Observation of strong and weak thermalization in a superconducting quantum processor

Fusheng Chen, Zheng‐Hang Sun, Ming Gong, Qingling Zhu, Yu-Ran Zhang, Yulin Wu, Yangsen Ye, Chen Zha, Shaowei Li, Shaojun Guo, Haoran Qian, He-Liang Huang, Jiale Yu, Hui Deng, Hao Rong, Jin Lin, Yu Xu, Lihua Sun, Cheng Guo, Na Li, Futian Liang, Cheng-Zhi Peng, Heng Fan, Xiaobo Zhu, Jian-Wei PanarXiv 2021 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

We experimentally study the ergodic dynamics of a 1D array of 12 superconducting qubits with a transverse field, and identify the regimes of strong and weak thermalization with different initial states. We observe convergence of the local observable to its thermal expectation value in the strong-thermalization regime. For weak thermalization, the dynamics of local observable exhibits an oscillation around the thermal value, which can only be attained by the time average. We also demonstrate that the entanglement entropy and concurrence can characterize the regimes of strong and weak thermalization. Our work provides an essential step towards a generic understanding of thermalization in quantum systems.

Introduction

In classical statistical mechanics, thermalization is a well-understood process where a system eventually reaches a predictable equilibrium state, such as the Maxwell-Boltzmann distribution. However, in the quantum realm, the situation is more complex. A closed quantum system evolves unitarily, meaning it preserves all information about its initial state. This raises a fundamental question: how does such a system "thermalize"?

Physicists distinguish between two primary regimes of quantum thermalization:

  1. Strong Thermalization: Local properties of the system rapidly converge to steady thermal values, effectively losing memory of the initial state.
  2. Weak Thermalization: Local properties oscillate around a thermal average without settling, meaning only the time-averaged state appears thermal.

While theoretical models predicted these behaviors, experimental observation in controlled, non-integrable many-body systems has remained a significant challenge.

Experimental Methods

The researchers utilized a high-precision superconducting quantum processor featuring a 1D array of 12 transmon qubits. To explore thermalization, they implemented a non-integrable Hamiltonian—a version of the Ising model with a controllable transverse field. Non-integrability is essential for thermalization, as integrable systems possess too many conserved quantities to reach a standard thermal equilibrium.

Experimental setup including the 12-qubit array, pulse sequence, and energy landscape.

The system was initialized in various "spin coherent states" defined by angles $(\theta_0, \phi_0)$, allowing the team to tune the effective temperature of the starting state. Following evolution for up to 300 ns, Quantum State Tomography (QST) was employed to reconstruct density matrices, enabling the calculation of local observables, Entanglement Entropy (EE), and concurrence.

Key Insights and Results

The study revealed that thermalization behavior is highly sensitive to the initial state. States with an effective inverse temperature near zero (high energy density) exhibited strong thermalization, while those further from zero showed weak thermalization.

Time evolution of local observables and entanglement entropy for strong (left) and weak (right) thermalization regimes.

Observable Convergence and Entanglement

In the strong thermalization regime (e.g., initial state $|\pi, 0\rangle$), the local observable $\langle \sigma^z \rangle$ stabilized to zero within approximately 150 ns. In contrast, the weak regime (e.g., $|\pi/2, \pi/4\rangle$) displayed persistent oscillations around the thermal value.

Entanglement dynamics also served as a clear differentiator. In the strong regime, Entanglement Entropy (EE) grew rapidly to the "Page value" ($\approx 0.692$ for a single qubit), indicating the qubit had become fully scrambled within the many-body system. In the weak regime, EE grew more slowly and reached a lower plateau. Furthermore, while concurrence (a measure of qubit-qubit entanglement) vanished quickly in the strong regime, it remained finite in the weak regime, suggesting that quantum correlations can persist through the thermalization process.

Conclusion

This work demonstrates the successful observation of distinct thermalization regimes on a superconducting quantum processor. While decoherence remains a limiting factor for long-time dynamics, the results are robust and align well with numerical simulations. This platform provides a powerful tool for exploring exotic non-equilibrium phases of matter, such as Many-Body Localization (MBL) and Discrete Time Crystals, moving closer to a comprehensive understanding of quantum statistical mechanics.

Summary updated

Abstract

We experimentally study the ergodic dynamics of a 1D array of 12 superconducting qubits with a transverse field, and identify the regimes of strong and weak thermalization with different initial states. We observe convergence of the local observable to its thermal expectation value in the strong-thermalizaion regime. For weak thermalization, the dynamics of local observable exhibits an oscillation around the thermal value, which can only be attained by the time average. We also demonstrate that the entanglement entropy and concurrence can characterize the regimes of strong and weak thermalization. Our work provides an essential step towards a generic understanding of thermalization in quantum systems.
BibTeX
@misc{chen2021observation,
  author = {Fusheng Chen and Zheng‐Hang Sun and Ming Gong and Qingling Zhu and Yu-Ran Zhang and Yulin Wu and Yangsen Ye and Chen Zha and Shaowei Li and Shaojun Guo and Haoran Qian and He-Liang Huang and Jiale Yu and Hui Deng and Hao Rong and Jin Lin and Yu Xu and Lihua Sun and Cheng Guo and Na Li and Futian Liang and Cheng-Zhi Peng and Heng Fan and Xiaobo Zhu and Jian-Wei Pan},
  title = {{Observation of strong and weak thermalization in a superconducting quantum processor}},
  year = {2021},
  eprint = {2102.08587},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2102.08587},
}
Figure