and emerges through experience-driven Hebbian plasticity. Using computational modeling and pharmacogenetics, the researchers show that the resulting spatial arrangement of receptive fields (RFs) is a primary driver of direction selectivity for frequency-modulated (FM) tone sweeps, independent of cortical inhibition.

The Developmental Puzzle of ON-OFF Tuning

In the adult primary auditory cortex (A1), many neurons respond to both the start and end of a sound. Crucially, the frequency that triggers the ON response is typically offset from the frequency that triggers the OFF response. This study addressed two fundamental questions: does this tuning offset emerge through experience, and does it serve a functional purpose in decoding complex sounds like FM sweeps?

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-disciplinary approach:

  • In Vivo Electrophysiology: Recorded neuronal activity in the A1 of mice at two stages: "Young" (post-hearing onset) and "Adult."
  • Computational Modeling: Developed a feedforward neural network using a standard Hebbian plasticity rule ("neurons that fire together, wire together") to test if alternating sound onsets and offsets drive RF divergence.
  • Pharmacogenetics (DREADDs): Selectively silenced inhibitory parvalbumin-positive (PV+) interneurons to test if lateral inhibition is required for direction selectivity.
  • Linear Regression: Analyzed which neuronal properties (bandwidth, overlap, CF difference) best predict a neuron's Direction Selectivity Index (DSI).

Key Insights: Experience Drives Divergence

The study found that ON and OFF receptive fields start almost perfectly overlapped in young mice. As the animal gains acoustic experience, these fields "push apart."

Developmental shift in ON and OFF receptive field organization from young to adult mice.

The Power of Alternation

The computational model revealed that the natural alternation of sound starting and stopping is sufficient to drive this divergence. Because an onset never occurs simultaneously with an offset at the same frequency, Hebbian learning naturally segregates these inputs into non-overlapping adjacent RFs.

Structural Direction Selectivity

The paper proposes a "summation" model for direction selectivity. If a neuron's ON-tuning is higher than its OFF-tuning, an upward sweep will trigger the OFF-response and then the ON-response in quick succession. This temporal proximity causes the signals to summate, leading to a more vigorous neuronal response compared to a downward sweep.

Key Results

  • Developmental Shift: In young mice, the difference between ON and OFF characteristic frequencies (CF) was centered at 0 octaves. In adults, this shifted to a mode of 0.25 octaves, confirming developmental divergence.
  • Predictive Power: The octave difference between ON and OFF tuning in adults was a strong predictor of the Direction Selectivity Index (DSI) ($r = -0.61$).
Scatter plot showing the correlation between ON and OFF characteristic frequencies (CF) in young (blue) versus adult (grey) mice.
  • Inhibition is Not the Driver: Silencing PV+ neurons increased overall firing rates by ~2.5x but did not abolish direction selectivity. This suggests that selectivity is primarily "baked into" the arrangement of excitatory excitatory inputs rather than being sculpted by inhibition.

Limitations and Future Work

While the feedforward model effectively explains the core phenomenon, it does not capture the full complexity of recurrent cortical circuitry. Future research could explore how other inhibitory cell types, such as somatostatin-expressing neurons, modulate this selectivity, or how enriched versus impoverished acoustic environments during development might alter the divergence of these receptive fields.

Summary updated

Abstract

Neurons in the auditory cortex exhibit distinct frequency tuning to the onset and offset of sounds, but the cause and significance of ON and OFF receptive field (RF) organisation are not understood. Here we demonstrate that distinct ON and OFF frequency tuning is largely absent in immature mouse auditory cortex and is thus a consequence of cortical development. Simulations using a novel implementation of a standard Hebbian plasticity model show that the natural alternation of sound onset and offset is sufficient for the formation of non-overlapping adjacent ON and OFF RFs in cortical neurons. Our model predicts that ON/OFF RF arrangement contributes towards direction selectivity to frequency-modulated tone sweeps, which we confirm by neuronal recordings. These data reveal that a simple and universally accepted learning rule can explain the organisation of ON and OFF RFs and direction selectivity in the developing auditory cortex.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{sollini2018off,
  author = {Joseph Sollini and Gaëlle Chapuis and Claudia Clopath and Paul Chadderton},
  title = {{ON-OFF receptive fields in auditory cortex diverge during development and contribute to directional sweep selectivity}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.1038/s41467-018-04548-3},
}
Figure