TL;DR
The BABAR experiment has observed a specific bottomonium state, the $\Upsilon(1^3D_J)$ with $J=2$, through its decay into $\pi^+\pi^-\Upsilon(1S)$. This observation provides crucial experimental confirmation of theoretical predictions for heavier bottomonium states and allows for a more precise measurement of its mass.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Understanding the spectrum of heavy quark bound states, like bottomonium (a bound state of a bottom quark and anti-bottom quark), is fundamental to testing and refining models of the strong nuclear force (Quantum Chromodynamics). While the lighter S-wave and P-wave bottomonium states are well-studied, heavier states, particularly those with orbital angular momentum (like D-wave states), have been more elusive. The $\Upsilon(1^3D_J)$ triplet ($J=1, 2, 3$) is predicted to exist, but experimental evidence has been scarce. Previous observations of a D-wave state were tentative and lacked definitive quantum number assignments. This paper aims to provide clear experimental evidence for a specific member of this triplet and to precisely measure its properties, thereby contributing to a more complete picture of the bottomonium spectrum.
Methods
The experiment utilized a large dataset of $\Upsilon(3S)$ decays collected by the BABAR detector. The core of the analysis involved reconstructing a specific decay chain: $\Upsilon(3S) \rightarrow \gamma\gamma\Upsilon(1^3D_J) \rightarrow \gamma\gamma\pi^+\pi^-\Upsilon(1S)$. The $\Upsilon(1S)$ was identified through its decays into lepton pairs ($\text{e}^+\text{e}^-$ or $\mu^+\mu^-$).
Key methodological aspects include:
- Event Reconstruction: Identifying events with exactly four charged tracks consistent with the decay chain, and requiring specific particle identification for leptons and pions.
- Background Rejection: Implementing sophisticated criteria to suppress various background processes, such as Bhabha scattering and other $\Upsilon(3S)$ decay modes. This involved using kinematic variables like the cosine of polar angles and invariant mass distributions.
- Maximum Likelihood Fit: An extended unbinned maximum likelihood fit was performed on the invariant mass distribution of the $\pi^+\pi^-\Upsilon(1S)$ system. This fit simultaneously modeled the signal for the three potential $\Upsilon(1^3D_J)$ states ($J=1, 2, 3$) and four distinct background categories.
- PDF Derivation: Probability Density Functions (PDFs) for signal and background components were derived from Monte Carlo simulations, incorporating detector response and known physics processes.
- Systematic Uncertainty Evaluation: A thorough assessment of systematic uncertainties was conducted, considering factors like luminosity, reconstruction efficiencies, PDF parameter variations, and background yield uncertainties.
- Quantum Number Tests: To confirm the assignment of the observed state as a D-wave ($L=2$) with $J=2$, the analysis examined the $\pi^+\pi^-$ invariant mass spectrum, the angle between the lepton pair and pion pair planes, and the pion helicity angle.
Datasets
The analysis is based on a sample of $(121.8 \pm 1.2) \times 10^6$ $\Upsilon(3S)$ decays collected by the BABAR detector, corresponding to an integrated luminosity of 28.6 fb$^{-1}$. Monte Carlo (MC) event samples were extensively used for simulating detector response, determining signal and background characteristics, and optimizing selection criteria.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Observation of $\Upsilon(1^3D_2)$: The most significant finding is the clear observation of the $\Upsilon(1^3D_2)$ state, a D-wave bottomonium resonance, through its decay into $\pi^+\pi^-\Upsilon(1S)$. This provides strong experimental validation for theoretical predictions of heavier quarkonium states.
- Precise Mass Measurement: The mass of the $\Upsilon(1^3D_2)$ state was determined with improved precision compared to previous measurements, offering a valuable data point for refining potential models.
- Confirmation of Quantum Numbers: The analysis of angular distributions (specifically the $\pi^+\pi^-$ invariant mass, the angle between lepton and pion planes, and the pion helicity angle) strongly supports the assignment of $L=2$, $J=2$, and negative parity ($P=-1$) to the observed state, consistent with it being the dominant member of the $\Upsilon(1^3D_J)$ triplet.
- Branching Fraction Determination: The paper reports branching fractions (or upper limits) for the decay of the $\Upsilon(1^3D_J)$ states into $\pi^+\pi^-\Upsilon(1S)$, which are found to be in good agreement with theoretical predictions.
Key Results
- Significance: The statistical significance for the $J=2$ member of the $\Upsilon(1^3D_J)$ triplet is 5.8 standard deviations, including systematic uncertainties.
- Mass: The mass of the $\Upsilon(1^3D_2)$ state is measured to be $10164.5 \pm 0.8 (\text{stat.}) \pm 0.5 (\text{syst.})$ MeV/c$^2$.
- Event Yields: The fit yielded $10.6 \pm 3$ events for $\Upsilon(1^3D_1)$, $33.9 \pm 3$ for $\Upsilon(1^3D_2)$, and $9.4^{+6.2}_{-5.2}$ for $\Upsilon(1^3D_3)$.
- Branching Fractions:
- $B[\Upsilon(1^3D_1) \rightarrow \pi^+\pi^-\Upsilon(1S)]$: $0.42 \pm 0.23 \pm 0.10\%$ (or $<0.82\%$ at 90% CL).
- $B[\Upsilon(1^3D_2) \rightarrow \pi^+\pi^-\Upsilon(1S)]$: $0.66 \pm 0.15 \pm 0.06\%$.
- $B[\Upsilon(1^3D_3) \rightarrow \pi^+\pi^-\Upsilon(1S)]$: $0.29 \pm 0.22 \pm 0.06\%$ (or $<0.62\%$ at 90% CL).
Limitations and Future Work
- Low Significance for $J=1$ and $J=3$: The statistical significance for the $\Upsilon(1^3D_1)$ and $\Upsilon(1^3D_3)$ states is low, meaning clear evidence for these specific states is not established in this analysis. Upper limits are provided for their branching fractions.
- Model Dependence: The determination of branching fractions relies on predicted ratios of branching fractions for different intermediate states ($\Upsilon(3S) \rightarrow \gamma\chi_{bJ}(2P)$ and $\chi_{bJ}(2P) \rightarrow \gamma\Upsilon(1^3D_J)$), introducing some model dependence.
- Future Work: The paper suggests that further studies could focus on improving the precision of the branching fraction measurements and potentially searching for other decay modes of these D-wave states. The observed fluctuations in the mass spectrum could also warrant further investigation.
Summary updated