Observed Equity and Driving Factors of Automated External Defibrillators: A Case Study Using WeChat Applet Data

Shunyi Liao, Feng Gao, Lei Feng, Jiemin Wu, Zexia Wang, Wangyang ChenISPRS Int. J. Geo Inf 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates the equity of Automated External Defibrillator (AED) distribution in Guangzhou and Shenzhen, revealing significant disparities and identifying key socio-economic drivers. By leveraging novel WeChat applet data and advanced spatial analysis, the research provides crucial insights for optimizing AED placement and improving public health emergency preparedness.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Out-of-hospital cardiac arrest (OHCA) is a critical medical emergency with a high mortality rate. Automated External Defibrillators (AEDs) are vital for immediate intervention and significantly improve survival rates. While much research has focused on the spatial distribution and accessibility of AEDs, there's a notable gap in understanding the equity of their distribution and the socio-economic factors that influence it. Furthermore, comparative studies across multiple cities are less common. This paper addresses this gap by analyzing AED equity at both city and block levels in two major Chinese megacities, Guangzhou and Shenzhen, and identifying the underlying socio-economic determinants.

Methods

The study employed a multi-faceted approach:

  • Data Acquisition: A Python script was used to extract AED location data from the "City Lifesaving Map" WeChat applet, providing a novel, standardized, and open-source data source for multiple cities.
  • Equity Assessment: The Gini coefficient and Lorenz curve were used to quantify AED equity at both the city and block scales. These methods are standard for measuring distributional inequalities.
  • Determinant Analysis: The Optimal Parameters-based Geographical Detector (OPGD) model was utilized. This is an advanced spatial statistical model that quantifies the individual and interactive effects of various socio-economic factors on AED equity, addressing the Modifiable Areal Unit Problem (MAUP) through optimal discretization.
  • Variable Selection: Six potential determinants were selected based on existing literature and city characteristics: local economic level (GDP per capita), population density, proportion of the elderly, population mobility, company density, and residential density.

Datasets

  • AED Location Data: Obtained via a WeChat applet ("City Lifesaving Map") for Guangzhou and Shenzhen. This represents a novel data source for this type of research.
  • Socio-economic Data:
    • Local economic level (per capita GDP): Derived from government block statistical data.
  • Population density: Derived from government block statistical data.
  • Proportion of the elderly: Derived from government block statistical data.
  • Population mobility: Calculated from mobile phone signal data at the base station level.
  • Company density: Calculated from POI density data (Baidu Map API).
  • Residential density: Calculated from POI density data (Baidu Map API).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Data Novelty: The use of a WeChat applet for data collection is a significant methodological advancement, offering a standardized, accessible, and up-to-date source for AED data across multiple cities.
  • Equity Disparities: The study highlights substantial differences in AED availability and equity between Guangzhou and Shenzhen, with Shenzhen demonstrating a more equitable distribution.
  • Socio-economic Drivers: The research moves beyond simple spatial distribution to identify specific socio-economic factors that drive AED equity, offering actionable insights for policy.
  • Interactive Effects: The OPGD model's ability to reveal interactive effects between determinants is crucial, showing that factors often work in combination to influence AED equity.

Key Results

  • Quantity Gap: Shenzhen has approximately eight times more AEDs than Guangzhou.
  • Equity Levels: Shenzhen exhibits more equitable AED distribution (Gini = 0.347) compared to Guangzhou (Gini = 0.504).
  • Individual Determinants:
    • Guangzhou: Residential density (LIVE_DEN) was the strongest individual determinant of AED equity (q=0.876), followed by population density (POP_DEN, q=0.805). The proportion of the elderly (OLD_RATIO) also played a significant role (q=0.483), reflecting the city's aging population.
  • Shenzhen: Residential density (LIVE_DEN) was also the strongest determinant (q=0.801), followed by local economic level (GDP, q=0.764) and company density (WORK_DEN, q=0.629).
  • Interactive Determinants:
    • Guangzhou: The interaction between residential density (LIVE_DEN) and company density (WORK_DEN) had the highest joint explanatory power (q=0.922). High-aging blocks combined with dense residential areas also showed high equity.
  • Shenzhen: The interaction between local economic level (GDP) and residential density (LIVE_DEN) was most significant (q=0.894). High local economic development, combined with dense residential areas and high mobility, characterized areas with equitable AED distribution.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Scope: The study focused on the overall society and did not analyze equity across different social groups. Future work should expand to include these finer-grained analyses.
  • Data Integration: The authors acknowledge the need to incorporate OHCA case data for a more accurate assessment of AED needs and application. This would allow for better placement strategies based on actual emergency incidence.
  • Spatial Heterogeneity: While block-level analysis was performed, future research could explore spatially varying associations between factors and AED equity using methods like geographically weighted regression.
  • Traffic Variables: The study did not include traffic-related variables, which are important for accessibility and could be a focus for future research.
  • Dynamic Analysis: The current study is based on data from a specific point in time. Future work could explore the dynamic evolution of AED equity and its determinants.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{liao2023observed,
  author = {Shunyi Liao and Feng Gao and Lei Feng and Jiemin Wu and Zexia Wang and Wangyang Chen},
  title = {{Observed Equity and Driving Factors of Automated External Defibrillators: A Case Study Using WeChat Applet Data}},
  journal = {ISPRS Int. J. Geo Inf.},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/ijgi12110444},
}
Figure