Observations of the Crab Nebula and Pulsar with the Large-sized Telescope Prototype of the Cherenkov Telescope Array

Hidetarô Abe, K. Abe, S. Abe, Arnau Aguasca-Cabot, I. Agudo, Nuria Álvarez Crespo, L. A. Antonelli, C. Aramo, A. Arbet Engels, C. Arcaro, Manuel Artero, Katsuaki Asano, P. Aubert, A. Baktash, A. Bamba, Andrés Baquero, L. Baroncelli, U. Barres de Almeida, J. A. Barrio, Ivana Batković, J. Baxter, J. Becerra González, E. Bernardini, M. Bernardos, J. Bernete Medrano, A. Berti, Pooja Bhattacharjee, Noah Biederbeck, C. Bigongiari, E. Bissaldi, O. Blanch, G. Bonnoli, P. Bordas, A. Borghese, A. Bulgarelli, I. Burelli, Mario Buscemi, M Cardillo, Sami Caroff, A. Carosi, F. Cassol-Brunner, D. Cauz, G. Ceribella, Yating Chai, K. S. Cheng, A. Chiavassa, M. Chikawa, L. Chytka, A. Cifuentes, J. L. Contreras, J. Cortina, H. Costantini, Giacomo D’Amico, M. Dalchenko, A. De Angelis, Mathieu de Bony de Lavergne, B. De Lotto, Raniere de Menezes, G. Deleglise, C. Delgado Mendez, J. Delgado, D. della Volpe, M. Dellaiera, Davide Depaoli, Ambra Di Piano, F. Di Pierro, R. Di Tria, L. Di Venere, C. Díaz, Rune Michael Dominik, D. Dominis Prester, Alice Donini, D. Dorner, M. Doro, Dominik Elsässer, Gabriel Emery, Juan Escudero, V. Fallah Ramazani, G. Ferrara, F. Ferrarotto, A. Fiasson, Lluís Freixas Coromina, Stefan Fröse, Satoshi Fukami, Y. Fukazawa, Enrique Alonso García, R. Garcia López, C. Gasbarra, D Gasparrini, Felix Geyer, J. Giesbrecht Paiva, N. Giglietto, F. Giordano, E. Giro, Paweł Gliwny, N. Godinović, R. Grau, D. Green, Jarred Gershon Green, Shuichi GunjiThe Astrophysical Journal 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

The first scientific results from the Cherenkov Telescope Array's Large-Sized Telescope prototype (LST-1) are presented, demonstrating its capability to observe the Crab Nebula and Pulsar. The LST-1 has achieved its expected performance, validating its simulation models and providing a sensitive new tool for very-high-energy gamma-ray astronomy, particularly at lower energies.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Ground-based gamma-ray observatories, like the Cherenkov Telescope Array (CTA), detect high-energy photons by observing the air showers they produce. A key challenge is accurately reconstructing the properties of these showers (energy, direction) to understand the astrophysical sources. This paper addresses the need to validate the performance of the LST-1, the first telescope of the CTA, and its associated data analysis pipeline. Specifically, it aims to demonstrate that LST-1 can achieve its design goals, particularly at the lower end of the very-high-energy (VHE) gamma-ray spectrum (down to ~20 GeV), and to assess its capabilities by observing a well-known VHE gamma-ray source: the Crab Nebula.

Methods

The study employs a comprehensive Monte Carlo (MC) simulation framework (CORSIKA and sim_telarray) to model the Cherenkov light produced by air showers and detected by the LST-1. Key aspects of the analysis include:

  • Shower Simulation: Gamma rays and protons are simulated with detailed energy spectra and angular distributions.
  • Telescope Simulation: The optical properties of the LST-1, including mirror reflectivity and PMT response, are modeled.
  • Data Analysis Pipeline (cta-lstchain): A multi-stage process is used, starting with pixel-wise charge integration, followed by "image cleaning" to select significant signals, and then parametrization using Hillas parameters.
  • Machine Learning for Reconstruction: Random forests are trained to reconstruct the incoming direction, energy, and classify events as gamma rays or background protons. Both "source-independent" and "source-dependent" analysis approaches are explored.
  • Instrument Response Functions (IRFs): These are derived from MC simulations to quantify the telescope's performance (effective area, energy and angular resolution) as a function of energy and other parameters.
  • Data-MC Comparison: The observed data from the Crab Nebula are compared against MC simulations to validate the analysis pipeline and assess the LST-1's performance.

Datasets

  • Simulated Data:
    • Gamma-ray showers (for training and testing the analysis pipeline).
  • Proton showers (for training the particle classification algorithms).
  • Single muons (for calibrating optical efficiency).
  • Observational Data:
    • Data from the Crab Nebula and Pulsar collected by the LST-1 prototype between November 2020 and March 2022, during its commissioning phase. This dataset comprises 48.0 hours of dark night observations.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • LST-1 Meets Expectations: The LST-1 prototype has successfully achieved its designed performance, validating the extensive MC simulations used for data analysis with only minor adjustments.
  • Low-Energy Frontier: The LST-1 is particularly effective at the lower end of the VHE gamma-ray spectrum (~20-30 GeV), opening up a new observational window for CTA.
  • Crab Nebula as a Standard Candle: The Crab Nebula, a well-studied VHE gamma-ray source, serves as an excellent benchmark for validating the LST-1's performance and the analysis pipeline.
  • Importance of Systematic Uncertainties: The study highlights that even for a bright source like the Crab Nebula, systematic uncertainties (e.g., in background estimation) can be significant, especially at low energies, and are crucial for accurate spectral and light curve measurements.
  • Pulsar Detection: The LST-1 has successfully detected the periodic signal from the Crab Pulsar, demonstrating its capability to probe VHE pulsar emission.

