OH formation and H2adsorption at the liquid water–Pt(111) interface

Henrik H. Kristoffersen, Tejs Vegge, Heine Anton HansenChemical 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This study uses advanced molecular dynamics simulations to reveal that the dynamic nature of liquid water significantly alters how hydroxyl (OH) and hydrogen (H₂) interact with a platinum surface compared to static models. These findings are crucial for understanding and improving catalysts used in fuel cells, particularly for the oxygen reduction reaction.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding the behavior of molecules at the interface between a metal catalyst and an electrolyte is fundamental to electrochemistry and catalysis, especially for applications like Proton Exchange Membrane Fuel Cells (PEMFCs). While previous studies have investigated reactions on metal surfaces, they often simplify the role of the liquid electrolyte by treating water as a static layer or using implicit models. This simplification can overlook the dynamic effects of liquid water, which can significantly influence reaction pathways, energetics, and surface structures. This paper aims to bridge this gap by explicitly incorporating the dynamic behavior of liquid water in simulations of the Pt(111) surface, a common and important catalyst material, to better understand OH formation and H₂ adsorption.

Methods

The researchers employed ab initio molecular dynamics (AIMD) simulations at a constant temperature (350 K) to model the liquid water-Pt(111) interface. This approach allows for the simultaneous treatment of electronic structure (DFT) and atomic motion, capturing the dynamic interactions between water molecules and the platinum surface.

Key methodological aspects include:

  • System Setup: A Pt(111) surface (4 atomic layers thick, 3x4 unit cell) was used, with 32 water molecules explicitly simulated on top.
  • AIMD Simulations: Constant temperature simulations were run using the VASP code with a Nose thermostat. Deuterium was used for water molecules to potentially improve thermalization and time statistics.
  • DFT Calculations: A plane-wave basis set with a 350 eV energy cutoff and a 2x2x1 k-point mesh was used for DFT calculations. The PBE functional with D3 van der Waals correction was employed for exchange-correlation effects.
  • Energy Calculations: Internal energies were calculated by averaging DFT energies and kinetic energies over the simulation time. This allowed for the determination of energy costs for OH formation and adsorption energies for H₂.
  • Analysis Techniques: Time-averaged Bader charges and work functions were calculated to probe charge redistribution and surface electronic properties.
  • Cyclic Voltammetry Simulation: The calculated free energy costs were used to simulate a cyclic voltammogram (CV) to compare with experimental results.

Datasets

Not explicitly discussed as distinct datasets. The study generates its own data through AIMD simulations of the defined liquid water-Pt(111) interface system.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Dynamic Water is Crucial: The most significant insight is that the dynamic nature of liquid water fundamentally changes the interface compared to static models. This impacts surface coverage, OH stability, and H₂ adsorption.
  • Stable OH Coverages Identified: Specific OH coverages (~0.08, 0.42, and 0.67 ML) were found to be particularly stable, aligning with features observed in experimental Pt(111) cyclic voltammetry.
  • Adjacent Uncovered Pt Sites Matter: Unlike static models, the stable OH configurations in dynamic water environments often feature adjacent uncovered Pt sites. This is hypothesized to be important for reactions requiring multiple adjacent metal atoms, like O₂ reduction.
  • Atomic Oxygen Instability: Atomic surface oxygen (O*) was found to be unstable in the presence of dynamic liquid water, contrasting with findings from static simulations.
  • H₂ Adsorption Complexity: H₂ adsorption is not a simple process. At low H coverage, it competes with water, leading to an apparent attraction between H atoms. At higher coverage, H desorbs, negatively charging the surface, which dramatically alters water orientation and interface structure.
  • Surface Charge Importance for H₂: The study suggests that a negatively charged Pt surface is necessary for an accurate description of H₂ adsorption at potentials where it occurs, a detail often missed in charge-neutral models.

Key Results

  • Stable OH Coverages: Identified stable OH coverages at ~0.08 ML (1/12 ML), ~0.42 ML (5/12 ML), and ~0.67 ML (2/3 ML).
  • OH Formation Energetics: The 5/12 ML OH coverage exhibited a particularly low free energy cost per OH species (0.66 eV).
  • Water Coverage Differences: At low OH coverage, the OH and H₂O* surface coverage was significantly lower than predicted by static models.
  • Simulated CV Matches Experiment: The simulated cyclic voltammogram showed a "butterfly feature" that closely matched experimental Pt(111) CVs in acidic electrolytes, validating the model's ability to capture key electrochemical phenomena.
  • H₂ Adsorption Behavior: Competitive adsorption between H and H₂O was observed at low H* coverage. At higher coverages, H desorption led to a negatively charged surface, altering water orientation.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Simulation Time: While longer than previous studies, the AIMD sampling times (up to ~30 ps after equilibration) might still be insufficient to fully capture all dynamic processes and avoid trapping in unfavorable phase space regions. The authors acknowledge that multiple simulations from different starting configurations are ideal.
  • Charge Neutrality: The initial interface model was charge-neutral, which was found to be inadequate for accurately describing H₂ adsorption at certain potentials.
  • Electrolyte Complexity: The simulations primarily focused on water and the metal surface, without explicitly including ions from the electrolyte. The authors suggest that the explicit presence of ions could influence interactions with *OH species.
  • O* Formation: While atomic oxygen (O) was found to be unstable, the possibility of mixed O, OH, and H₂O networks contributing to stability was mentioned but not explicitly studied.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest that future work should focus on improving the interface model for H adsorption by incorporating surface charging and explicitly considering electrolyte ions. Further investigation into mixed O, OH, and H₂O networks is also warranted.

Summary updated

Abstract

The liquid water-Pt(111) interface is studied with constant temperature <i>ab initio</i> molecular dynamics to explore the importance of liquid water dynamics of catalytic reactions such as the oxygen reduction reaction in PEM fuel cells. The structure and energetics of hydroxyls formed at the liquid water-Pt(111) interface are found to be significantly different from those of the hydroxyl formed on a bare Pt(111) surface and the hydroxyl formed on a Pt(111) surface with a static water layer. We identify 1/12 ML *OH, 5/12 ML *OH and 2/3 ML *OH as particularly stable hydroxyl coverages in highly dynamic liquid water environments, which - contrary to static water-hydroxyl models - contain adjacent uncovered Pt sites. Atomic surface oxygen is found to be unstable in the presence of liquid water, in contrast to static atomic level simulations. These results give an improved understanding of hydroxide and surface oxide formation from Pt(111) cyclic voltammetry and allow us to draw detailed connections between the electrostatic potential and the interface structure. The study of hydrogen adsorption at the liquid water-Pt(111) interface finds competitive adsorption between the adsorbed hydrogen atoms and water molecules. This does not adhere with experimental observations, and this indicates that the Pt(111) surface has to be negatively charged for a correct description of the liquid water-Pt(111) interface at potentials where hydrogen adsorption occurs.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{kristoffersen2018oh,
  author = {Henrik H. Kristoffersen and Tejs Vegge and Heine Anton Hansen},
  title = {{OH formation and H<sub>2</sub>adsorption at the liquid water–Pt(111) interface}},
  booktitle = {Chemical},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.1039/c8sc02495b},
}
Figure