Observed strong atmospheric water constraints on forest photosynthesis using eddy covariance and satellite-based data across the Northern Hemisphere

Yongxian Su, Xueqin Yang, Pierre Gentine, Fabienne Maignan, Jiali Shang, Philippe CiaisInternational Journal of Applied Earth Observation and Geoinformation 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals that the timing of rainfall relative to solar radiation significantly influences how water availability (soil moisture vs. atmospheric dryness) limits forest photosynthesis across the Northern Hemisphere. Forests in "synchronous" climates (rain and sun in sync) are more constrained by atmospheric dryness, while those in "asynchronous" climates (rain and sun out of sync) are more limited by soil moisture, especially when combined with high atmospheric dryness.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Terrestrial ecosystems, particularly forests, play a crucial role in the global carbon cycle. Their ability to absorb carbon dioxide (photosynthesis) is heavily influenced by water availability. Two key factors limit photosynthesis: soil water deficit (when plants can't access enough water from the ground) and high atmospheric dryness, often measured by vapor pressure deficit (VPD) (when the air is very dry, increasing water loss from leaves). While both are known to limit photosynthesis, it's been unclear how the seasonality of these factors, and their interplay with climate patterns, affects forest carbon uptake. Specifically, the paper investigates how the timing of rainfall relative to incoming solar radiation (a measure of energy for photosynthesis) influences whether soil moisture or atmospheric dryness is the dominant constraint on forest photosynthesis.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-faceted approach combining ground-based eddy covariance data with satellite observations.

  • Climate Seasonality Classification: They classified climate seasonality based on the Pearson correlation coefficient (Rclimate) between monthly precipitation (Pre) and incoming shortwave radiation (SW) over the growing season (April-September).
  • Synchronous Climate: Positive Rclimate (Pre and SW covary positively).
  • Asynchronous Climate: Negative Rclimate (Pre and SW covary negatively).
  • Water Stress Proxies:
    • Soil Water Availability: Approximated by the ratio of actual evapotranspiration (AET) to potential evapotranspiration (PET) (AET/PET).
  • Atmospheric Dryness: Measured by vapor pressure deficit (VPD).
  • Photosynthesis Metrics:
    • Ecosystem Light-Use Efficiency (LUEEC): Calculated from eddy covariance data (gross primary production divided by absorbed photosynthetically active radiation).
  • Canopy Fluorescence Yield (Fqy): Derived from satellite Solar Induced Fluorescence (SIF) divided by absorbed photosynthetically active radiation (APAR).
  • Statistical Analysis: They used correlation analyses, mixed-effect linear models, and locally weighted regression to disentangle the effects of soil moisture and VPD on LUEEC across different AET/PET bins and Rclimate categories.

Datasets

  • Eddy Covariance Data: From 83 forest sites across the Northern Hemisphere (latitude > 15°N) from the FLUXNET 2015 openly available database (Tier 1).
  • Satellite-Based Data:
    • Solar Induced Fluorescence (SIF) from GOME-2 and TROPOMI.
  • Phenological data: NDVI, LAI, EVI, NIRv, and Ku-VOD.
  • MODIS land cover products (MCD12C1) for continental scale analysis.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Climate Seasonality is Key: The timing of rainfall relative to solar radiation is a critical factor determining which water stress (soil moisture or atmospheric dryness) dominates forest photosynthesis.
  • Synchronous Climates = Atmospheric Dryness Dominance: In regions where rainfall and solar radiation are in phase (synchronous), forests are more likely to be limited by high atmospheric dryness (high VPD), even with adequate soil moisture. This suggests that the demand for water from the atmosphere is a major constraint.
  • Asynchronous Climates = Soil Moisture + Dryness Combo: In regions where rainfall and solar radiation are out of phase (asynchronous), forests experience stronger limitations from low soil water availability, particularly when it coincides with high atmospheric dryness. This indicates a dual stress scenario.
  • Atmospheric Dryness is Widespread: The study implies that atmospheric dryness exerts a stronger constraint on forest photosynthesis over a larger area in synchronous climates compared to asynchronous climates across the Northern Hemisphere.
  • VPD Thresholds Vary: The critical VPD threshold at which photosynthesis is significantly impacted differs based on soil water availability and the climate seasonality type.

Key Results

  • Forest photosynthesis (measured by LUEEC and Fqy) is significantly reduced by low soil water availability when accompanied by high atmospheric dryness in asynchronous climates.
  • In synchronous climates, forest photosynthesis is primarily limited by high atmospheric dryness, with less impact from soil water stress.
  • Site and regional analyses consistently show that atmospheric dryness is a stronger constraint in synchronous climates over a larger area.
  • The study found that Rclimate values are positively correlated with Rconstraint (correlation between VPD and AET/PET), indicating that climates with synchronized rainfall and radiation also tend to have synchronized water stress signals.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Seasonal Temperature Disturbances: The authors acknowledge that seasonal temperature variations were not explicitly excluded and could introduce uncertainty into the findings regarding soil and atmospheric water constraints. Further in-depth studies are needed to address this.
  • Data Archiving: The data is currently being archived and will be made available in ZENODO repository upon acceptance of the paper.
  • Future Projections: The paper suggests that with increasing global VPD, the regions dominated by high atmospheric dryness constraints on terrestrial forests may expand, highlighting the need for improved climate change impact models.

Summary updated

Abstract

Soil water deficit and high atmospheric dryness (vapor pressure deficit, VPD) are major environmental limitations on carbon uptake of terrestrial ecosystems. However, it is still unclear how climate seasonality influences seasonal soil water supply and atmospheric water demand, and consequently limits plant photosynthesis. Here, we analyzed the impacts of the seasonal radiation-rainfall coupling on soil moisture limitations versus atmospheric dryness limitations on plant photosynthesis across the Northern Hemisphere north of 15°N, using the eddy covariance data of 83 forest sites and multiple satellite-based data. Our results show that forest photosynthesis is strongly reduced by low soil water availability that is accompanied by a high atmospheric dryness during warm seasons for sites and regions where there is a strong negative covariation between radiation and rainfall availability, which we denote as asynchronous climate. However, under climates with positive covariation between radiation and rainfall availability, i.e. synchronous climate, forest photosynthesis experiences only a small soil water stress, but tends to be limited by high atmospheric dryness during warm seasons. Both the site and regional analyses imply that atmospheric dryness exhibits stronger constraints on forest photosynthesis in synchronous climate over a larger area than in asynchronous climate across the Northern Hemisphere.
BibTeX
@article{su2022observed,
  author = {Yongxian Su and Xueqin Yang and Pierre Gentine and Fabienne Maignan and Jiali Shang and Philippe Ciais},
  title = {{Observed strong atmospheric water constraints on forest photosynthesis using eddy covariance and satellite-based data across the Northern Hemisphere}},
  journal = {International Journal of Applied Earth Observation and Geoinformation},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1016/j.jag.2022.102808},
}
Figure