Offline Social Networks: stepping away from the Internet (Position paper)

Anne-Marie Kermarrec, Erwan Le Merrer, Bretagne Atlantique2012

TL;DR

This paper proposes "Offline Social Networks" (OffSNs) as a novel approach to social networking that prioritizes physical proximity and user privacy by operating entirely off the internet. OffSNs aim to complement existing online social networks by enabling ephemeral, location-based interactions and data sharing without the privacy concerns associated with centralized online platforms.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Online Social Networks (OSNs) like Facebook have revolutionized how we connect, but they have limitations. The paper highlights that OSNs often fail to leverage physical proximity, which is a significant factor in real-world interactions. Furthermore, the sustainable nature of online relationships can make it awkward to disconnect from people, and the ephemeral nature of online content makes it difficult to retrieve past information. Most critically, OSNs raise significant privacy concerns due to the vast amounts of personal data collected and the potential for breaches, de-anonymization, and misuse. The paper argues that current OSNs don't adequately address these issues, especially for interactions that are temporary and geographically bound.

Methods

The core of the proposed solution is the "Offline Social Network" (OffSN) concept, which relies on a dedicated hardware device acting as a local access point. This device, exemplified by the "Widrop" prototype, is designed to be placed in a physical location, allowing users within its Wi-Fi range to connect anonymously. The OffSN operates independently of the internet, enabling users to form ephemeral social networks, exchange data, and potentially access functionalities similar to OSNs. The paper discusses the Widrop prototype, which is a low-power, Linux-based mini-server with Wi-Fi capabilities, capable of acting as a hotspot and providing a local web server for content sharing and uploads. The authors also suggest extending this basic layer with social networking frameworks like Elgg to add features like message walls and access management.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Physical Proximity as a First-Class Citizen: The paper strongly advocates for integrating geographical locality as a fundamental aspect of social networking, moving beyond the global, often decontextualized nature of current OSNs.
  • Ephemeral Interactions for Social Flexibility: OffSNs are designed to facilitate temporary social connections, mirroring real-world scenarios where relationships are fluid and not necessarily meant to be permanent. This addresses the awkwardness of maintaining unsustainable online connections.
  • Privacy by Design: By operating offline and allowing anonymous access, OffSNs inherently mitigate many privacy risks associated with centralized online platforms. The paper emphasizes the potential for enhanced user control and reduced data exposure.
  • Complementary to Online Networks: OffSNs are not presented as a replacement for OSNs but as a complementary technology that caters to a different set of needs, particularly those involving local, temporary, and privacy-sensitive interactions.
  • Leveraging Existing Hardware and Open Source: The concept builds upon existing technologies like Wi-Fi and open-source software, making it potentially feasible to implement and deploy.

Key Results

As this is a position paper, it focuses on conceptualizing and outlining the potential of OffSNs rather than presenting empirical results from extensive experiments. The paper describes the development of a functional Widrop prototype, demonstrating the technical feasibility of the core hardware component. It also outlines several promising application scenarios, such as local content promotion, ephemeral social networks for meetings, family sharing, and personalized local recommendations, suggesting the broad applicability of the OffSN concept.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several challenges and areas for future research:

  • Privacy Auditing: While OffSNs offer inherent privacy advantages, a comprehensive audit of privacy-sensitive questions is still needed. This includes exploring on-the-fly disk encryption and robust log management.
  • Trust and Security: Establishing user trust in OffSNs is crucial. The paper suggests that open-source approaches and security mechanisms like SWATT (software-based attestation) can help build this trust.
  • Scalability and Flash Crowds: Handling large numbers of users and sudden influxes of activity (flash crowds), especially in scenarios like concerts, requires further investigation. Solutions like "fatdrops" or connecting multiple Widrops are proposed.
  • Peer-to-Peer Dissemination: For large-scale dissemination, a peer-to-peer protocol that assists OffSNs and requires local clients on user devices is suggested.
  • Local Recommendations: Developing effective user profiles and similarity metrics for personalized recommendations without compromising privacy remains a significant challenge.
  • Collaborative Widrop: Exploring decentralized models where responsibilities are distributed among user devices, potentially using secret sharing techniques for controlled data access, is a promising future direction.
  • Bootstrap and Reliability: For advanced collaborative models, challenges related to bootstrapping the protocol and ensuring the reliability of such systems need to be addressed for practical applications.

Summary updated

Abstract

Online social networks have been revolutionary in the way people interact over the Internet today. Typically in online social networks the information is ephemeral while the relationships between users are sustainable. While they have been very successful, they usually do not leverage the notion of physical proximity. In addition the sustainable nature of the connections does not leave any room for sporadic and fleeting social relations. In this position paper, we explore the concept of offline social network considering geographical locality as a first-class citizen. Offline social networks do not aim at capturing long-standing relationships and in that sense are very complementary to online ones. Being implemented off the Internet, they avoid privacy breaches that users start to complain about. An offline social network relies on a hardware device, plugged in some location, to which anyone can freely connect. In an offline social network, while the relationships between users are ephemeral, the information can be temporary or permanent depending on the application scenarios. We believe that such a concept matches a wide spectrum of usages today that are not covered by online social networks. In this position paper, we describe the concept, the potential applications, the underlying technologies as well as the associated exciting research agenda. 1
BibTeX
@misc{kermarrec2012offline,
  author = {Anne-Marie Kermarrec and Erwan Le Merrer and Bretagne Atlantique and Erwan Le Merrer},
  title = {{Offline Social Networks: stepping away from the Internet (Position paper)}},
  year = {2012},
}

Loading related content...

Figure