Occurrence and Exposure Assessment of Nickel in Zhejiang Province, China

Junde Han, Ronghua Zhang, Jun Tang, Jiang Chen, Chenyang Zheng, Dong Zhao, Jikai Wang, Hexiang Zhang, Xiaojuan Qi, Xiaoli Wu, Qihao Weng, Jinping Zeng, Jiaolan Du, Min Zhang, Yinyin Wu, Biao ZhouToxics 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigated nickel (Ni) contamination in a wide range of food products across Zhejiang Province, China, revealing that beans are a significant source of Ni exposure. While overall Ni exposure is generally acceptable for most residents, children aged 0-6 face a higher risk, highlighting the need for targeted monitoring and dietary guidance.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Nickel, an essential trace element with antioxidative properties, is also a potential environmental contaminant. Anthropogenic activities have led to increased Ni levels in various environmental media. This paper addresses the critical need to understand the occurrence and dietary exposure risks of nickel in food consumed by the population of Zhejiang Province, China. Previous studies have provided limited perspectives, and with Zhejiang being a major industrial and e-waste processing region, understanding current Ni contamination levels and associated health risks is crucial, especially for vulnerable groups.

Methods

The researchers employed a comprehensive approach to assess Ni contamination and dietary exposure.

  • Sampling: A total of 2628 food samples were collected from 11 cities in Zhejiang Province between 2018 and 2019, covering diverse food categories including beans, vegetables, aquatic foods, meat products, cereal products, and fruits.
  • Chemical Analysis: Nickel concentrations were determined using Inductively Coupled Plasma Mass Spectrometry (ICP-MS) after microwave digestion of the food samples. Rigorous quality control measures, including the use of certified reference materials and blank experiments, were implemented.
  • Dietary Exposure Assessment: Food consumption data from a 2014-2017 dietary survey of Zhejiang residents were utilized. The study calculated the Estimated Daily Intake (EDI) of Ni for different age groups using the simple distribution method and the Target Hazard Quotient (THQ) method, as recommended by the US Environmental Protection Agency (USEPA).
  • Statistical Analysis: Various statistical tests, including chi-squared tests, normality tests, and Wilcoxon rank-sum tests, were used to analyze detection rates, overstandard rates, and differences in consumption patterns across age groups.

Datasets

The study utilized two primary datasets:

  1. Food Sample Data: Nickel concentrations from 2628 food samples collected in Zhejiang Province between 2018 and 2019. This dataset covers a wide array of food categories.
  2. Dietary Survey Data: Food consumption data from a Zhejiang Province dietary survey conducted between 2014 and 2017, which included information on food habits, frequency of consumption, and body weight for approximately 19,000 individuals across different age groups.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Beans as a High-Nickel Food: The study identified beans as having the highest Ni concentration among all food categories analyzed, with a 100% overstandard rate compared to national limits. This makes beans a primary contributor to high Ni exposure risk.
  • Vulnerable Population Identified: Children aged 0-6 years exhibited the highest dietary exposure to Ni, with their THQ exceeding the safety threshold under high consumption and contamination scenarios. This highlights a critical need for targeted attention to this age group.
  • Biodilution in Aquatic Foods: For aquatic foods, a biodilution effect was observed, meaning lower-trophic-level organisms (like shellfish) had higher Ni concentrations than higher-trophic-level organisms.
  • Processed Foods as Potential Sources: Processed foods, such as pickled vegetables and canned fish, showed higher Ni levels, suggesting that processing and food contact materials can contribute to Ni transfer.
  • Regional Differences in Ni Levels: While Ni levels in Zhejiang's soil are generally lower than the national average, anthropogenic activities appear to be driving elevated Ni concentrations in food.

Key Results

  • Overall Detection Rate: Nickel was detected in 86.5% of all food samples analyzed.
  • Highest Ni Concentration: Beans exhibited the highest Ni concentration across all food categories.
  • Overstandard Rates: While most food categories had low overstandard rates for Ni (ranging from 0% to 5.07%), beans showed a 100% overstandard rate.
  • Dietary Exposure Risk: Generally acceptable Ni exposure levels were found for most age groups. However, for children aged 0-6, the THQ value of 1.078 indicated an unacceptable exposure risk under certain consumption modes.
  • Major Contributors to Exposure: Beans and vegetables/vegetable products were identified as the main sources of dietary Ni exposure for low consumption scenarios, while vegetables remained a primary source for high consumption scenarios.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited Cereal Variety: The study acknowledges that only a limited variety of cereals (e.g., bread, cookies, egg rolls) were sampled, which may lead to an underestimation of Ni exposure risk from cereal consumption.
  • Overestimation of Overstandard Ratio for Beans: The paper notes that while beans had the highest overstandard ratio, their Ni accumulation ability might be lower than that of animal fat, potentially leading to an overestimation of the overstandard ratio.
  • Need for Probability Assessment: For risk exposure values approaching or exceeding the Allowable Daily Intake, the authors suggest that a probability assessment is necessary, which was not employed in this study due to technical limitations.
  • Future Work: The authors emphasize the crucial need for a comprehensive study focusing on younger children due to their higher exposure and potential vulnerability. They also suggest classifying limited Ni values among diverse foods to improve the precision of risk assessments and recommend considering drinking water as another significant pathway for Ni intake.

Summary updated

Abstract

Nickel (Ni) is a silver-white metal with high antioxidative properties, often existing in a bivalent form in the environment. Despite being the fifth most abundant metal on Earth, anthropogenic activities, including industrial processes, have elevated Ni levels in environmental media. This study investigated Ni contamination in various food groups in Zhejiang Province, China, mainly focusing on Ni levels in beans, vegetables, aquatic foods, meat products, cereal products, and fruits. A total of 2628 samples were collected and analyzed. Beans exhibited the highest Ni content in all samples. The overall detection rate of Ni was 86.5%, with variation among food categories. For plant-origin foods, legumes had the highest Ni concentration while for animal-origin foods, shellfish showed the highest median Ni concentration. The results indicate generally acceptable Ni exposure levels among Zhejiang residents, except for children aged 0-6. Beans were identified as the primary contributor to high Ni exposure risk. The paper suggests monitoring Ni contamination in food, especially for vulnerable populations, and provides insights into exposure risks in different age groups.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{han2024occurrence,
  author = {Junde Han and Ronghua Zhang and Jun Tang and Jiang Chen and Chenyang Zheng and Dong Zhao and Jikai Wang and Hexiang Zhang and Xiaojuan Qi and Xiaoli Wu and Qihao Weng and Jinping Zeng and Jiaolan Du and Min Zhang and Yinyin Wu and Biao Zhou},
  title = {{Occurrence and Exposure Assessment of Nickel in Zhejiang Province, China}},
  booktitle = {Toxics},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3390/toxics12030169},
}
Figure