O TRABALHO DE CAMPO COMO METODOLOGIA FACILITADORA DA APRENDIZAGEM NA OPINIÃO DE PROFESSORA E ALUNOS DE UMA ESCOLA PRIVADA EM MANAUS-AM

Francesco Pinto, Renata Peres Barbosa, Wilcilene da Silva CorrêaRevista 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This study explores the disconnect between the recognized pedagogical value of fieldwork and its actual implementation in a private school in Manaus, Brazil. While 98% of surveyed students believe fieldwork is essential for understanding Geography, systemic barriers like urban violence and logistical costs keep learning largely confined to the "bureaucratic walls" of the classroom.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Geography education often suffers from being perceived as a "mnemonic" or "decorative" subject—one where students simply memorize maps, capitals, and landforms without connecting them to their lived reality. The authors argue that fieldwork is the primary methodology for transitioning to an "active geography" that fosters critical thinking and social participation.

The paper tackles a specific challenge: In a city like Manaus, nestled within the complex Amazonian landscape, why is fieldwork still so rare? By surveying 8th-grade students and their teacher at a private institution, the researchers aim to understand the perceptions of this methodology and identify the friction points preventing its use.

Methods

The researchers employed a quali-quantitative approach, blending statistical data with interpretive analysis.

  • Quantitative: They surveyed 51 students (a 69% sample of the 8th-grade cohort) using semi-structured questionnaires to quantify interest levels and perceptions of fieldwork's utility.
  • Qualitative: They conducted an in-depth, open-ended interview with the Geography teacher to capture the nuances of pedagogical planning and the institutional hurdles she faces.
  • Theoretical Framework: The study leans on the concept of "campear" (to search or research), framing fieldwork not as a "field trip" (tourism) but as a rigorous "materialization of theory."

Datasets

The primary data was collected in 2019 at a private school in the eastern zone of Manaus. The "dataset" consists of:

  • Survey responses from 51 students (ages 13–15).
  • A 7-question open interview with the sole Geography teacher for those grades.
  • Geospatial data regarding student residency (mapped by neighborhood) to contextualize the school's social environment.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Fieldwork $\neq$ Tourism: The authors emphasize that for fieldwork to be effective, it must be preceded by theoretical grounding. Without a "look guided by method," a trip is just a trip.
  • The "Active" Shift: Fieldwork transforms students from "passive receptors" into "active researchers." It moves the needle from a descriptive geography to a reflexive one.
  • The Safety Paradox: The teacher interviewed had a transformative personal experience with fieldwork (living with a ribeirinha family in Manacapuru), yet she rarely takes her own students out. This highlights a gap between a teacher's pedagogical ideals and the harsh realities of urban management.
  • Student Hunger for Context: Despite 98% of students never having done a Geography field trip, nearly all of them instinctively recognized that seeing the "real world" would help them understand classroom theory.

Key Results

The quantitative findings reveal a stark contrast between student desire and classroom reality:

  • High Interest: 40 out of 51 students reported liking Geography.
  • The Experience Gap: Only one student out of 51 had ever participated in a Geography-specific fieldwork activity.
  • Universal Value: 50 out of 51 students (98%) believe fieldwork is important, and 49 believe it directly facilitates the learning of theoretical content.
  • Teacher Perspective: The teacher identified institutional support and rigorous prior organization as the two most critical factors for success, but noted that "urban violence" in the school's vicinity makes local outings nearly impossible.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several significant "entraves" (obstacles) that limit the scope of their findings and the methodology itself:

  • Urban Violence: The school is located in one of the city's more dangerous zones, making even neighborhood walks a security risk.
  • Economic Barriers: Even in a private school, a significant number of students are on scholarships (bolsistas), making the costs of transportation and fees a barrier to participation.
  • Teacher Saturation: The paper notes that teachers are often "saturated by the system" and lack the institutional "comfort zone" to take on the massive legal and physical responsibility of taking minors off-campus.

Future Work: The authors suggest that schools must move beyond seeing fieldwork as an "extra" and instead integrate it into the core annual planning, potentially through interdisciplinary projects (like the Science/Geography overlap mentioned in the study) to share costs and responsibilities.

Summary updated

Abstract

This article presents the opinion of teacher and 8th grade students from a private school in Manaus about the fieldwork methodology as a facilitator of learning, specifically in the discipline of Geography. Such research had been carried out in the Field Practice in Basic Education course of the Geography Degree course of ENS/UEA. For this, we used the qualitative and quantitative method and applied a questionnaire open to the teacher and semi-structured to students, including 51 students, which corresponds to a sample of 69%. As a result, it was found that students and teachers consider fieldwork important, which facilitates the learning of lectures and allows students to contextualize what is seen in the classroom, but due to issues such as public safety and costs. is still little explored. Thus, it is emphasized that the use of fieldwork increases the interest in geographical science and facilitates its learning.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{pinto2020o,
  author = {Francesco Pinto and Renata Peres Barbosa and Wilcilene da Silva Corrêa},
  title = {{O TRABALHO DE CAMPO COMO METODOLOGIA FACILITADORA DA APRENDIZAGEM NA OPINIÃO DE PROFESSORA E ALUNOS DE UMA ESCOLA PRIVADA EM MANAUS-AM}},
  booktitle = {Revista},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.14393/reg-v11-2020-76658},
}
Figure