On Consensusability of Linear Interconnected Multiagent Systems and Simultaneous Stabilization

Mustafa Sahin Turan, Liang Xu, Giancarlo Ferrari-TrecateIEEE Trans. Control. Netw. Syst 2022 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper tackles the challenge of achieving consensus in multi-agent systems (MASs) where agents are not only connected via a communication network but also physically coupled. The authors establish a link between this "consensusability" and the problem of simultaneously stabilizing multiple linear systems, proposing a novel linear programming approach to verify this. Their findings suggest that weaker physical connections and denser communication/physical networks are beneficial for achieving consensus.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In many real-world systems, like power grids or microgrids, individual components (agents) are not just communicating information but are also physically interconnected. This physical coupling introduces complexities that traditional MAS consensusability analysis, which typically assumes only communication links, doesn't account for. The paper addresses how to determine if such "Linear Interconnected Multi-Agent Systems" (LIMASs) can reach a state where all agents' states converge to a common value, despite these physical interactions. This is crucial for ensuring coordinated behavior and stability in these complex systems.

Methods

The core of the paper's contribution lies in reframing the consensusability problem for LIMASs. They show that it's equivalent to a "simultaneous stabilization" problem for a set of linear time-invariant (LTI) systems.

  • Simultaneous Stabilization: The authors introduce a novel linear programming (LP) based test for verifying if a group of LTI systems can be stabilized by a single controller. This is a significant improvement over existing methods that often rely on more computationally intensive convex or non-convex programming.
  • Consensusability Conditions: They derive several conditions for LIMAS consensusability:
  • A sufficient condition based on the LP test for simultaneous stabilization.
  • Algebraic sufficient conditions, particularly for scalar subsystems and when physical coupling is proportional to the system dynamics.
  • Necessary conditions that highlight factors hindering consensus.
  • Mathematical Framework: The analysis involves algebraic graph theory (Laplacian matrices for physical and communication graphs) and linear system theory (Schur stability, controllability). They also leverage concepts like the average state and state deviation to simplify the system dynamics.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper uses simulated systems based on mathematical models of supercapacitors and DC microgrids for validation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Physical Coupling Matters: The paper clearly demonstrates that physical interconnections significantly impact consensusability, often making it harder to achieve compared to systems with only communication links.
  • Link to Simultaneous Stabilization: The crucial insight is the direct relationship between LIMAS consensusability and the simultaneous stabilization of multiple LTI systems. This connection allows for the application of existing (and novel) techniques from one field to the other.
  • LP for Stability: The development of a linear programming test for simultaneous stabilization is a key methodological contribution, offering a more efficient way to check for stability across multiple systems.
  • Favorable Conditions: The research highlights that weak physical couplings and densely connected physical and communication graphs are generally favorable for achieving consensus in LIMASs. This provides practical design guidelines.
  • Scalar Subsystems as a Testbed: Analyzing scalar subsystems first provides valuable intuition and simpler conditions that are often necessary and sufficient when physical coupling is absent.

Key Results

The paper presents several theoretical results:

  • Sufficient Condition: A linear programming formulation is proposed to check for consensusability, which is shown to be more computationally efficient than prior methods.
  • Necessary and Sufficient Conditions: Algebraic conditions are derived for scalar subsystems, showing that consensusability depends on the interplay between physical coupling strength (related to eigenvalues of the physical Laplacian), communication graph connectivity (eigenvalues of the communication Laplacian), and the system's inherent dynamics.
  • Simulation Validation: The theoretical results are validated through simulations of:
  • A network of identical supercapacitors, demonstrating voltage consensus.
  • A DC microgrid, showing voltage regulation and consensus. These simulations confirm the theoretical predictions regarding the influence of physical and communication graph structures.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Commuting Laplacians: For the general case of vector subsystems, the analysis relies on the assumption that the physical and communication graph Laplacians commute. The authors acknowledge that removing this assumption is a significant direction for future work.
  • Output Synchronization: The paper focuses on state consensus. Extending the analysis to output synchronization for LIMASs is suggested as a future research avenue.
  • More Complex Dynamics: The current work focuses on linear systems. Investigating consensusability for nonlinear LIMASs would be a natural extension.
  • Worst-Case Scenario: The necessary conditions derived are based on worst-case scenarios of eigenvalue pairings, which can introduce conservatism.

Summary updated

Abstract

Consensusability of multiagent systems (MASs) certifies the existence of a distributed controller capable of driving the states of each subsystem to a consensus value. We study the consensusability of linear interconnected MASs (LIMASs), where, as in several real-world applications, subsystems are physically coupled. We show that consensusability is related to the simultaneous stabilizability of multiple LTI systems, and present a novel sufficient condition in form of a linear program for verifying this property. We also derive several necessary and sufficient consensusability conditions for LIMASs in terms of parameters of the subsystem matrices and the eigenvalues of the physical and communication graph Laplacians. The results show that weak physical couplings among subsystems and densely connected physical and communication graphs are favorable for consensusability. Finally, we validate our results through simulations of networks of supercapacitors and dc microgrids.
BibTeX
@article{turan2022consensusability,
  author = {Mustafa Sahin Turan and Liang Xu and Giancarlo Ferrari-Trecate},
  title = {{On Consensusability of Linear Interconnected Multiagent Systems and Simultaneous Stabilization}},
  journal = {IEEE Trans. Control. Netw. Syst.},
  year = {2022},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=mfQmjb8Fk1},
}
Figure