On deterministic nature of the intermittent geodesic acoustic mode observed in L- mode discharge near tokamak edge, Part I Zonal flow driven by ion temperature gradient turbulence

Z. Y. Liu, Y. Z. Zhang, S. M. Mahajan, A. D. Liu, T. Xie, Chi Zhou, Tao Lan, Jinlin Xie, Haoxuan Li, G. Zhuang, W. D. LiuarXiv 2020 · arXiv

Abstract

Through a carefully designed numerical experiment, we demonstrate that a transition between two distinct phases of energy concentration in a zonal flow-drift wave system (caviton and instanton) may play a key role in the intermittent excitation of geodesic acoustic mode (GAM) that are observed in tokamaks. The two energy structures - the caviton, a slowly breathing spatial local structure of negative energy, and the instanton, a fine radial structure of short lifetime in rapid propagation, were recently identified; the preceding work is based on the micro-turbulence associated with ion temperature gradient (ITG) mode, and slab-based phenomenological model of zonal flow. When toroidal effect are introduced into the system, two branches of zonal flow emerge: the torus-modified low frequency zonal flow (TLFZF), and GAM, necessitating a unified exploration of GAM and TLFZF. Indeed, we observe that the transition (decay) from the caviton to instanton is triggered by a rapid zero-crossing of radial group velocity of drift wave and is found to be strongly correlated with the GAM onset; it happens if and only if the intensity of TLFZF is above a certain level. Many features peculiar to intermittent GAMs, observed in real machines, are thus identified in the numerical experiment.

Introduction

In the quest for clean fusion energy, tokamaks use magnetic fields to confine hot plasma. However, turbulence often causes energy to leak out. "Zonal flows" act like planetary jet streams in the plasma, helping to suppress this turbulence and improve confinement. One specific high-frequency zonal flow is the Geodesic Acoustic Mode (GAM).

Experimentally, GAMs are elusive: they do not stay on continuously. Instead, they appear in short, seemingly random bursts lasting only a few milliseconds. While numerical simulations have replicated this "intermittency," the underlying physical mechanism remained a mystery. This paper aims to bridge that gap by providing a theoretical framework that explains both the sudden onset and the radial propagation of these plasma waves.

Methods

The researchers developed a unified theoretical-computational pathway that integrates two types of zonal flows: the torus-modified low-frequency zonal flow (TLFZF) and the higher-frequency GAM.

  • Theoretical Foundation: They utilized the Braginskii two-fluid equations, extending them from "cold ion" models to include "warm ion" effects (Finite Larmor Radius corrections).
  • Coupled Equations: They derived a set of three interconnected equations describing the zonal flow, the sound wave (the precursor to the GAM), and the energy of the background micro-turbulence (specifically Ion Temperature Gradient or ITG modes).
  • Numerical Simulation: The system was solved using a 2nd-order Crank-Nicolson method. They compared simulations of a single "rational surface" (a specific magnetic layer) against models with multiple coupled surfaces to observe how complexity emerges. Numerical experiments used specific plasma parameters from shot #141958 of the DIII-D tokamak.

Results

The Instanton Trigger

The core discovery is that GAM bursts are triggered by a phase transition. When the radial group velocity of background drift waves crosses zero, a stable energy structure (a "caviton") decays into a fast-moving "instanton." This pulse induces a resonance that kicks off a GAM burst. This transition is found to be strongly correlated with the GAM onset and occurs only if the intensity of the TLFZF is above a certain threshold.

Figure 1: Visualization of the energy concentration structure in the zonal flow-drift wave system, showing the localized nature of the energy pulse in a toroidal cross-section.

Deterministic Intermittency

The authors argue that GAM intermittency is not truly random but deterministic. The apparent randomness seen in experiments arises from the asynchronous triggering and overlapping of GAMs across multiple magnetic layers (rational surfaces). Simulating a single magnetic layer produced regular, periodic bursts. However, coupling 11 layers together transformed these into the irregular, intermittent patterns observed in real tokamak discharges.

Temporal Matching and Propagation

The simulated GAM bursting period (~4ms) aligns closely with experimental observations from machines like ASDEX-U and T-10, which typically report periods of 1–5ms. Furthermore, GAM propagation is highly correlated with the motion of these triggering instantons. The study shows that the direction of wave propagation (phase vs. group velocity) depends on the sign of the plasma's dispersive coefficient, providing a new way to interpret experimental signals.

Conclusion

This work successfully demonstrates that TLFZF and GAM are two branches of the same unified zonal flow system. The transition from caviton to instanton provides a deterministic explanation for the intermittent nature of GAMs. Future work will address the feedback of zonal flows on turbulence (shear suppression) and explore the role of electron drift waves in Part II of this study.

Summary updated

Abstract

Through a carefully designed numerical experiment, we demonstrate that a transition between two distinct phases of energy concentration in a zonal flow-drift wave system (caviton and instanton) may play a key role in the intermittent excitation of geodesic acoustic mode (GAM) that are observed in tokamaks. The two energy structures - the caviton, a slowly breathing spatial local structure of negative energy, and the instanton, a fine radial structure of short lifetime in rapid propagation, were recently identified in [Y. Z. Zhang, Z. Y. Liu, T. Xie, S. M. Mahajan, and J. Liu, Physics of Plasmas 24, 122304 (2017)]; the preceding work is based on the micro-turbulence associated with ion temperature gradient (ITG) mode, and slab-based phenomenological model of zonal flow. When toroidal effect are introduced into the system, two branches of zonal flow emerge: the torus-modified low frequency zonal flow (TLFZF), and GAM, necessitating a unified exploration of GAM and TLFZF. Indeed, we observe that the transition (decay) from the caviton to instanton is triggered by a rapid zero-crossing of radial group velocity of drift wave and is found to be strongly correlated with the GAM onset; it happens if and only if the intensity of TLFZF is above a certain level. Many features peculiar to intermittent GAMs, observed in real machines, are thus identified in the numerical experiment; the results will be displayed in figures and in a movie. Since one cannot make a foolproof case that the experimentally observed zonal flows must originate in ITG driven micro-turbulence (Appendix A), we have also explored the possibility that this phenomenon could be caused by electron drift waves, instead; the latter will make part II of this work.
BibTeX
@misc{liu2020deterministic,
  author = {Z. Y. Liu and Y. Z. Zhang and S. M. Mahajan and A. D. Liu and T. Xie and Chi Zhou and Tao Lan and Jinlin Xie and Haoxuan Li and G. Zhuang and W. D. Liu},
  title = {{On deterministic nature of the intermittent geodesic acoustic mode observed in L- mode discharge near tokamak edge, Part I Zonal flow driven by ion temperature gradient turbulence}},
  year = {2020},
  eprint = {2007.00250},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2007.00250},
}
Figure