O-pH: Optical pH Monitor to Measure Dental Biofilm Acidity and Assist in Enamel Health Monitoring

Manuja Sharma, Lauren K. Lee, Matthew D. Carson, David S. Park, Se W. An, Micah G. Bovenkamp, Jess J. Cayetano, Ian A. Berude, Leonard Y. Nelson, Zheng Xu, Alireza Sadr, Shwetak N. Patel, Eric J. SeibelIEEE Trans. Biomedical Engineering 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces O-pH, a novel optical device that non-invasively measures the pH of dental biofilm, a key indicator of tooth decay. By using a fluorescent dye and optical detection, O-pH offers a more direct and potentially earlier assessment of oral health risks compared to traditional methods.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Tooth decay, or chronic caries, is a widespread global health issue. Current methods for detecting early signs of decay, like visual inspection and X-rays, provide lagging indicators. Dentists and patients lack tools that offer real-time, quantitative feedback on oral health risk factors. Specifically, the acidity produced by oral bacteria in dental biofilms is a crucial factor in enamel demineralization. Existing methods for measuring this acidity, such as pH micro-electrodes and pH strips, have limitations including fragility, invasiveness, and difficulty in measuring pH within the biofilm matrix itself. There's a clear need for a non-invasive, accurate, and clinically practical device to monitor dental biofilm pH.

Methods

The O-pH device employs a ratiometric pH sensing method utilizing the fluorescent dye Sodium Fluorescein (Fl). This dye's fluorescence properties change with pH. The device works by:

  • Excitation: A blue LED (420 nm) excites the fluorescein dye applied to the tooth surface.
  • Detection: The emitted fluorescence is captured by a photodetector unit with four optically filtered channels. Two channels are specifically designed to capture the fluorescence from the anion and dianion forms of fluorescein, which are pH-dependent. The ratio of fluorescence intensities from these two channels is used to calculate the pH.
  • Autofluorescence (AF) and Porphyrin (PpIX) Detection: Two additional channels are included to detect autofluorescence from the tooth enamel and porphyrin fluorescence from bacteria. These act as indicators for signal quality and potential biofilm maturity, respectively.
  • Device Architecture: The system comprises an excitation unit, a detection unit, and a mouth probe with a bundle of optical fibers to transmit excitation light and collect emitted fluorescence.
  • Algorithm: The device converts sampled voltages to frequency domain using FFT and uses the amplitude at the LED's pulsing frequency (500 Hz) to discriminate against background light. The ratio of fluorescence readings from specific channels is then used to calculate pH.
  • Calibration: The device is calibrated against a conventional pH meter using buffered fluorescein solutions.
  • Clinical Protocol: A study was conducted on pediatric patients to measure "rest pH" (before sugar rinse) and "drop pH" (after sugar rinse) to calculate "diff pH." This was performed on subjects with varying biofilm loads and oral hygiene histories.
  • Imaging Extension: The authors also developed a modified version using a multi-modal Scanning Fiber Endoscope (mm-SFE) to create image-based pH heatmaps, allowing for spatial pH mapping.

Datasets

The study utilized data collected from 30 pediatric patients categorized into "Post-Cleaning" and "Pre-Cleaning" groups based on their recent professional dental cleaning history, along with a control group. The device was also tested on artificial teeth, extracted human teeth, and in vitro using buffered fluorescein solutions. No new benchmark datasets were introduced; rather, the device's performance was evaluated against existing clinical scenarios and prior studies.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Direct Biofilm pH Measurement: O-pH offers a direct measurement of the pH within the dental biofilm, which is more indicative of the immediate environment affecting enamel than saliva pH.
  • Leading Indicator for Caries: By measuring biofilm acidity, O-pH can serve as a leading indicator of caries risk, allowing for earlier intervention than traditional methods.
  • Impact of Biofilm Load: The study found that subjects with higher biofilm loads (Pre-Cleaning group) exhibited lower rest and drop pH, and higher diff pH, suggesting increased bacterial acidification.
  • Clinical Relevance: The device demonstrated the ability to differentiate between groups with different oral hygiene statuses, highlighting its potential clinical utility.
  • Imaging for Spatial pH Mapping: The development of an imaging-based system (mm-SFE) shows promise for capturing spatial variations in biofilm pH, which is crucial given the localized nature of caries.

Key Results

  • Calibration Accuracy: The O-pH device achieved a correlation coefficient of 0.97 with a standard lab pH meter during calibration.
  • Clinical Study Findings:
    • The "Pre-Cleaning" group (higher biofilm load) showed significantly lower drop pH (p=0.0008) and a higher diff pH (p=0.014) compared to the "Post-Cleaning" group.
  • For unhealthy tooth surfaces (rank 1), rest pH and drop pH were significantly different between the Pre- and Post-Cleaning groups.
  • Saliva-normalized pH measurements also showed significant differences for rest pH and diff pH between the groups.
  • Device Verification: The device demonstrated repeatable measurements with a pooled standard deviation of 0.23 pH.
  • Imaging Case Study: The mm-SFE system produced pH heatmaps showing a drop pH of 5-5.5 and a diff pH of around 1.5, consistent with Stephan curve data.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Biofilm Thickness Requirement: O-pH requires a moderate to high biofilm build-up to achieve a good signal-to-noise ratio, which can be a limitation for detecting pH changes in subjects with very thin biofilms or those with excellent oral hygiene.
  • In Vivo Verification: Direct in vivo verification against approved micro-electrodes was limited due to the lack of such devices approved for intra-oral use in the US.
  • Averaging Technique: While the study analyzed surface-specific data, future work could explore contralateral surface comparisons.
  • Protocol Optimization: Future studies could investigate higher sucrose concentrations and longer monitoring periods for the Stephan curve to better differentiate between healthy and unhealthy surfaces.
  • Imaging Challenges: The imaging system faces challenges with enamel surface featureless, air bubbles, and image registration, which require further development.
  • Microbial Analysis: The study did not include microbial analysis of the biofilm, which could provide deeper insights into the composition and its role in caries formation.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest improving excitation power and fluorescein concentration, developing more robust imaging processing, and exploring hyperspectral cameras for pH mapping. Further clinical studies are needed to validate the device's utility and measure pH trends in various populations.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{sharma2022o,
  author = {Manuja Sharma and Lauren K. Lee and Matthew D. Carson and David S. Park and Se W. An and Micah G. Bovenkamp and Jess J. Cayetano and Ian A. Berude and Leonard Y. Nelson and Zheng Xu and Alireza Sadr and Shwetak N. Patel and Eric J. Seibel},
  title = {{O-pH: Optical pH Monitor to Measure Dental Biofilm Acidity and Assist in Enamel Health Monitoring}},
  journal = {IEEE Trans. Biomedical Engineering},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1109/tbme.2022.3153659},
}
Figure