Nursing Workflow Change in a COVID-19 Inpatient Unit Following the Deployment of Inpatient Telehealth: Observational Study Using a Real-Time Locating System

Stacie Vilendrer, Mary E. Lough, Donn W. Garvert, Monique H Lambert, Jonathan Lu, Birju Patel, Nigam H. Shah, Michelle Y. Williams, Samantha M.r. KlingJournal of Medical Internet Research 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study used real-time locating systems (RTLS) to analyze how nursing workflows changed on a COVID-19 inpatient unit after implementing telehealth. The findings suggest that while the frequency of in-person nurse-patient encounters decreased and their duration increased, the total time nurses spent at the bedside remained consistent, indicating a "batching" of work. This implies telehealth complemented, rather than replaced, in-person care, with potential benefits for PPE use and infection control.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The COVID-19 pandemic necessitated rapid adoption of telehealth in healthcare settings to reduce pathogen exposure and conserve personal protective equipment (PPE). Inpatient units, in particular, faced unique challenges in adapting nursing workflows to these new technologies. Understanding how nurses re-organized their time and patient interactions is crucial for assessing the impact on patient safety, infection control, and resource utilization. Previous studies often relied on indirect measures like PPE inventory or patient satisfaction surveys. This paper addresses the need for objective, real-time data to understand these workflow shifts, specifically focusing on the impact of inpatient telehealth on nursing time spent at the bedside.

Methods

The researchers employed a retrospective, observational study design using data from a real-time locating system (RTLS) and electronic health records (EHR). The RTLS tracked the movement of nurses within patient rooms on a primary COVID-19 unit and three comparison units over six stages of the pandemic (prepandemic, telehealth rollout, and four pandemic stages).

Key metrics analyzed included:

  • Frequency of direct nurse-patient encounters: Defined as the number of times nurses entered patient rooms.
  • Duration of nurse-patient encounters: The time nurses spent in patient rooms per encounter.
  • Total time spent with patients per shift: The cumulative time nurses spent in patient rooms.

A difference-in-differences analysis was used to compare changes in these outcomes between the COVID-19 unit and the comparison units, controlling for prepandemic baseline levels. Telehealth utilization data (video call frequency and duration) were also collected at the unit level.

Datasets

  • Real-Time Locating System (RTLS) Data: Captured nurse movement (entry/exit from patient rooms) and time spent in rooms. This data was collected from January 1, 2020, to December 27, 2020.
  • Electronic Health Record (EHR) Data: Used to determine patient presence in rooms and COVID-19 status.
  • Telehealth Utilization Data: Extracted from Zoom, including call start/end times and participant counts, to assess unit-level telehealth use.

No new datasets or benchmarks were introduced; the study utilized existing data collection systems.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • "Batching" of Work: The most striking finding is the redistribution of nursing work. Nurses on the COVID-19 unit, with dedicated in-room telehealth, reduced the frequency of in-person visits but increased the duration of each visit. This suggests a strategy of consolidating tasks into fewer, longer encounters.
  • Telehealth as a Complement, Not Replacement: The total time nurses spent at the bedside remained largely unchanged, even with the introduction of telehealth. This indicates that telehealth was used to augment, rather than substitute for, in-person care, allowing nurses to maintain their overall bedside presence.
  • Impact of Dedicated vs. Shared Telehealth: The COVID-19 unit had in-room telehealth hardware, while comparison units used mobile carts. This difference in accessibility likely contributed to the observed workflow changes, with the COVID-19 unit adopting telehealth more readily and experiencing more pronounced workflow shifts.
  • Potential for PPE Savings: The reduction in encounter frequency on the COVID-19 unit, even with longer durations, suggests potential savings in PPE usage, estimated at approximately 785 units per week for the unit.

Key Results

  • Direct Nurse-Patient Encounters: The COVID-19 unit saw a significantly greater decrease in the frequency of nurse-patient encounters compared to comparison units across all pandemic stages (difference-in-differences ranging from -6.6 to -14.1 encounters per shift).
  • Duration of Nurse-Patient Encounters: Conversely, the duration of these encounters increased significantly more on the COVID-19 unit (difference-in-differences ranging from 1.8 to 6.2 minutes per encounter).
  • Total Time at Bedside: Despite changes in encounter frequency and duration, the total time nurses spent in patient rooms per patient per shift did not significantly differ between the COVID-19 and comparison units during most pandemic stages (P>.17).
  • Telehealth Adoption: The primary COVID-19 unit quickly adopted telehealth, initiating 15,088 encounters averaging 6.6 minutes each.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Causality: The study acknowledges that it cannot establish a causal link between nursing workflow changes and telehealth adoption due to the observational nature and potential confounding factors (e.g., evolving COVID-19 management protocols, differences in patient acuity, and unmeasured nurse-patient communication like bedside phones).
  • Telehealth Data Granularity: Telehealth utilization data was only available at the unit level, lacking information on the purpose of calls, or the specific nurses, patients, or other staff involved.
  • RTLS Data Limitations: RTLS data was limited to nurses and did not capture the movements of other healthcare professionals. Patient census data was based on midnight counts, not real-time fluctuations.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest further evaluation is needed to determine the downstream implications of these workflow changes on disease transmission, PPE utilization, and patient safety. Understanding the optimal ratio of in-person to virtual encounters and identifying patient/clinician triggers for each type of encounter are also areas for future research. Long-term use and sustainability of inpatient telehealth outside the pandemic setting also warrant investigation.

Summary updated

Abstract

RTLS movement data suggest that total nursing time at the bedside remained unchanged following the deployment of inpatient telehealth in a COVID-19 unit. Compared to other units with shared mobile telehealth units, the frequency of nurse-patient in-person encounters decreased and the duration lengthened on a COVID-19 unit with in-room telehealth availability, indicating "batched" redistribution of work to maintain total time at bedside relative to prepandemic periods. The simultaneous adoption of telehealth suggests that virtual care was a complement to, rather than a replacement for, in-person care. However, study limitations preclude our ability to draw a causal link between nursing workflow change and telehealth adoption. Thus, further evaluation is needed to determine potential downstream implications on disease transmission, PPE utilization, and patient safety.
BibTeX
@article{vilendrer2022nursing,
  author = {Stacie Vilendrer and Mary E. Lough and Donn W. Garvert and Monique H Lambert and Jonathan Lu and Birju Patel and Nigam H. Shah and Michelle Y. Williams and Samantha M.R. Kling},
  title = {{Nursing Workflow Change in a COVID-19 Inpatient Unit Following the Deployment of Inpatient Telehealth: Observational Study Using a Real-Time Locating System}},
  journal = {Journal of Medical Internet Research},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.2196/36882},
}
Figure