Occurrence of pesticide residues in fruit – results of official control (2021)

Bożena Łozowicka, Piotr Kaczyński, Ewa Rutkowska, Magdalena Jankowska, Izabela Hrynko, Aleksandra Pietraszko, Justyna Śniadach, Marta Czerwińska, Rafał Wiśniewski, Rafał KoneckiProgress 2023 · DOI

Abstract

This study provides a multidimensional analysis of pesticide residues in 87 fruit samples collected in Poland during 2021. Samples were obtained through official state control (68, WIORiN) and cross-compliance control (19, ARiMR). The research assessed the frequency of chemical groups, active substance (a.s.) concentrations, and adherence to Maximum Residue Levels (MRLs). Pesticide residues were detected in 45% of WIORiN samples and 9% of ARiMR samples, with only 1% exceeding MRL standards. Fungicides were the most prevalent chemical group. Multi-residue samples were common (44%), highlighting the importance of ongoing monitoring to ensure food quality and safety.

Introduction

The use of Plant Protection Products (PPPs) is essential in modern agriculture to mitigate crop loss from agrophages and maintain high yields. However, the persistence of these chemicals as residues in food poses potential health risks. To manage this, regulatory bodies establish Maximum Residue Levels (MRLs). This paper evaluates the adherence of Polish fruit producers to these standards and examines the prevalence of multi-residue "cocktails" in fruit reaching the market.

Methodology

The researchers screened for 516 different active substances and their metabolites using a multi-dimensional analytical approach.

  • Sampling: 87 samples were collected across 16 Polish provinces.
  • Extraction: The QuEChERS method was employed for efficient multi-residue extraction.
  • Detection: Analysis was performed using Gas Chromatography-Tandem Mass Spectrometry (GC-MS/MS), Liquid Chromatography-Tandem Mass Spectrometry (LC-MS/MS), and spectrophotometry for dithiocarbamates.
  • Quality Control: All methods were validated and accredited according to ISO/IEC 17025 and SANTE 2019 guidelines.

Dataset and Sample Distribution

The study analyzed 87 samples categorized into berries and small fruits (48), stone fruits (33), and pome fruits (6). These were collected under two frameworks: WIORiN (official state control) and ARiMR (cross-compliance controls).

Distribution of fruit types in ARiMR samples (n=19)
Distribution of fruit types in WIORiN samples (n=68)

Key Findings

Compliance and Residue Levels

While 54% of the total samples contained detectable residues, overall compliance with safety standards was high. 46% of samples were residue-free, and 53% contained residues within legal MRLs. Only 1% of samples—specifically a cherry sample containing iprodione—exceeded the MRL. Notably, residues were found in 45% of WIORiN samples but only 9% of ARiMR samples, reflecting differences in sampling priorities.

The "Cocktail Effect" and Chemical Profile

Fungicides dominated the chemical profile, representing 78% of the 26 detected substances. This is likely due to late-season applications to prevent fungal rot. A significant concern is the "cocktail effect," where 44% of samples contained multiple residues (ranging from 2 to 9 substances). One cherry sample contained nine different chemicals, raising questions about the cumulative toxicological impact of such mixtures.

Crop-Specific Vulnerabilities

Strawberries had the highest frequency of residue detection (18%), while blueberries showed the highest concentration of a single substance (1.6 mg/kg of boscalid). Furthermore, 5% of samples contained residues of substances not recommended for the specific crop, suggesting potential off-label use.

Conclusion

The 2021 monitoring results indicate that while MRL exceedances are rare, the prevalence of multi-residue samples is a significant trend. Current individual-substance regulations may need to evolve toward cumulative risk assessments to better address the "cocktail effect." Continued official control is vital for guaranteeing food safety in crops requiring intensive chemical protection.

Summary updated

Abstract

The aim of the study was a multidimensional analysis of the occurrence of pesticide residues in fruit samples (87) within the framework of official control (68, WIORiN) and cross-compliance control (19, ARiMR). There was an assessment of the frequency of detection of chemical groups and individual active substances (a.s.), the level of concentrations and estimation of the magnitude of exceedances of permissible standards (MRLs), as well as diagnosis of multi-residue samples. The practical purpose of the studies conducted was to assess compliance by producers with the regulations for the application of the pesticide residues. In 45% (WIORiN) and 9% (ARiMR) of the samples, residues of pesticides were found. MRL exceedances were recorded in 1% of the samples tested. Samples with a non-recommended a.s. accounted for 5% of samples. Of the 516 labeled pesticides, 26 a.s. were detected, mainly fungicides. The highest level was recorded for boscalid (1.6 mg/kg) in the blueberry sample. Residues of pesticides were most often detected in strawberries (18%). The highest number of compounds was detected in cherries, where nine a.s. were determined. The presence of multi-residue samples was noted (44%), of which samples with two residues were the most numerous (11%). The results obtained from the study show the importance of controlling residues of pesticides in fruits, which require frequent use of chemical pesticides due to attack from agrophages, in order to guarantee food quality and safety.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{ozowicka2023occurrence,
  author = {Bożena Łozowicka and Piotr Kaczyński and Ewa Rutkowska and Magdalena Jankowska and Izabela Hrynko and Aleksandra Pietraszko and Justyna Śniadach and Marta Czerwińska and Rafał Wiśniewski and Rafał Konecki},
  title = {{Occurrence of pesticide residues in fruit – results of official control (2021)}},
  booktitle = {Progress},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.14199/ppp-2023-001},
}
Figure