OMEGA: a software tool for the management, analysis, and dissemination of intracellular trafficking data that incorporates motion type classification and quality control

Alessandro Rigano, Vanni Galli, Jasmine Clark, Lara Pereira, Loris Grossi, Jeremy Luban, Raffaello Giulietti, Tiziano Leidi, Eric Hunter, Mario Valle, Ivo F. Sbalzarini, Caterina Strambio‐De‐CastilliabioRxiv 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

OMEGA is a new, open-source software tool that addresses the challenge of managing, analyzing, and sharing complex intracellular particle tracking data. It integrates image import, particle tracking, motion analysis, and quality control, while meticulously tracking data provenance to ensure reproducibility and facilitate meta-analysis across different labs.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding the dynamics of intracellular processes, like viral infection or vesicular trafficking, relies heavily on tracking the movement of tiny particles within living cells using time-lapse microscopy. However, the data generated by different research groups is often incompatible due to varying methodologies, making it difficult to compare results or perform large-scale meta-analyses. This lack of standardization and integrated data management hinders scientific progress. The authors identify a critical need for a system that can handle high-throughput data, automate analysis workflows, ensure data provenance, and facilitate quality control, thereby enabling robust and reproducible research.

Methods

OMEGA is a Java-based, cross-platform application designed to streamline the entire particle tracking workflow. Key features include:

  • Data Import: Integrates with OMERO (Open Microscopy Environment Remote Objects) and other data sources to import images and metadata.
  • Particle Tracking: Implements algorithms for detecting and linking particles to form trajectories, offering flexibility in algorithm selection.
  • Trajectory Management: Allows for editing and segmentation of trajectories to handle non-uniform motion.
  • Motion Analysis: Computes various tracking measures (Intensity, Mobility, Velocity, Diffusivity) to quantify particle behavior.
  • Motion Type Classification: Classifies trajectories into distinct motion types (e.g., confined, diffusive, directed) using phase space analysis of ODC and SMSS.
  • Quality Control: Includes SNR estimation to assess image quality and its impact on tracking.
  • Data Provenance and Standardization: Automatically harvests and stores metadata, creating a persistent link between raw data and analysis results, adhering to MIAPTE (Minimum Information About Particle Tracking Experiments) guidelines.
  • User Interface: Provides an intuitive graphical user interface (GUI) to simplify complex operations.

Datasets

The paper utilizes both simulated and real-life datasets for validation and demonstration:

  • Simulated Datasets: Used for benchmarking particle tracking algorithms and validating motion type classification. These datasets are described as "uniform artificial trajectories of known mobility" and "scenario IV, infecting viral particles; SNR = 7; low particle density" from Chenouard et al. (2014).
  • Real-life Datasets:
    • Viral particle trafficking in living human cells (Clark et al., 2013; Pereira et al., 2012).
  • M-PMV (Mason-Pfizer Monkey Virus) Gag-containing viral particles during M-PMV viral assembly in rhesus macaque cells, with and without Nocodazole treatment.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Power of Integration: The core idea is that integrating data management, analysis, and quality control into a single platform is crucial for overcoming the current fragmentation in particle tracking research.
  • Provenance is Paramount: Automatically tracking data provenance is not just a nice-to-have; it's essential for ensuring reproducibility and enabling meaningful comparisons across experiments and labs.
  • Standardization Drives Collaboration: Adhering to established (and proposed) standards like OME-XML and MIAPTE is key to building a collaborative ecosystem for particle tracking data.
  • Motion Type Classification is More Than Just Speed: Moving beyond simple speed measurements, OMEGA's approach to classifying motion types based on diffusivity and scaling spectra provides a richer understanding of particle behavior and interactions.

