Observation of Very High Energy Gamma‐Ray Emission from the Active Galactic Nucleus 1ES 1959+650 Using the MAGIC Telescope

J. Albert, E. Aliu, H. Anderhub, P. Antoranz, A. Armada, M. Asensio, C. Baixeras, J. A. Barrio, H. Bartko, D. Bastieri, W. Bednarek, K. Berger, C. Bigongiari, A. Biland, Erica Bisesi, R. K. Böck, T. Bretz, I. Britvitch, Montaña Cámara, A. Chilingarian, S. Ciprini, J. A. Coarasa, S. Commichau, J. L. Contreras, J. Cortina, V. Danielyan, F. Dazzi, A. De Angelis, R. de los Reyes, B. De Lotto, E. Domingo-Santamaría, D. Dorner, M. Doro, M. Errando, D. Ferenc, E. Fernandez, R. Firpo, J. Flix, M. V. Fonseca, L. Font, N. Galante, M. Garczarczyk, M. Gaug, J. Gebauer, R. Giannitrapani, M. Giller, F. Göebel, D. Hakobyan, M. Hayashida, T. Hengstebeck, D. Höhne, J. Hose, P. Jacoń, O. Kalekin, D. Kranich, A. Laille, T. Lenisa, P. Liebing, E. Lindfors, F. Longo, Javier Castro López, Marcos López, E. Lorenz, F. Lucarelli, P. Majumdar, G. Maneva, K. Mannheim, M. Mariotti, M. Martı́nez, K. Mase, D. Mazin, C. Merck, M. Merck, M. Meucci, M. Meyer, J. M. Miranda, R. Mirzoyan, S. Mizobuchi, A. Moralejo, K. Nilsson, E. de Oña Wilhelmi, R. Orduña, A. N. Otte, D. Paneque, R. Paoletti, M. Pasanen, D. Pascoli, F. Pauss, N. Pavel, R. Pegna, L. Peruzzo, A. Piccioli, Massimo Del Pin, E. Prandini, J. Rico, W. Rhode, Bernhard Riegel, M. Rissi, A. RobertThe Astrophysical Journal 2006 · DOI

TL;DR

The MAGIC telescope has detected very high-energy (VHE) gamma-ray emission from the active galactic nucleus (AGN) 1ES 1959+650 during a period of low activity. This observation, extending down to 180 GeV, reveals a steady VHE emission component and provides a detailed spectrum that is steeper than that of the Crab Nebula.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Active Galactic Nuclei (AGNs), particularly those with X-ray peaked blazar (HBL) characteristics, are known to emit gamma rays across a wide energy spectrum. Understanding the mechanisms behind this emission, especially during quiescent states, is crucial for developing comprehensive models of AGN physics. Previous observations of 1ES 1959+650 had shown variability, including intriguing "orphan flares" where VHE gamma-ray emission occurred without a corresponding increase in X-ray activity, challenging standard synchrotron self-Compton (SSC) models. This paper aims to characterize the VHE gamma-ray emission of 1ES 1959+650 during a period of low activity, providing a detailed spectral measurement at lower energies than previously achieved and investigating its variability.

Methods

The study utilizes the MAGIC (Major Atmospheric Gamma Imaging Cherenkov) telescope, a next-generation Imaging Air Cherenkov Telescope (IACT). The MAGIC telescope's design allows for a lower energy threshold (down to 180 GeV in this analysis) compared to previous instruments like HEGRA and Whipple.

The data analysis involved:

  • Gamma-hadron separation: Classical techniques pioneered by the Whipple collaboration were employed, using image parameters of the Cherenkov showers to distinguish between gamma-ray-induced and cosmic-ray-induced events.
  • Parameter optimization: The Random Forest method was used to optimize the transformation of image parameters into a single "hadronness" variable for effective discrimination.
  • Energy and direction reconstruction: The image parameters were also used to reconstruct the arrival direction and energy of the detected gamma rays.
  • Background estimation: The background at low ALPHA values (an image parameter indicating the angle between the major axis of the shower image and the source direction) was estimated using both OFF-source data and by extrapolating the ALPHA distribution from ON-source events.
  • Spectral analysis: The differential energy spectrum was fitted with a power law.
  • Light curve analysis: The temporal variability of the gamma-ray flux was assessed by analyzing the data in nightly bins.

Datasets

  • 1ES 1959+650 data: Observed for approximately 6 hours in September and October 2004.
  • Crab Nebula data: Observed as a reference source for optimizing analysis cuts and for flux comparison.
  • OFF-source data: Used as a crosscheck for cosmic ray background.
  • RXTE-ASM X-ray flux data: Published data used for comparison with VHE gamma-ray activity.
  • Tuorla Observatory Blazar Monitoring Program optical data: Used for comparison with VHE gamma-ray activity.
  • HEGRA spectral data: Previously published data at higher energies for spectral comparison.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Steady Quiescent Emission: The detection of a statistically significant VHE gamma-ray signal from 1ES 1959+650 during a period of low optical and X-ray activity suggests the presence of a steady, underlying VHE emission component, not solely driven by flaring activity.
  • Lower Energy Threshold: The MAGIC telescope's ability to observe down to 180 GeV provides crucial new information about the low-energy end of the VHE spectrum, which was previously inaccessible.
  • Steeper Spectrum: The VHE gamma-ray spectrum of 1ES 1959+650 in the observed energy range is found to be steeper than that of the Crab Nebula, indicating differences in the emission processes or particle populations.
  • Lack of Variability: The absence of significant variations in the VHE gamma-ray light curve over the observation period further supports the idea of a quiescent state, contrasting with previous observations that showed significant flaring.

