Obtaining Record Linkage Consent: Results from a Wording Experiment in Germany

Joseph W. Sakshaug, Stefanie Wolter, Frauke KreuterSocial 2015 · DOI

Abstract

Many sample surveys ask respondents for consent to link their survey information with
\nadministrative sources. There is significant variation in how linkage requests are
\nadministered and little experimental evidence to suggest which approaches are useful for
\nachieving high consent rates. A common approach is to emphasize the positive benefits of
\nlinkage to respondents. However, some evidence suggests that emphasizing the negative
\nconsequences of not consenting to linkage is a more effective strategy. To further examine
\nthis issue, we conducted a gain-loss framing experiment in which we emphasized the benefit
\n(gain) of linking or the negative consequence (loss) of not linking one’s data as it related to
\nthe usefulness of their survey responses. In addition, we explored a sunk-prospective costs
\nrationale by varying the emphasis on response usefulness for responses that the respondent
\nhad already provided prior to the linkage request (sunk costs) and responses that would be
\nprovided after the linkage request (prospective costs). We found a significant interaction
\nbetween gain-loss framing and the sunk-prospective costs rationale: respondents in the
\ngain-framing condition consented to linkage at a higher rate than those in the loss-framing
\ncondition when response usefulness was emphasized for responses to subsequent survey
\nitems. Conversely, the opposite pattern was observed when response usefulness was
\nemphasized for responses that had already been provided: loss-framing resulted in a higher
\nconsent rate than the gain-framing, but this result did not reach statistical significance.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{sakshaug2015obtaining,
  author = {Joseph W. Sakshaug and Stefanie Wolter and Frauke Kreuter},
  title = {{Obtaining Record Linkage Consent: Results from a Wording Experiment in Germany}},
  booktitle = {Social},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.13094/smif-2015-00012},
}

Loading related content...

Figure