Key Results

  • Energy Threshold: The energy threshold at trigger level is around 20 GeV, rising to approximately 30 GeV after data analysis.
  • Angular Resolution: Ranges from 0.12° to 0.40° depending on energy and analysis cuts.
  • Energy Resolution: Ranges from 15% to 50% depending on energy and analysis cuts.
  • Flux Sensitivity: For a 50-hour observation, the sensitivity is around 1.1% of the Crab Nebula flux above 250 GeV (12% for 30 minutes).
  • Spectral Energy Distribution (SED) and Light Curve: The obtained SED and light curve for the Crab Nebula are in good agreement with previous measurements, considering statistical and systematic uncertainties.
  • Pulsar Signal: A clear periodic signal from the Crab Pulsar has been detected.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Monoscopic Limitations: The paper acknowledges that the monoscopic nature of LST-1 limits its performance compared to stereoscopic arrays, especially at lower energies, due to challenges in background rejection and direction reconstruction.
  • Data-MC Discrepancies: While generally good, some discrepancies between data and MC distributions were observed, particularly in image parameters at lower intensities. These are attributed to potential arcminute-scale mispointing, which is expected to be resolved with offline pointing corrections.
  • Systematic Uncertainties: The study emphasizes the need for further investigation into systematic uncertainties, particularly in background estimation, which significantly impact low-energy spectral measurements.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that a more complete MC training sample could potentially improve performance. They also highlight that the Crab pulsar spectrum analysis is ongoing and will be the subject of a future publication. The development of more sophisticated analysis techniques, such as source-dependent analysis, is also an area of ongoing work.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract The Cherenkov Telescope Array (CTA) is a next-generation ground-based observatory for gamma-ray astronomy at very high energies. The Large-Sized Telescope prototype (LST-1) is located at the CTA-North site, on the Canary Island of La Palma. LSTs are designed to provide optimal performance in the lowest part of the energy range covered by CTA, down to ≃20 GeV. LST-1 started performing astronomical observations in 2019 November, during its commissioning phase, and it has been taking data ever since. We present the first LST-1 observations of the Crab Nebula, the standard candle of very-high-energy gamma-ray astronomy, and use them, together with simulations, to assess the performance of the telescope. LST-1 has reached the expected performance during its commissioning period—only a minor adjustment of the preexisting simulations was needed to match the telescope’s behavior. The energy threshold at trigger level is around 20 GeV, rising to ≃30 GeV after data analysis. Performance parameters depend strongly on energy, and on the strength of the gamma-ray selection cuts in the analysis: angular resolution ranges from 0.°12–0.°40, and energy resolution from 15%–50%. Flux sensitivity is around 1.1% of the Crab Nebula flux above 250 GeV for a 50 hr observation (12% for 30 minutes). The spectral energy distribution (in the 0.03–30 TeV range) and the light curve obtained for the Crab Nebula agree with previous measurements, considering statistical and systematic uncertainties. A clear periodic signal is also detected from the pulsar at the center of the Nebula.
BibTeX
@article{abe2023observations,
  author = {Hidetarô Abe and K. Abe and S. Abe and Arnau Aguasca-Cabot and I. Agudo and Nuria Álvarez Crespo and L. A. Antonelli and C. Aramo and A. Arbet Engels and C. Arcaro and Manuel Artero and Katsuaki Asano and P. Aubert and A. Baktash and A. Bamba and Andrés Baquero and L. Baroncelli and U. Barres de Almeida and J. A. Barrio and Ivana Batković and J. Baxter and J. Becerra González and E. Bernardini and M. Bernardos and J. Bernete Medrano and A. Berti and Pooja Bhattacharjee and Noah Biederbeck and C. Bigongiari and E. Bissaldi and O. Blanch and G. Bonnoli and P. Bordas and A. Borghese and A. Bulgarelli and I. Burelli and Mario Buscemi and M Cardillo and Sami Caroff and A. Carosi and F. Cassol-Brunner and D. Cauz and G. Ceribella and Yating Chai and K. S. Cheng and A. Chiavassa and M. Chikawa and L. Chytka and A. Cifuentes and J. L. Contreras and J. Cortina and H. Costantini and Giacomo D’Amico and M. Dalchenko and A. De Angelis and Mathieu de Bony de Lavergne and B. De Lotto and Raniere de Menezes and G. Deleglise and C. Delgado Mendez and J. Delgado and D. della Volpe and M. Dellaiera and Davide Depaoli and Ambra Di Piano and F. Di Pierro and R. Di Tria and L. Di Venere and C. Díaz and Rune Michael Dominik and D. Dominis Prester and Alice Donini and D. Dorner and M. Doro and Dominik Elsässer and Gabriel Emery and Juan Escudero and V. Fallah Ramazani and G. Ferrara and F. Ferrarotto and A. Fiasson and Lluís Freixas Coromina and Stefan Fröse and Satoshi Fukami and Y. Fukazawa and Enrique Alonso García and R. Garcia López and C. Gasbarra and D Gasparrini and Felix Geyer and J. Giesbrecht Paiva and N. Giglietto and F. Giordano and E. Giro and Paweł Gliwny and N. Godinović and R. Grau and D. Green and Jarred Gershon Green and Shuichi Gunji},
  title = {{Observations of the Crab Nebula and Pulsar with the Large-sized Telescope Prototype of the Cherenkov Telescope Array}},
  journal = {The Astrophysical Journal},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3847/1538-4357/ace89d},
}
Figure