Obesity mediates the opposite association of education and diabetes in Chinese men and women: Results from the <scp>REACTION</scp> study

Yuanyue Zhu, Chunyan Hu, Lin Lin, Shuangyuan Wang, Yanan Huo, Qin Wan, Yingfen Qin, Ruying Hu, Lixin Shi, Qing Su, Xuefeng Yu, Li Yan, Guijun Qin, Xulei Tang, Gang Chen, Min Xu, Yu Xu, Tiange Wang, Zhiyun Zhao, Zhengnan Gao, Guixia Wang, Feixia Shen, Zuojie Luo, Li Chen, Qiang Li, Zhen Ye, Yinfei Zhang, Chao Liu, Youmin Wang, Shengli Wu, Tao Yang, Huacong Deng, Lulu Chen, Tianshu Zeng, Jiajun Zhao, Yiming Mu, Weiqing Wang, Guang Ning, Yufang Bi, Yuhong Chen, Jieli LuJournal of Diabetes 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study reveals a striking gender-specific link between education and diabetes risk in China: higher education is associated with increased diabetes risk in men but decreased risk in women. Obesity emerges as a key mediator, explaining a significant portion of this disparity, particularly in women.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The relationship between socioeconomic status, specifically education, and health outcomes like diabetes is well-established in developed countries, often showing a gradient where lower education correlates with poorer health. However, this relationship is less clear and potentially more complex in developing nations undergoing rapid economic and nutritional transitions, like China. Previous research has hinted at gender differences in this association, but a comprehensive understanding of the mediating factors, especially in a large, representative Chinese population, was lacking. This paper aims to bridge that gap by investigating how education influences diabetes risk in both Chinese men and women and identifying the specific behavioral factors, like obesity, that might explain these differences.

Methods

The researchers employed a structural equation model (SEM), a powerful statistical technique for analyzing complex relationships between multiple variables. This approach allowed them to go beyond simple correlations and quantify the "path-specific effects" of potential mediators. Specifically, they modeled the pathway from education to mediators (path 'a'), from mediators to diabetes (path 'β'), and the overall direct effect of education on diabetes (path 'c'). They also calculated the indirect effect (a*β) and the proportion of mediation for each factor. For individual behavioral factor effects, they used multivariable logistic regression.

Datasets

The study utilized data from the REACTION study, a large, nationwide, population-based cohort of Chinese individuals aged 40 years or older. The dataset included information on education level, lifestyle factors (smoking, physical activity, diet, sleep, depression), obesity, and diabetes diagnosis (self-report and biochemical measurements). The final analysis included 244,881 individuals.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Gender Reversal: The most striking finding is the opposite direction of the education-diabetes association in men and women. This challenges the often-assumed universal gradient and highlights the need for gender-specific public health strategies.
  • Obesity as a Central Mediator: Obesity is identified as the primary behavioral factor explaining the education-diabetes link, particularly in women. This suggests that interventions targeting obesity could be crucial for mitigating educational disparities in diabetes risk.
  • Differential Mediation: While obesity is key for both genders, other behavioral factors play a role, but their importance varies by sex. Physical activity, diet, and sleep are significant mediators for women, but not for men.
  • Complexity of Socioeconomic Influence: Education is a robust proxy for socioeconomic status, but even after accounting for key behavioral mediators, a substantial direct effect of education on diabetes remains, suggesting other unmeasured factors are at play.

Key Results

  • Men: College-educated men had a 19% higher risk of diabetes compared to those with the least education (OR 1.19, 95% CI 1.12–1.27). Obesity mediated 11.6% of this association.
  • Women: College-educated women had a 23% lower risk of diabetes compared to their less educated counterparts (OR 0.77, 95% CI 0.73–0.82). Obesity mediated a substantial 23.9% of this association.
  • Overall Behavioral Mediation: All behavioral factors combined explained 12.4% of the education-diabetes association in men and 33.3% in women.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Cross-sectional Design: This study design limits the ability to establish causality definitively. However, they argue that educational attainment is generally stable after early adulthood, reducing the likelihood of reversed causation.
  • Self-Reported Data: Information on education, diet, and physical activity was self-reported, which could introduce reporting bias.
  • Age Restriction: The study excluded individuals under 40, and the education-diabetes association might be more pronounced in younger populations.

Future work could focus on longitudinal studies to confirm causality and explore other potential mediators, such as marital status, household income, and insurance type, which were not fully explained by the current behavioral factors. The findings strongly suggest that targeted lifestyle modification programs, especially for women with lower education, could be highly effective in reducing diabetes disparities.

Summary updated

Abstract

In a general Chinese population, the association between education level and diabetes was positive in men but negative in women. Obesity was the major mediator underlying the education disparities of diabetes risk, with a stronger mediation effect among women.
BibTeX
@article{zhu2022obesity,
  author = {Yuanyue Zhu and Chunyan Hu and Lin Lin and Shuangyuan Wang and Hong Lin and Yanan Huo and Qin Wan and Yingfen Qin and Ruying Hu and Lixin Shi and Qing Su and Xuefeng Yu and Li Yan and Guijun Qin and Xulei Tang and Gang Chen and Min Xu and Yu Xu and Tiange Wang and Zhiyun Zhao and Zhengnan Gao and Guixia Wang and Feixia Shen and Zuojie Luo and Li Chen and Qiang Li and Zhen Ye and Yinfei Zhang and Chao Liu and Youmin Wang and Shengli Wu and Tao Yang and Huacong Deng and Lulu Chen and Tianshu Zeng and Jiajun Zhao and Yiming Mu and Weiqing Wang and Guang Ning and Yufang Bi and Yuhong Chen and Jieli Lu},
  title = {{Obesity mediates the opposite association of education and diabetes in Chinese men and women: Results from the <scp>REACTION</scp> study}},
  journal = {Journal of Diabetes},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1111/1753-0407.13325},
}
Figure