Objective measures of reward sensitivity and motivation in people with high vs low anhedonia

Chloe Slaney, Adam M. Perkins, Robert E. Davis, Ian S. Penton‐Voak, Marcus R. Munafò, Conor Houghton, Emma RobinsonmedRxiv 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This study uses a battery of "cross-species" behavioral tasks to show that anhedonia—the loss of pleasure—is not a monolithic symptom. By comparing high- and low-anhedonia individuals, researchers found that while high anhedonia is linked to reduced reward sensitivity and impaired effort-based decision-making, these deficits don't necessarily overlap in the same person, suggesting distinct biological subgroups.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Anhedonia is a hallmark of Major Depressive Disorder (MDD), yet it remains notoriously difficult to treat with standard antidepressants. A major hurdle is that "anhedonia" is an umbrella term covering several distinct processes: motivation (the drive to get a reward), consummatory experience (the actual "liking" or detection of the reward), and learning.

Currently, clinicians rely heavily on subjective self-report questionnaires. This paper seeks to move toward "objective biomarkers" by using behavioral tasks that are directly translated from rodent research. By dissociating these reward components, the authors aim to provide a more granular understanding of the "mechanistic plumbing" behind depression, which is vital for developing targeted drug therapies.

Methods

The researchers recruited a non-clinical population (primarily students) and split them into two groups based on their scores on the Snaith-Hamilton Pleasure Scale (SHAPS). They then put participants through three objective tasks:

  1. Effort-Expenditure for Rewards Task (EEfRT): A classic "decision-making" task where participants choose between an easy task for a small reward or a harder task (more button presses) for a larger reward.
  2. Joystick-Operated Runway Task (JORT): A novel adaptation of a task used to measure fear in rodents. Here, it measures physical effort exertion. Participants use a force-sensing joystick to "chase" an onscreen target; the harder they push, the faster they go.
  3. Sweet Taste Test: Unlike previous studies that asked how much people liked sugar, this used a "staircase method" to find the detection threshold—the minimum concentration of sucrose a person needs to even notice the sweetness.

Datasets

The study involved a primary analysis of 66 participants (34 low anhedonia, 32 high anhedonia) selected from an initial screening of 380 volunteers. While the sample size is modest, the researchers focused on a "symptom-based approach" (aligned with the RDoC framework) rather than a binary "depressed vs. healthy" diagnosis.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Wanting" vs. "Doing" Dissociation: One of the most striking findings was that while high-anhedonia individuals were less likely to choose a hard task (EEfRT), they exerted the same amount of physical force as the low-anhedonia group once the task began (JORT). This suggests anhedonia affects the cognitive decision to engage, rather than the physical capacity to work.
  • Sensory Blunting: High anhedonia was significantly linked to a higher threshold for detecting sweetness. This supports the idea of "sensory anhedonia," where the world quite literally feels less intense.
  • The Heterogeneity Hypothesis: Crucially, performance on the Sweet Taste Test did not correlate with performance on the EEfRT. This is the "aha" moment: it suggests that one person’s anhedonia might be driven by a "liking/detection" deficit, while another’s is driven by a "wanting/motivation" deficit. They are distinct flavors of the same symptom.

Key Results

  • Reward Sensitivity: The high-anhedonia group required a significantly higher concentration of sucrose to detect sugar ($p = .037$).
  • Effort-Based Decision-Making: The high-anhedonia group chose the "hard" option less frequently than the low-anhedonia group ($p = .039$), though the authors note this evidence was modest.
  • Physical Effort: There was no evidence of a difference between groups in the JORT ($p = .95$). Both groups scaled their physical force appropriately based on the size of the reward.
  • Cross-Task Correlation: EEfRT and JORT scores were positively correlated ($r = .21$), suggesting they measure related aspects of motivation, but neither correlated with the Sweet Taste Test.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Population: The study used a non-clinical, predominantly student sample. Anhedonia in clinical MDD may be qualitatively different or more severe.
  • Sex Imbalance: The high-anhedonia group had a higher proportion of males (53% vs 21%). While the authors controlled for this statistically, it remains a factor for future study.
  • Liking vs. Detecting: The Sweet Taste Test measured detection, not "pleasure" (liking). Future work should include objective measures of hedonic impact that don't rely on point scales.
  • Subgrouping: To truly prove the existence of anhedonia "subtypes," much larger samples are needed to perform cluster analyses across a wider battery of tasks (including reward learning).

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Background Anhedonia – a diminished interest or pleasure in activities – is a core self-reported symptom of depression which is poorly understood and often resistant to conventional antidepressants. This symptom may occur due to dysfunction in one or more sub-components of reward processing: motivation, consummatory experience, and/or learning. However, the precise impairments remain elusive. Dissociating these components (ideally, using cross-species measures) and relating them to the subjective experience of anhedonia is critical as it may benefit fundamental biology research and novel drug development. Methods Using a battery of behavioural tasks based on rodent assays, we examined reward motivation (Joystick-Operated Runway Task, JORT; and Effort-Expenditure for Rewards Task, EEfRT) and reward sensitivity (Sweet Taste Test) in a non-clinical population who scored high ( N = 32) or low ( N = 34) on an anhedonia questionnaire (Snaith-Hamilton Pleasure Scale). Results Compared to the low anhedonia group, the high anhedonia group displayed marginal impairments in effort-based decision-making (EEfRT) and reduced reward sensitivity (Sweet Taste Test). However, we found no evidence of a difference between groups in physical effort exerted for reward (JORT). Interestingly, whilst the EEfRT and Sweet Taste Test correlated with anhedonia measures, they did not correlate with each other. This poses the question of whether there are subgroups within anhedonia; however, further work is required to directly test this hypothesis. Conclusions Our findings suggest that anhedonia is a heterogenous symptom associated with impairments in reward sensitivity and effort-based decision-making.
BibTeX
@misc{slaney2021objective,
  author = {Chloe Slaney and Adam M. Perkins and Robert E. Davis and Ian S. Penton‐Voak and Marcus R. Munafò and Conor Houghton and Emma Robinson},
  title = {{Objective measures of reward sensitivity and motivation in people with high vs low anhedonia}},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1101/2021.10.21.21265287},
  howpublished = {medRxiv},
}
Figure