Observation of the Anomalous Shape of $X(1840)$ in $J/ψ\rightarrow γ3(π^+ π^-)$ Indicating a Second Resonance Near $p\bar{p}$ Threshold

Besiii Collaboration, F. De Mori, М. Н. Ачасов, P. Adlarson, X. Ai, R. Aliberti, A. Amoroso, M. R. An, Q. An, Y. Bai, O. Bakina, I. Balossino, Y. Ban, V. Batozskaya, K. Begzsuren, N. Berger, M. Berlowski, M. Bertani, D. Bettoni, F. Bianchi, E. Bianco, A. Bortone, I. Boyko, R. A. Briere, A. Brueggemann, H. Cai, X. Cai, A. Calcaterra, G. F. Cao, N. Cao, Selim Çetin, J. F. Chang, T. T. Chang, W. L. Chang, G. R. Che, G. Chelkov, C. Chen, G. Chen, H. S. Chen, M. L. Chen, S. J. Chen, T. Chen, X. R. Chen, Y. B. Chen, Z. J. Chen, W. S. Cheng, S. K. Choi, X. Chu, G. Cibinetto, S. C. Coen, F. Cossio, J. J. Cui, H. L. Dai, J. P. Dai, A. Dbeyssi, R. E. de Boer, Dmitri Dedovich, Z. Y. Deng, A. Denig, I. Denysenko, M. Destefanis, B. Ding, X. X. Ding, Yibing Ding, J. Dong, L. Y. Dong, M. Y. Dong, X. Dong, M. C. Du, S. X. Du, Z. H. Duan, P. Egorov, Y. H. Fan, J. Fang, S. S. Fang, W. X. Fang, Y. Fang, R. Farinelli, L. Fava, F. Feldbauer, G. Felici, C. Q. Feng, J. H. Feng, K Fischer, M. Fritsch, C. Fritzsch, C. D. Fu, J. Fu, Y. W. Fu, H. Gao, Yu Gao, Yang GaoarXiv 2023 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Using a sample of $(10087\pm44)\times 10^6$ $J/ψ$ events—approximately 45 times larger than previous studies—researchers at the BESIII experiment have performed a detailed investigation of the $J/ψ\rightarrow γ3(π^+π^-)$ decay. For the first time, a significant distortion in the line-shape of the $3(π^+π^-)$ invariant mass spectrum was observed at 1.84 GeV/$c^2$. This anomaly is resolved by the presence of two overlapping resonant structures: the known $X(1840)$ and a newly identified state, $X(1880)$. The $X(1880)$ is observed with a statistical significance exceeding $10σ$. Its mass and width are determined to be $1882.1\pm1.7\pm0.7$ MeV/$c^2$ and $30.7\pm5.5 \pm2.4$ MeV, respectively, strongly suggesting the existence of a $p\bar{p}$ bound state.

Introduction: The Search for Baryonium

In the standard model of particle physics, most hadrons are either mesons (quark-antiquark) or baryons (three quarks). However, Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD) predicts more exotic configurations, including "baryonium"—a molecule-like bound state of a baryon and an anti-baryon.

Physicists have long searched for these states near the proton-antiproton ($p\bar{p}$) mass threshold (approximately 1.88 GeV/$c^2$). While the $X(1840)$ resonance was discovered previously, its internal structure remained ambiguous. This study investigates whether the "anomalous" shape of the $X(1840)$ peak hides a more complex reality, specifically looking for signatures of a $p\bar{p}$ bound state.

Methodology and Dataset

The analysis was conducted using the BESIII detector at the Beijing Electron Positron Collider (BEPCII), focusing on the decay $J/\psi \to \gamma 3(\pi^+\pi^-)$. The dataset comprised over 10 billion $J/\psi$ events, providing the statistical precision necessary to resolve fine structures in the mass spectrum.

The team employed an unbinned maximum likelihood fit to analyze the $3(\pi^+\pi^-)$ invariant mass spectrum. They compared two primary models:

  1. Model I: A single-resonance model using a Flatté formula to account for threshold effects.
  2. Model II: A model featuring two interfering resonances, $X(1840)$ and the new $X(1880)$.
Comparison of the $M(6\pi)$ invariant mass spectrum fits using a single resonance (a) and two interfering resonances (b). The interference between $X(1840)$ and $X(1880)$ in Model II better describes the observed distortion.

Key Insights: Resolving the Distortion

The massive increase in data revealed that the $X(1840)$ peak was not a simple, smooth curve. A distinct distortion near 1.84 GeV/$c^2$ suggested quantum interference between two states. By modeling the signal as two interfering resonances (Model II), the fit quality improved dramatically, with the $\chi^2/ndof$ dropping from 399.0/45 to 155.6/41.

