On a Generalized Notion of Mistake Bounds

Sanjay Jain, Arun SharmaCOLT 1999 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces constructive ordinals as a generalized measure for mistakes in on-line learning, extending the model's applicability to more complex concept classes like pattern languages and logic programs. They establish a crucial link between this generalized mistake bound model and the traditional "identification in the limit" framework, showing they are equivalent under certain conditions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The standard on-line learning model evaluates algorithms by counting the number of mistakes they make. However, this model is limited when dealing with expressive concept classes like pattern languages or logic programs because the number of mistakes can be unbounded or require an infinite number of mind changes. Traditional mistake bounds are restricted to natural numbers, which are insufficient for these complex scenarios. The paper aims to overcome this limitation by introducing a more powerful way to measure mistakes using constructive ordinals, thereby enabling the analysis of learnability for richer and more practical concept classes.

Methods

The core innovation is the use of constructive ordinals as mistake bounds. Instead of just counting mistakes with natural numbers, the paper proposes using ordinals (like $\omega$, $\omega \times 2$, $\omega^2$, etc.) to represent mistake bounds. This allows for a more nuanced measure, where an ordinal bound like $\omega \times n$ signifies that a learner might need to revise its mistake bound $n$ times.

A key technical contribution is establishing a sufficient condition for learnability with an ordinal mistake bound. This condition is based on a topological property of language classes called "effective bounded finite thickness." Intuitively, this property relates to how many minimal formal systems are needed to define a given set of examples.

Furthermore, the paper provides a characterization of learnability in the on-line mistake bound model in terms of the identification in the limit framework. They show that classes of languages learnable with an ordinal mistake bound $\alpha$ are precisely those learnable in the limit from both positive and negative data by a Popperian, consistent learner with at most $\alpha$ mind changes. This bridges two important learning paradigms.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Ordinals as a richer mistake measure: The paper demonstrates that constructive ordinals provide a more expressive and flexible way to quantify mistakes in on-line learning, moving beyond the limitations of natural numbers.
  • Bridging two learning models: The equivalence established between the generalized on-line mistake bound model and identification in the limit is a significant theoretical contribution, offering a unified perspective on learning.
  • Effective bounded finite thickness as a key property: This topological property emerges as a crucial condition for learnability with ordinal mistake bounds, providing a concrete criterion for analyzing concept classes.
  • Generalizing learnability analysis: The framework developed allows for the analysis of complex concept classes like unions of pattern languages and logic programs, which were previously difficult to handle with traditional mistake bound models.

Key Results

  • The paper shows that classes of languages with effective bounded finite thickness can be learned with an ordinal mistake bound of the form $\omega \times m$.
  • As a consequence, unions of up to $n$ pattern languages and length-bounded linear logic programs are shown to be learnable with mistake bounds of $\omega \times n$.
  • A characterization theorem proves that a class of languages is learnable with an ordinal mistake bound $\alpha$ if and only if it can be identified in the limit by a Popperian, consistent learner with at most $\alpha$ mind changes.

Limitations and Future Work

The paper focuses on specific types of logic programs (linear, linearly-covering, linearly-moded) and pattern languages. While the framework is general, applying it to other complex concept classes might require further investigation. The authors also mention that the bound on the body length of clauses is crucial for the effective bounded finite thickness property in logic programs, suggesting that relaxing this might require different analytical tools. Future work could explore the learnability of classes without these restrictions and investigate other topological properties that might lead to similar learnability results.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{jain1999generalized,
  author = {Sanjay Jain and Arun Sharma},
  title = {{On a Generalized Notion of Mistake Bounds}},
  booktitle = {Conference on Learning Theory},
  year = {1999},
  doi = {10.1145/307400.307450},
}

Loading related content...

Figure