Abstract: Finding string backgrounds with de Sitter spacetime, where all approximations and corrections are controlled, is an open problem. We revisit the search for de Sitter solutions in the classical regime for specific type IIB supergravity compactifications on group manifolds, an under-explored corner of the landscape that offers an interesting testing ground for swampland conjectures. While the supergravity de Sitter solutions we obtain numerically are ambiguous in terms of their classicality, we find an analytic scaling that makes four out of six compactification radii, as well as the overall volume, arbitrarily large. This potentially provides parametric control over corrections. If we could show that these solutions, or others to be found, are fully classical, they would constitute a counterexample to conjectures stating that asymptotic de Sitter solutions do not exist. We discuss this point in great detail.
Introduction
In the quest to reconcile string theory with the observed expansion of our universe, identifying stable de Sitter (dS) solutions remains a primary challenge. While string theory naturally accommodates Anti-de Sitter (AdS) spaces, dS solutions are notoriously elusive. The "de Sitter Swampland Conjecture" suggests that dS vacua cannot exist within a controlled classical regime of string theory. To challenge this, researchers must find solutions where all approximations—such as ignoring quantum loops or string-scale effects—are under strict parametric control, allowing the extra dimensions to be made arbitrarily large and the string coupling arbitrarily small.
A recent study by David Andriot and Fabian Ruehle, published in JHEP, explores an under-studied region of the string landscape to identify mechanisms that might preserve dS solutions against these conjectures.
Methodology and Setup
The authors focus on Type IIB supergravity compactified on six-dimensional group manifolds, specifically solvmanifolds. These geometries feature complex fibration structures that provide mathematical "loopholes" to existing no-go theorems that typically assume simpler geometries like tori. The setup involves specific arrangements of O5-planes and D5-branes across the internal dimensions.
To navigate this complex parameter space, the authors utilized numerical optimization techniques, including constrained supergravity searches via Mathematica and TensorFlow. They analyzed the MSSS (Minkowski/de Sitter/anti-de Sitter) solution database to find points that satisfy both the 10D supergravity equations of motion and the physical requirements for a classical string background.
Key Insights: The $\gamma$-Scaling
The most significant finding is a family of analytic scalings, termed $\gamma$-scaling. The researchers demonstrated that if a dS solution is found, it can be scaled such that four of the six internal radii and the total compactification volume grow as $\gamma \to \infty$. This provides the "parametric control" necessary to suppress quantum corrections, potentially validating the classical approximation in the large-volume limit.
However, a persistent challenge identified in the numerical solutions is the "substringy radius problem." Two of the six radii consistently remain smaller than the fundamental string length ($l_s$). The authors argue that because these radii normalize non-closed forms, they might not correspond to physical cycles, which could protect the solution from the stringy corrections that typically invalidate such small-scale geometries.
Results and Limitations
- Solution 29: The study identified a new dS solution with a string coupling $g_s \approx 0.53$, reinforcing the existence of these vacua in Type IIB theory.
- Lack of Scale Separation: Quantitatively, the Kaluza-Klein mass scale ($m_{KK}$) scales identically to the 4D Ricci scalar ($\mathcal{R}_4$), suggesting that the extra dimensions are not clearly separated from the 4D physics scale ($m_{KK}^2 / \mathcal{R}_4 \sim 1$).
- Stability: The solutions found are currently tachyonic (unstable). While they do not represent permanent stable vacua, they could potentially describe "quintessence" models of dark energy.
Conclusion
By exploring solvmanifolds and the $\gamma$-scaling mechanism, this work suggests that the "Swampland" may contain habitable islands for de Sitter solutions. While issues regarding stability and backreaction from localized sources remain, the identification of parametric volume control is a major step toward a fully controlled classical string background.
Reference: Andriot, D., & Ruehle, F. (2024). On classical de Sitter solutions and parametric control. JHEP06(2024)101. arXiv:2403.07065
Summary updated