The proximity of the new $X(1880)$ state to the $p\bar{p}$ threshold ($2 \times 938.3$ MeV $\approx 1876.6$ MeV) is a "smoking gun" for its interpretation as a baryonium candidate. Furthermore, this dual-resonance model explains why previous measurements of the $X(1840)$ width seemed unusually narrow; the overlap with $X(1880)$ created an optical illusion in lower-statistics data.

Results

The discovery of $X(1880)$ is established with a significance of over $10\sigma$. The final parameters for both states are summarized in the table below.

Measured mass, width, and branching fractions for the $X(1840)$ and $X(1880)$ states across two mathematical solutions.

The mass of $X(1880)$ was determined to be $1882.1 \pm 1.7 \pm 0.7$ MeV/$c^2$ with a width of $30.7 \pm 5.5 \pm 2.4$ MeV. The original $X(1840)$ mass was refined to $1832.5 \pm 3.1 \pm 2.5$ MeV/$c^2$.

Conclusion and Future Outlook

While the proximity to the $p\bar{p}$ threshold strongly suggests a baryonium state, other interpretations, such as a radial excitation of the $\eta^\prime$ meson, remain possible. Future work will involve a formal Partial Wave Analysis (PWA) to definitively confirm the spin-parity quantum numbers of these states. Additionally, studying complementary decay modes like $J/\psi \to \gamma p\bar{p}$ will be essential to fully characterize the interaction between these resonances and the proton-antiproton threshold.

Summary updated

Abstract

Using a sample of $(10087\pm44)\times 10^6$ $J/ψ$ events, which is about 45 times larger than that was previously analyzed, a further investigation on the $J/ψ\rightarrow γ3(π^+π^-)$ decay is performed. A significant distortion at 1.84 GeV/$c^2$ in the line-shape of the $3(π^+π^-)$ invariant mass spectrum is observed for the first time, which could be resolved by two overlapping resonant structures, $X(1840)$ and $X(1880)$. The new state $X(1880)$ is observed with a statistical significance larger than $10σ$. The mass and width of $X(1880)$ are determined to be $1882.1\pm1.7\pm0.7$ MeV/$c^2$ and $30.7\pm5.5 \pm2.4$ MeV, respectively, which indicates the existence of a $p\bar{p}$ bound state.
BibTeX
@misc{collaboration2023observation,
  author = {BESIII Collaboration and F. De Mori and М. Н. Ачасов and P. Adlarson and X. Ai and R. Aliberti and A. Amoroso and M. R. An and Q. An and Y. Bai and O. Bakina and I. Balossino and Y. Ban and V. Batozskaya and K. Begzsuren and N. Berger and M. Berlowski and M. Bertani and D. Bettoni and F. Bianchi and E. Bianco and A. Bortone and I. Boyko and R. A. Briere and A. Brueggemann and H. Cai and X. Cai and A. Calcaterra and G. F. Cao and N. Cao and Selim Çetin and J. F. Chang and T. T. Chang and W. L. Chang and G. R. Che and G. Chelkov and C. Chen and Chao Chen and G. Chen and H. S. Chen and M. L. Chen and S. J. Chen and S. L. Chen and S. M. Chen and T. Chen and X. R. Chen and X. T. Chen and Y. B. Chen and Y. Q. Chen and Z. J. Chen and W. S. Cheng and S. K. Choi and X. Chu and G. Cibinetto and S. C. Coen and F. Cossio and J. J. Cui and H. L. Dai and J. P. Dai and A. Dbeyssi and R. E. de Boer and Dmitri Dedovich and Z. Y. Deng and A. Denig and I. Denysenko and M. Destefanis and F. De Mori and B. Ding and X. X. Ding and Yibing Ding and Yibing Ding and J. Dong and L. Y. Dong and M. Y. Dong and X. Dong and M. C. Du and S. X. Du and Z. H. Duan and P. Egorov and Y. H. Fan and Y. L. Fan and J. Fang and S. S. Fang and W. X. Fang and Y. Fang and R. Farinelli and L. Fava and F. Feldbauer and G. Felici and C. Q. Feng and J. H. Feng and K Fischer and M. Fritsch and C. Fritzsch and C. D. Fu and J. Fu and Y. W. Fu and H. Gao and Yu Gao and Yang Gao},
  title = {{Observation of the Anomalous Shape of $X(1840)$ in $J/ψ\textbackslash\{\}rightarrow γ3(π^+ π^-)$ Indicating a Second Resonance Near $p\textbackslash\{\}bar\{p\}$ Threshold}},
  year = {2023},
  eprint = {2310.17937},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2310.17937},
}
Figure