Key Results

  • OMEGA successfully imports image data and metadata from OMERO.
  • It automates the particle tracking and motion analysis workflow, reducing manual effort.
  • The system effectively tracks data provenance, linking raw images to final analysis results.
  • Motion type classification, based on ODC and SMSS, showed excellent agreement with expected values for both simulated and real-life data.
  • The tool was demonstrated to be effective in analyzing both standardized benchmarking datasets and complex real-life imaging data, including the effect of Nocodazole treatment on viral particle trafficking.
  • The use of OMEGA significantly increased the throughput of systematic motion analysis experiments compared to individual tools.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Interactive Workflow: At the time of writing, many workflows are interactive, requiring user supervision. Future releases aim to introduce batch processing for entire image datasets.
  • Algorithm Integration: While OMEGA is designed for extensibility, the integration of additional particle detection, linking, and tracking plugins is planned for future releases.
  • Automated Segmentation: The current trajectory segmentation is manual. Automated methods are planned for future integration.
  • Additional Features: Further features to augment phase-space clustering, such as directional change and anisotropy measures, are easily implementable and planned for future releases.
  • Error Estimation: While OMEGA incorporates theoretical and empirical methods for error estimation, the authors acknowledge that the effect of positional uncertainty and sample size on motion type estimates can still be challenging to predict theoretically.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract MOTIVATION Particle tracking coupled with time-lapse microscopy is critical for understanding the dynamics of intracellular processes of clinical importance. Spurred on by advances in the spatiotemporal resolution of microscopy and automated computational methods, this field is increasingly amenable to multi-dimensional high-throughput data collection schemes (Snijder et al., 2012). Typically, complex particle tracking datasets generated by individual laboratories are produced with incompatible methodologies that preclude comparison to each other. There is therefore an unmet need for data management systems that facilitate data standardization, meta-analysis, and structured data dissemination. The integration of analysis, visualization, and quality control capabilities into such systems would eliminate the need for manual transfer of data to diverse downstream analysis tools. At the same time, it would lay the foundation for shared trajectory data, particle tracking, and motion analysis standards. RESULTS Here, we present Open Microscopy Environment inteGrated Analysis (OMEGA), a cross-platform data management, analysis, and visualization system, for particle tracking data, with particular emphasis on results from viral and vesicular trafficking experiments. OMEGA provides intuitive graphical interfaces to implement integrated particle tracking and motion analysis workflows while providing easy to use facilities to automatically keep track of error propagation, harvest data provenance and ensure the persistence of analysis results and metadata. Specifically, OMEGA: 1) imports image data and metadata from data management tools such as the Open Microscopy Environment Remote Objects (OMERO; Allan et al., 2012); 2) tracks intracellular particles movement; 3) facilitates parameter optimization and trajectory results inspection and validation; 4) performs downstream trajectory analysis and motion type classification; 5) estimates the uncertainty propagating through the motion analysis pipeline; and, 6) facilitates storage and dissemination of analysis results, and analysis definition metadata, on the basis of our newly proposed FAIRsharing.org complainant Minimum Information About Particle Tracking Experiments (MIAPTE; Rigano and Strambio-De-Castillia, 2016; 2017) guidelines in combination with the OME-XML data model (Goldberg et al., 2005). In so doing, OMEGA maintains a persistent link between raw image data, intermediate analysis steps, the overall analysis output, and all necessary metadata to repeat the analysis process and reproduce its results. Availability and implementation OMEGA is a cross-platform, open-source software developed in Java. Source code and cross-platform binaries are freely available on GitHub at https://github.com/OmegaProject/Omega (doi: 10.5281/zenodo.2535523), under the GNU General Public License v.3. Contact [email protected] and [email protected] Supplementary information Supplementary Material is available at BioRxiv.org
BibTeX
@misc{rigano2018omega,
  author = {Alessandro Rigano and Vanni Galli and Jasmine Clark and Lara Pereira and Loris Grossi and Jeremy Luban and Raffaello Giulietti and Tiziano Leidi and Eric Hunter and Mario Valle and Ivo F. Sbalzarini and Caterina Strambio‐De‐Castillia},
  title = {{OMEGA: a software tool for the management, analysis, and dissemination of intracellular trafficking data that incorporates motion type classification and quality control}},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.1101/251850},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure