On energy-efficient trap coverage in wireless sensor networks

Jiming Chen, Junkun Li, Shibo He, Tian He, Yu Gu, Youxian SunACM Trans. Sens. Networks 2013 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper tackles the challenge of maximizing the operational lifetime of wireless sensor networks (WSNs) by introducing "trap coverage," a novel concept that balances coverage quality with energy efficiency. They propose an algorithm, Trap Cover Optimization (TCO), to intelligently schedule sensor activation, achieving significant energy savings and extending network lifetime compared to existing methods.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Wireless Sensor Networks (WSNs) are increasingly deployed for various applications, but their widespread adoption is hindered by the high cost of deploying a massive number of sensors and the limited energy resources of individual nodes. While "full coverage" (ensuring every point in the monitored area is covered) is ideal, it's often impractical for large-scale deployments. "Partial coverage" offers a solution by allowing coverage holes, but it can lead to arbitrarily large holes, making it unsuitable for applications requiring guaranteed detection within a certain distance.

This paper addresses this by introducing "trap coverage," which allows coverage holes but limits their size by defining the maximum diameter of any hole. This ensures that a target, even if it enters a hole, will be detected within a predictable maximum distance. The core problem then becomes how to schedule sensor activation to maintain this D-trap coverage while minimizing energy consumption and maximizing the network's overall lifetime, especially in randomly deployed WSNs where optimal deployment is not guaranteed.

Methods

The paper proposes a novel algorithm called Trap Cover Optimization (TCO) to solve the Minimum Weight Trap Cover Problem. This problem aims to select a subset of sensors that provides D-trap coverage with the minimum total weight, where sensor weights are inversely proportional to their residual energy (prioritizing sensors with more energy).

TCO operates in two main steps:

  1. Minimum Weight Sensor Cover (MSC) Initialization: First, it finds a minimum weight sensor cover (C') that provides full coverage to the entire region. This is a standard problem in WSNs.
  2. Iterative Sensor Removal: Then, TCO iteratively removes sensors from C' to form the final trap cover (C). The key innovation here is the criterion for removal. Instead of simply removing sensors with the lowest weights, TCO considers a metric called $D_\psi(i)$, which estimates the potential increase in the largest coverage hole diameter if sensor $i$ is removed. Sensors are prioritized for removal based on a normalized weight $G(i) = w_i / (1 + \alpha D_\psi(i))$, which balances residual energy and the potential impact on coverage holes. A sensor is only removed if its removal does not cause the maximum coverage hole diameter to exceed the threshold $D$.

This approach ensures that sensors with lower residual energy or those that have a minimal impact on coverage hole sizes are preferentially deactivated, thus balancing energy consumption and extending network lifetime.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The evaluation is based on extensive simulations using randomly deployed sensor networks with specified parameters.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Trap Coverage as a Practical Trade-off: Trap coverage offers a practical middle ground between full coverage and simple partial coverage, providing a quantifiable guarantee on detection performance (maximum travel distance within a hole) while saving significant energy.
  • The Importance of $D_\psi(i)$: The metric $D_\psi(i)$ is crucial. It quantifies how much removing a sensor might worsen the coverage quality (increase hole diameter). This allows TCO to make more informed decisions about which sensors to deactivate, going beyond simple energy-based weighting.
  • Global Optimization vs. Local Heuristics: TCO's two-step approach (initial full cover, then iterative removal) allows for a more globally optimized trap cover compared to purely greedy or local methods.
  • Energy Efficiency Through Balanced Deactivation: By prioritizing the removal of sensors with low residual energy and low impact on coverage hole size, TCO effectively balances energy consumption across the network, leading to a longer overall lifetime.
  • NP-Hardness of the Problem: The Minimum Weight Trap Cover Problem is formally proven to be NP-hard, underscoring the need for efficient approximation algorithms like TCO.

Key Results

  • Theoretical Guarantee: The paper proves that TCO's performance is bounded by $O(\rho)$, where $\rho$ is the sensor density. This means the algorithm's approximation ratio is related to how densely the sensors are deployed, offering better guarantees for large-scale networks.
  • Simulation Performance: Extensive simulations demonstrate that TCO significantly outperforms a naive trap coverage approach (Naive-Trap) and a full coverage heuristic (Greedy-MSC) in terms of network lifetime.
  • TCO achieves at least 14% better energy efficiency than the state-of-the-art solution (Naive-Trap).
  • The simulations show TCO consistently activates fewer sensors per time slot, leading to lower energy consumption.
  • TCO also demonstrates a higher average residual energy for activated sensors, indicating a more balanced energy usage.
  • The network lifetime achieved by TCO is consistently longer across various scenarios (varying sensor count, initial energy, and diameter threshold).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Centralized Algorithm: TCO is presented as a centralized algorithm. While effective, implementing it in a large-scale WSN would require a central controller, which might be a bottleneck or single point of failure. Future work could explore distributed versions of TCO.
  • Homogeneous Sensors: The paper assumes homogeneous sensors with identical sensing ranges and initial energy. Extending the algorithm to handle heterogeneous sensors would be a valuable next step.
  • Simplified Network Model: The use of a disk model for sensing regions is a simplification. Real-world sensing regions can be irregular. While the authors argue the disk model captures essential properties, practical applications might require more complex models.
  • Communication Costs: The paper assumes communication costs for scheduling and information dissemination are negligible. In real-world scenarios, these costs can be significant and should be considered in future research.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{chen2013energy,
  author = {Jiming Chen and Junkun Li and Shibo He and Tian He and Yu Gu and Youxian Sun},
  title = {{On energy-efficient trap coverage in wireless sensor networks}},
  journal = {ACM Trans. Sens. Networks},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.1145/2529973},
}
Figure