On computational fluid dynamics models for sinonasal drug transport: Relevance of nozzle subtraction and nasal vestibular dilation

Saikat Basu, Dennis O. Frank‐Ito, Julia S. KimbellInternational Journal for Numerical Methods in Biomedical Engineering 2017 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Generating anatomically realistic 3D models of the human sinonasal cavity for numerical investigations of sprayed drug transport presents a host of methodological ambiguities. For example, subject-specific radiographic images used for 3D reconstructions typically exclude spray bottles. Subtracting a bottle contour from the 3D airspace and dilating the anterior nasal vestibule for nozzle placement augment the complexity of model building. This study explored how essential these steps are to adequately simulate nasal airflow and identify optimal delivery conditions for intranasal sprays, specifically focusing on particle deposition in the maxillary sinus for chronic rhinosinusitis treatment. The models were reconstructed from post-surgery CT scans of a 39-year-old male. We hypothesized that posterior airflow transport and particle deposition trends would not be radically affected by nozzle subtraction and vestibular dilation due to the stability of laminar-viscous modeling. The study involved one base model and two derived models with nozzle contours. Results showed that similar release points facilitated improved maxillary deposition in all three cases, suggesting functional redundancy of nozzle insertion in 3D numerical models for identifying optimal spray release locations.

Introduction

Chronic rhinosinusitis (CRS) is a debilitating condition for millions, often requiring topical drug delivery via nasal sprays. To improve the efficacy of these treatments, researchers increasingly turn to Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) to predict where medicine actually deposits within the complex sinonasal architecture. However, a significant bottleneck exists in the model-building process: standard clinical CT scans do not include the spray bottle or the physical dilation of the nostril that occurs during use.

Manually "subtracting" a nozzle from the digital airspace and simulating the way a nostril stretches (vestibular dilation) adds significant complexity and potential for error. This study investigates whether this extra modeling effort actually changes the clinical outcome—specifically, whether the presence of a nozzle significantly alters which spray angles and positions best reach the maxillary sinus.

Anatomical Reconstruction and Methodology

The study utilized a patient-specific dataset consisting of 270 CT slices from a 39-year-old Caucasian male with a history of CRS and bilateral functional endoscopic sinus surgery (FESS). This high-fidelity reconstruction served as the foundation for the computational models.

3D reconstruction of the sinonasal cavity showing the target maxillary sinuses.

To test the impact of nozzle inclusion, the researchers developed three distinct 3D models:

  1. Model I (Base): A standard reconstruction with no nozzle.
  2. Model II: Included a "subtracted" nozzle contour with a dorsal (upward) inclination.
  3. Model III: Included a nozzle contour with a ventral (downward) inclination.

To create realistic nozzle-integrated models, the team 3D-printed the patient's anterior nasal cavity in a flexible material, inserted a physical nozzle, and re-scanned the assembly to capture authentic tissue dilation.

Comparison of the base model (Model I) and nozzle-subtracted models (Models II and III).

Steady-state laminar-viscous CFD simulations were performed using ANSYS Fluent. The team tracked nearly 344,000 virtual droplets (modeled after Flonase™) across 27 "clinically safe" release points using Lagrangian particle tracking to identify conditions that maximized Target Site Particle Deposition (TSPD) in the left maxillary sinus.

Key Insights and Results

Laminar Stability and Flow Consistency

The researchers hypothesized that because resting nasal airflow is predominantly laminar, it would be relatively insensitive to "inlet perturbations" like a nozzle. The results confirmed this: while the nozzle creates local turbulence and stagnation zones near the nostril, the downstream flow into the sinuses remains remarkably consistent across all models.

Robustness of the "Sweet Spot"

A critical finding was that the "optimal zone" for spray release—the specific coordinates and angles yielding the best sinus penetration—remained localized to the same tiny 2mm-by-4.5mm area across all three models. Spearman’s rank-order test showed a high correlation in deposition patterns between the base model and the nozzle models, with coefficients ($R$) ranging from 0.767 to 0.929 ($p < 0.00001$).

Absolute vs. Relative Values

While the relative ranking of release points was consistent, the absolute amount of medicine reaching the sinus varied. Model I showed a peak deposit five times higher than Model II, likely because the nozzle in Model II caused more particles to impact the anterior walls of the nose immediately. However, for the purpose of identifying where to aim a spray, the complex step of modeling nozzle insertion appears to be functionally redundant.

Conclusion and Limitations

This study demonstrates that for identifying optimal spray release locations, standard CT-based reconstructions without nozzle subtraction are sufficient. This justifies the use of simpler, faster-to-build models in clinical engineering workflows.

However, several limitations remain. The study utilized a steady-state airflow assumption, which ignores the dynamics of a full breathing cycle. Additionally, the models assume rigid walls that "trap" particles instantly, ignoring the potential redistribution of drugs by mucociliary clearance. As a methods-focused study on a single subject, future work should validate these findings across a larger cohort with varying nasal geometries to ensure the redundancy of the nozzle holds true across diverse populations.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Generating anatomically realistic 3‐dimensional (3D) models of the human sinonasal cavity for numerical investigations of sprayed drug transport presents a host of methodological ambiguities. For example, subject‐specific radiographic images used for 3D reconstructions typically exclude spray bottles. Subtracting a bottle contour from the 3D airspace and dilating the anterior nasal vestibule for nozzle placement augment the complexity of model building. So we explored the question: how essential are these steps to adequately simulate nasal airflow and identify the optimal delivery conditions for intranasal sprays? In particular, we focused on particle deposition patterns in the maxillary sinus, a critical target site for chronic rhinosinusitis. The models were reconstructed from postsurgery computed tomography scans for a 39‐year‐old Caucasian male, with chronic rhinosinusitis history. Inspiratory airflow patterns during resting breathing are reliably tracked through computational fluid dynamics–based steady‐state laminar‐viscous modeling, and such regimes portray relative lack of sensitivity to inlet perturbations. Consequently, we hypothesized that the posterior airflow transport and the particle deposition trends should not be radically affected by the nozzle subtraction and vestibular dilation. The study involved 1 base model and 2 derived models; the latter 2 with nozzle contours (2 different orientations) subtracted from the dilated anterior segment of the left vestibule. We analyzed spray transport in the left maxillary sinus for multiple release conditions. Similar release points, localized on an approximately 2 mm × 4.5 mm contour, facilitated improved maxillary deposition in all 3 test cases. This suggests functional redundancy of nozzle insertion in a 3D numerical model for identifying the optimal spray release locations.
BibTeX
@article{basu2017computational,
  author = {Saikat Basu and Dennis O. Frank‐Ito and Julia S. Kimbell},
  title = {{On computational fluid dynamics models for sinonasal drug transport: Relevance of nozzle subtraction and nasal vestibular dilation}},
  journal = {International Journal for Numerical Methods in Biomedical Engineering},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1002/cnm.2946},
}
Figure