Object Reconfiguration with Simulation-Derived Feasible Actions

Yiyuan Lee, Wil Thomason, Zachary Kingston, Lydia E. KavrakiarXiv 2023 · arXiv

TL;DR

This paper introduces a framework that embeds a physics simulator directly into a robot motion planner to solve complex 3D object reconfiguration tasks. By letting the simulator implicitly define which actions are physically valid and stable, the approach completely eliminates the need for tedious, manual encoding of symbolic action rules.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

When robots rearrange objects in 3D—such as unstacking blocks, clearing debris, or assembling structures—they must constantly reason about physical constraints. For instance, removing a block from the bottom of a tower will cause it to topple, and placing an object on an uneven surface might make it slide away.

Traditionally, roboticists solve this by manually writing out formal rules using symbolic languages like PDDL (Planning Domain Definition Language). This process is tedious, error-prone, and highly specific to each environment. While some specialized planners avoid this by assuming a simplified 2D tabletop world, they fail when faced with true 3D physics, uneven surfaces, or complex stability constraints. The authors address this bottleneck by asking: Can we use an off-the-shelf physics engine to discover valid actions automatically?

Methods

The authors present Stable Arrangement Search Trees (SAST), a bidirectional sampling-based planner that operates in a novel abstraction called the Arrangement Space.

Bidirectional search trees in the arrangement space.

Key components of the method include:

  • Arrangement Space: Instead of planning purely in the robot's high-dimensional joint space, SAST plans in a space where each state represents a valid configuration of all objects in the environment. An arrangement is considered valid only if it is collision-free and statically stable.
  • Implicit Physics Validation: Rather than checking hand-coded rules, SAST uses an embedded physics simulator (DART) to evaluate stability. It steps the simulator forward for a fixed duration; if the objects' displacements remain below a tiny threshold, the arrangement is deemed stable.
  • Bidirectional Tree Search: Inspired by the classic RRTConnect algorithm, SAST grows two trees of valid arrangements—one from the start configuration and one from the goal—until they connect.
  • Integrated Low-Level Motion Planning: For every proposed object transition, SAST uses OMPL and Robowflex to immediately verify that a collision-free robot trajectory (Transit and Transfer motions) actually exists to execute the move.
  • Solution Simplification: A post-processing heuristic optimizes the final path by merging or removing redundant object movements.

Datasets

The method was evaluated on three challenging, randomized 3D tabletop rearrangement benchmarks designed by the authors:

  1. REVERSE: Re-stacking a tower of 6 cubes in reverse order on the same base location.
  2. TRANSFORM: Changing a 6-cube tower into a pyramid on a table covered with random-height tiles.
  3. ROTATE: Rotating a diagonal pyramid of cubes on a surface covered with random bumps, making stable intermediate placements difficult to find.
Test problems used in the experiments: REVERSE, TRANSFORM, and ROTATE.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Simulator as the Specification: A physics engine can act as an implicit, zero-effort specification of action semantics. If the simulator says a state is stable and a path is collision-free, it is valid. This bypasses symbolic logic entirely.
  • Interleaving is Crucial: You cannot separate high-level arrangement planning from low-level motion planning. The authors demonstrated that if you plan a sequence of object moves assuming the robot can always reach them, and then check robot kinematics afterwards, the success rate plummets. The robot's physical reachability constraints must guide the high-level search.
  • Physics-Assisted Sampling: Instead of engineering complex samplers to find stable states on low-measure manifolds, SAST simply samples random 3D poses and lets the physics simulator drop/settle the objects into stable configurations.

Key Results

  • High Success Rates: SAST achieved a 96% success rate on the REVERSE and TRANSFORM tasks, and a perfect 100% success rate on the highly constrained ROTATE task within a 300-second timeout.
  • Reasonable Computation Times: Despite repeatedly calling a physics simulator and a motion planner, average solve times were under a minute (~16.5s for REVERSE, ~55.0s for TRANSFORM, and ~61.5s for ROTATE).
  • Effective Path Pruning: The solution simplification heuristic successfully cut down the initial non-optimal path lengths by roughly half, bringing them close to the physical optimum.
A simplified sequence of actions solving the ROTATE problem.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Pick-and-Place Only: The current implementation is restricted to prehensile pick-and-place actions. It cannot yet reason about non-prehensile actions like pushing, sliding, or rolling objects.
  • Non-Optimizing Core: Because SAST is based on RRTConnect, the initial paths found can be highly redundant, relying heavily on the post-processing step for efficiency.
  • Sim-to-Real Gap: The paper evaluates the method entirely in simulation; transferring these plans to a real robot arm interacting with real-world noisy physics remains an open challenge.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest exploring more advanced search strategies (like Monte Carlo Tree Search), biased samplers, and integrating differentiable simulation to handle more complex contact dynamics.

Summary updated

Abstract

3D object reconfiguration encompasses common robot manipulation tasks in which a set of objects must be moved through a series of physically feasible state changes into a desired final configuration. Object reconfiguration is challenging to solve in general, as it requires efficient reasoning about environment physics that determine action validity. This information is typically manually encoded in an explicit transition system. Constructing these explicit encodings is tedious and error-prone, and is often a bottleneck for planner use. In this work, we explore embedding a physics simulator within a motion planner to implicitly discover and specify the valid actions from any state, removing the need for manual specification of action semantics. Our experiments demonstrate that the resulting simulation-based planner can effectively produce physically valid rearrangement trajectories for a range of 3D object reconfiguration problems without requiring more than an environment description and start and goal arrangements.
BibTeX
@misc{lee2023object,
  author = {Yiyuan Lee and Wil Thomason and Zachary Kingston and Lydia E. Kavraki},
  title = {{Object Reconfiguration with Simulation-Derived Feasible Actions}},
  year = {2023},
  eprint = {2302.14161},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2302.14161},
}

Loading related content...

Figure