Objective Prediction Tracking Control Technology Assisted by Inertial Information

Yue Leng, Sheng ZhongJournal of Marine Science and Engineering 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel tracking control system for electro-optical equipment that significantly improves accuracy for high-mobility targets by fusing high-frequency inertial navigation data with traditional tracking information. This approach effectively mitigates delays inherent in optical tracking, leading to a threefold increase in accuracy and a substantial reduction in tracking errors.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Maritime electro-optical tracking systems often struggle with reduced accuracy when tracking fast-moving targets like speedboats and aircraft. This inaccuracy stems from inherent delays in acquiring and processing "off-target" error information (the deviation between the target and the center of the camera's field of view). These delays are caused by factors like image sensor frame rates and processing times, leading to a lag between the target's actual position and the system's perceived position. Traditional control methods, which heavily rely on the target's current observed position, are thus compromised. The paper aims to overcome this by developing a system that can predict the target's future position more accurately, even with these inherent delays.

Methods

The core innovation lies in fusing high-frequency inertial navigation data with traditional optical tracking data. The proposed method involves:

  • Multi-Spatial Frame Attitude Information Fusion: Inertial Measurement Unit (IMU) data provides high-frequency attitude information (pitch, roll, yaw) of the tracking platform. This data is used to transform the target's position information across multiple coordinate systems: the imaging frame, the carrier frame (the platform itself), and the geographic frame. This transformation helps to account for the platform's own motion and disturbances.
  • Target Prediction Algorithm: By leveraging the fused attitude information and the delayed off-target error, the system predicts the target's trajectory in the relatively stable geographic coordinate system. This prediction is crucial for compensating for the lag in the off-target error signal. The method effectively interpolates and resamples the low-frequency off-target deviation data to match the high-frequency update rate of the inertial data.
  • Interdisciplinary Fusion: The approach deeply integrates inertial navigation technology with tracking control technology, moving beyond traditional methods that solely rely on optical feedback or simplified object models.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The experiments were conducted using a specific maritime electro-optical tracking platform with a simulated moving target.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Inertial Data as a Game-Changer: High-frequency inertial data isn't just for stabilizing the platform; it's a critical source of information for predicting the target's motion, effectively bridging the gap caused by optical system delays.
  • Coordinate Transformation is Key: Projecting target information across imaging, carrier, and geographic frames allows for a more robust understanding of the target's position relative to the environment, independent of the tracking platform's own dynamics.
  • Prediction Over Pure Compensation: Instead of just trying to compensate for the delay, the system actively predicts where the target will be, offering a more proactive approach to tracking.
  • Bridging Discrete and Continuous: The method effectively bridges the gap between discrete, low-frequency optical measurements and the continuous, high-frequency motion of the target and platform.

Key Results

  • Significant Accuracy Improvement: The proposed target prediction and tracking control technique achieved approximately a threefold increase in tracking accuracy for high-speed targets compared to traditional methods.
  • Reduced Off-Target Error: Under identical experimental conditions, the statistical values of off-target measurements were reduced from 1.8 mrad to 633 µrad.
  • Enhanced Real-time Performance: The integration of high-frequency inertial data and the prediction algorithm significantly improves the update frequency and real-time performance of the tracking control position loop.
  • Superiority over Existing Methods: Experimental comparisons showed the proposed method outperforming both a standard PI control technique and an improved Smith predictor method, particularly in scenarios with significant target motion and platform disturbances.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Integration Requirement: The method requires the complete integration of inertial navigation components within the tracking system, not just gyroscope components.
  • Model-Free vs. Model-Based: While the paper highlights advantages over model-dependent methods, the effectiveness of the prediction algorithm might still be influenced by the complexity of target motion that deviates significantly from predictable patterns.
  • Future Work: The paper suggests that this approach offers a technology-based optimization and demonstrates excellent performance for high-speed moving targets, implying potential for broader applications in various tracking scenarios. Further validation in diverse operational environments could be a natural next step.

Summary updated

Abstract

This paper addresses the challenge of reduced tracking accuracy in maritime electro-optical tracking equipment when dealing with high-mobility targets like speedboats and aircraft due to off-target error delays. We propose an innovative technique that leverages inertial navigation data to enhance target prediction and tracking control. Our approach involves the real-time integration of high-frequency inertial navigation-derived attitude information into the tracking system. By combining off-target error information with angular measurements from the tracking mechanism, we project the vector of the tracked target into multiple coordinate systems, including the imaging coordinate system, carrier coordinate system, and geographic coordinate system. Subsequently, we model and predict the target’s motion trajectory in the relatively slow-changing geographic coordinate system. This transformation process increases the update frequency and real-time performance of the tracking control position loop command angle. Unlike traditional control methods that heavily rely on the model of the controlled object, our approach significantly improves tracking accuracy and engineering applicability. It offers a technology-based optimization of tracking and control performance through an interdisciplinary theoretical fusion, deeply integrating inertial navigation technology with tracking control technology. Experimental results with maritime electro-optical tracking equipment demonstrate that our proposed control technique increases tracking accuracy for high-speed targets by approximately threefold compared to traditional methods. Under the same experimental conditions, the off-target error statistics are reduced from 1.8 mrad to 633 μrad.
BibTeX
@article{leng2023objective,
  author = {Yue Leng and Sheng Zhong},
  title = {{Objective Prediction Tracking Control Technology Assisted by Inertial Information}},
  journal = {Journal of Marine Science and Engineering},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/jmse11112175},
}
Figure