Key Results

  • Significance: A VHE gamma-ray signal from 1ES 1959+650 with an 8.2 sigma significance was detected.
  • Excess Events: 246 ± 30 excess events were observed in approximately 6 hours of observation.
  • Integral Flux: The integral VHE gamma-ray flux above 180 GeV was measured to be (3.73 ± 0.41 ± 0.35) × 10⁻¹¹ photons cm⁻² s⁻¹, which is about 20% of the Crab Nebula flux.
  • Flux above 300 GeV: The flux above 300 GeV was (1.57 ± 0.17 ± 0.30) × 10⁻¹¹ photons cm⁻² s⁻¹.
  • Differential Spectrum: The energy spectrum between 180 GeV and 2 TeV can be fitted with a power law of index -2.72 ± 0.14.
  • Comparison with Crab: The spectrum of 1ES 1959+650 is found to be steeper than that of the Crab Nebula over the observed energy range.
  • Light Curve: The light curve, sampled over 7 days, showed no significant variations.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited Observation Time: The ~6 hours of observation time, while sufficient for a significant detection, limits the detailed study of variability. Longer observation campaigns are needed to fully characterize the source's temporal behavior.
  • Quiescent State Definition: The paper notes that there is no unique definition of a "low state" for AGNs, which can complicate comparisons with previous observations.
  • Extrapolation to EBL: The paper discusses the question of whether the cumulative VHE flux from multiple HBLs in a low state could contribute to the diffuse extragalactic background light (EBL). While their findings suggest this is unlikely to fully explain the EGRET diffuse spectrum, further measurements are needed.
  • Multi-wavelength Monitoring: The authors emphasize the need for multi-wavelength monitoring campaigns to further unravel the nature of the VHE emission component in 1ES 1959+650.
  • Neutrino Astronomy: The paper highlights the potential for future neutrino observatories to probe the emission mechanisms, especially if hadronic components are involved, referencing recent tantalizing hints from AMANDA.

Summary updated

Abstract

The MAGIC Cerenkov telescope has observed very high energy (VHE) gamma-ray emission from the active galactic nucleus 1ES 1959+650 during 6 hr in 2004 September and October. The observations were carried out alternating with observations of the Crab Nebula, whose data were used as a reference source for optimizing gamma -ray/hadron separation and for flux comparison. The data analysis shows VHE gamma-ray emission of 1ES 1959+650 with similar to 8 sigma significance, at a time of low activity in both optical and X-ray wavelengths. An integral flux above similar to 180 GeV of about 20% that of the Crab Nebula was obtained. The light curve, sampled over 7 days, shows no significant variations. The differential energy spectrum between 180 GeV and 2 TeV can be fitted with a power-law of index -2.72 +/- 0.14. The spectrum is consistent with the slightly steeper spectrum seen by HEGRA at higher energies, also during periods of low X-ray activity.
BibTeX
@article{albert2006observation,
  author = {J. Albert and E. Aliu and H. Anderhub and P. Antoranz and A. Armada and M. Asensio and C. Baixeras and J. A. Barrio and H. Bartko and D. Bastieri and W. Bednarek and K. Berger and C. Bigongiari and A. Biland and Erica Bisesi and R. K. Böck and T. Bretz and I. Britvitch and Montaña Cámara and A. Chilingarian and S. Ciprini and J. A. Coarasa and S. Commichau and J. L. Contreras and J. Cortina and V. Danielyan and F. Dazzi and A. De Angelis and R. de los Reyes and B. De Lotto and E. Domingo-Santamaría and D. Dorner and M. Doro and M. Errando and D. Ferenc and E. Fernandez and R. Firpo and J. Flix and M. V. Fonseca and L. Font and N. Galante and M. Garczarczyk and M. Gaug and J. Gebauer and R. Giannitrapani and M. Giller and F. Göebel and D. Hakobyan and M. Hayashida and T. Hengstebeck and D. Höhne and J. Hose and P. Jacoń and O. Kalekin and D. Kranich and A. Laille and T. Lenisa and P. Liebing and E. Lindfors and F. Longo and Javier Castro López and Marcos López and E. Lorenz and F. Lucarelli and P. Majumdar and G. Maneva and K. Mannheim and M. Mariotti and M. Martı́nez and K. Mase and D. Mazin and C. Merck and M. Merck and M. Meucci and M. Meyer and J. M. Miranda and R. Mirzoyan and S. Mizobuchi and A. Moralejo and K. Nilsson and E. de Oña Wilhelmi and R. Orduña and A. N. Otte and R. Mirzoyan and D. Paneque and R. Paoletti and M. Pasanen and D. Pascoli and F. Pauss and N. Pavel and R. Pegna and L. Peruzzo and A. Piccioli and Massimo Del Pin and E. Prandini and J. Rico and W. Rhode and Bernhard Riegel and M. Rissi and A. Robert},
  title = {{Observation of Very High Energy Gamma‐Ray Emission from the Active Galactic Nucleus 1ES 1959+650 Using the MAGIC Telescope}},
  journal = {The Astrophysical Journal},
  year = {2006},
  doi = {10.1086/499421},
}
Figure