Observational Needs for Improving Ocean and Coupled Reanalysis, S2S Prediction, and Decadal Prediction

Stephen G. Penny, Santha Akella, Magdalena Balmaseda, Philip Browne, James A. Carton, Matthieu Chevallier, François Counillon, Catia M. Domingues, Sergey Frolov, Patrick Heimbach, Patrick Hogan, Ibrahim Hoteit, Doroteaciro Iovino, Patrick Laloyaux, Matthew Martin, Simona Masina, Andrew M. Moore, Patricia de Rosnay, Dinand Schepers, Bernadette M. Sloyan, Andrea Storto, Aneesh C. Subramanian, SungHyun Nam, Frédéric Vitart, Chunxue Yang, Yosuke Fujii, Hao Zuo, T. Okane, Paul A. Sandery, Thomas Moore, Christopher ChapmanFrontiers in Marine Science 2019 · DOI

Abstract

Developments in observing system technologies and ocean data assimilation (DA) are symbiotic. New observation types lead to new DA methods and new DA methods, such as coupled DA, can change the value of existing observations or indicate where new observations can have greater utility for monitoring and prediction. Practitioners of DA are encouraged to make better use of observations that are already available, for example, taking advantage of strongly coupled DA so that ocean observations can be used to improve atmospheric analyses and vice versa. Ocean reanalyses are useful for the analysis of climate as well as the initialization of operational long-range prediction models. There are many remaining challenges for ocean reanalyses due to biases and abrupt changes in the ocean-observing system throughout its history, the presence of biases and drifts in models, and the simplifying assumptions made in DA solution methods. From a governance point of view, more support is needed to bring the ocean-observing and DA communities together. For prediction applications, there is wide agreement that protocols are needed for rapid communication of ocean-observing data on numerical weather prediction (NWP) timescales. There is potential for new observation types to enhance the observing system by supporting prediction on multiple timescales, ranging from the typical timescale of NWP, covering hours to weeks, out to multiple decades. Better communication between DA and observation communities is encouraged in order to allow operational prediction centers the ability to provide guidance for the design of a sustained and adaptive observing network.

Introduction

Predicting the Earth system is fundamentally a "missing data" problem. While satellite coverage of the ocean surface is extensive, the deep ocean remains largely unobserved, and small-scale processes at the air-sea interface are difficult to capture. Historically, the ocean and atmosphere were analyzed independently—a "weakly coupled" approach. This often leads to dynamical imbalances at the interface, where the two models "fight" each other, resulting in model drift and reduced forecast accuracy. This review by Penny et al. explores the critical symbiosis between ocean observing systems and data assimilation (DA), arguing for a shift toward "Strongly Coupled" Data Assimilation (SCDA) to improve weather and climate forecasts across timescales.

From Weak to Strong Coupling

The paper reviews the transition from standard DA to Coupled Data Assimilation (CDA):

  • Weakly Coupled DA (WCDA): DA is performed on each component (ocean, atmosphere, sea ice) separately. Information only exchanges during the model integration phase.
  • Strongly Coupled DA (SCDA): A more advanced approach where an observation in one domain (e.g., an ocean temperature profile) can directly adjust the state of another domain (e.g., atmospheric humidity) during the assimilation step. This relies on calculating cross-domain error covariances.
  • Direct Radiance Assimilation: Instead of using pre-processed "retrieval" products, the authors advocate for assimilating raw satellite brightness temperatures directly into coupled models. This ensures consistency across the air-sea interface and helps resolve the "diurnal skin temperature" of the ocean.

The Evolution of Ocean Observation

The historical growth of our "eyes" in the ocean has been staggering. The transition from sparse, ship-based measurements to the high-density Argo profiling float era has finally allowed for reliable global ocean heat content estimates and more robust reanalysis products like SODA3 and ORAS5.

Global availability of in situ temperature profiles by vertical depth from 1978 to 2013, showing the massive increase in data density in the 2000s.

Impact on Prediction Skill

The co-evolution of observing technologies and DA methods has led to dramatic improvements in forecast lead times. For example, the ability to predict the El Niño-Southern Oscillation (ENSO), measured by NINO3.4 correlation, has improved significantly with successive generations of DA systems. Conversely, withholding key data types, such as satellite altimetry, can increase global RMS Sea Surface Height innovations by as much as 16%.

Lead time in months at which NINO3.4 SST anomaly correlation drops below 0.9. Note the "NoObs" bar, showing the severe degradation in skill when ocean observations are withheld.

Future Challenges and Governance

Despite these advancements, several hurdles remain:

  • Computational Expense: SCDA is computationally punishing, requiring massive ensemble sizes or complex adjoint models.
  • Deep Ocean Blind Spot: Most current observations stop at 2000m, leaving the bottom half of the ocean's volume largely unmonitored.
  • Model Bias: DA cannot fully compensate for fundamental physical biases in models, such as the "cold tongue" bias in the Pacific.
  • Governance: The authors call for new protocols to treat ocean data with the same urgency as atmospheric data, reducing the "cut-off" time for real-time Numerical Weather Prediction (NWP).

Looking forward, the integration of Machine Learning (ML) may help produce dynamic subgrid-scale parameterizations, extracting more information from high-resolution satellite data without the full cost of traditional high-resolution modeling.

Summary updated

Abstract

Developments in observing system technologies and ocean data assimilation (DA) are symbiotic. New observation types lead to new DA methods and new DA methods, such as coupled DA, can change the value of existing observations or indicate where new observations can have greater utility for monitoring and prediction. Practitioners of DA are encouraged to make better use of observations that are already available, for example, taking advantage of strongly coupled DA so that ocean observations can be used to improve atmospheric analyses and vice versa. Ocean reanalyses are useful for the analysis of climate as well as the initialization of operational long-range prediction models. There are many remaining challenges for ocean reanalyses due to biases and abrupt changes in the ocean-observing system throughout its history, the presence of biases and drifts in models, and the simplifying assumptions made in DA solution methods. From a governance point of view, more support is needed to bring the ocean-observing and DA communities together. For prediction applications, there is wide agreement that protocols are needed for rapid communication of ocean-observing data on numerical weather prediction (NWP) timescales. There is potential for new observation types to enhance the observing system by supporting prediction on multiple timescales, ranging from the typical timescale of NWP, covering hours to weeks, out to multiple decades. Better communication between DA and observation communities is encouraged in order to allow operational prediction centers the ability to provide guidance for the design of a sustained and adaptive observing network.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{penny2019observational,
  author = {Stephen G. Penny and Santha Akella and Magdalena Balmaseda and Philip Browne and James A. Carton and Matthieu Chevallier and François Counillon and Catia M. Domingues and Sergey Frolov and Patrick Heimbach and Patrick Hogan and Ibrahim Hoteit and Doroteaciro Iovino and Patrick Laloyaux and Matthew Martin and Simona Masina and Andrew M. Moore and Patricia de Rosnay and Dinand Schepers and Bernadette M. Sloyan and Andrea Storto and Aneesh C. Subramanian and SungHyun Nam and Frédéric Vitart and Chunxue Yang and Yosuke Fujii and Hao Zuo and T. Okane and Paul A. Sandery and Thomas Moore and Christopher Chapman},
  title = {{Observational Needs for Improving Ocean and Coupled Reanalysis, S2S Prediction, and Decadal Prediction}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Marine Science},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.3389/fmars.2019.00391},
}
Figure