Numerical Study on the Influence of Aquitard Layer Distribution and Permeability Parameters on Foundation Pit Dewatering

Jinguo Wang, Zhiheng Ma, Jiale Zeng, Zhou Chen, Guoqing LiWater 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates how the distribution and properties of clay layers (aquitards) impact the efficiency of dewatering for deep excavations. Using a 3D groundwater flow model, they found that more extensive clay layers improve dewatering, but higher clay permeability reduces efficiency. The location of these clay layers also matters, with those below the riverbed being more effective than those in the foothills.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Deep excavations for civil engineering projects often encounter groundwater, which can compromise stability and safety. Dewatering is crucial to manage this, but its effectiveness is heavily influenced by complex geological conditions, particularly the presence and characteristics of aquitard layers like clay. In river valley areas, these clay layers can be discontinuous due to sedimentation, making it challenging to predict dewatering performance, especially when detailed on-site geological data is limited. This study aims to quantitatively assess how the distribution and permeability of these clay layers affect foundation pit dewatering efficiency, providing a more optimized approach for dewatering designs.

Methods

The researchers employed a three-dimensional, non-steady-state groundwater flow model using the MODFLOW-USG software. This software is notable for its use of unstructured grids, which allows for flexible grid refinement to better represent complex geological features like aquitard layers. The model was calibrated against hydrogeological data and observed groundwater levels from a specific deep excavation site on the Chongjiang River. To analyze the influence of clay layers, they simulated various scenarios by altering the clay layer's coverage, permeability, storage coefficient, and specific yield. The MODPATH module was also used to track groundwater flow directions and understand the impact of cutoff walls.

Datasets

The study utilized hydrogeological data from borehole investigations and pumping tests conducted at the Chongjiang River Inlet Culvert project site. Meteorological data (average annual precipitation and intensity) were also used for rainfall infiltration calculations. Observed groundwater levels from 21 monitoring wells were used for model calibration. No new datasets were created or introduced in this study.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Clay as a Barrier: Increased clay layer coverage acts as a more effective barrier, significantly enhancing dewatering efficiency by reducing groundwater inflow.
  • Permeability Trade-off: While more clay is generally good, higher permeability within the clay layer itself can paradoxically reduce dewatering efficiency. This suggests a balance is needed.
  • Specific Yield's Minor Role: The specific yield of the clay layer appears to have a less pronounced effect on dewatering efficiency compared to its permeability or coverage.
  • Location Matters: The position of discontinuous clay layers is critical. Clay layers situated below the riverbed are more effective at impeding groundwater flow and improving dewatering than those located in the foothills, where continuous recharge from higher ground can occur.
  • Cutoff Walls are Crucial: The study reinforces the significant positive impact of cutoff walls in preventing external groundwater from entering the dewatering zone, thereby greatly increasing dewatering effectiveness.

Key Results

The model successfully reproduced actual dewatering processes, with calibration showing errors in water level calculations generally less than 3 meters. The simulations revealed that pumping rates can increase significantly as clay layer coverage decreases. For instance, pumping rates could rise from 18,200 m³/d with 100% clay coverage to 48,000 m³/d with 0% coverage. The study also quantified the impact of hydraulic conductivity and storage coefficient, showing that higher values generally lead to higher pumping rates, with the effect of hydraulic conductivity becoming more pronounced when combined with a higher storage coefficient. The groundwater level in the engineering area was observed to drop from an average of 1832 m to 1790 m within 30 days of dewatering.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that the study area exhibits strong heterogeneity due to the irregular distribution of clay layers. While the model effectively captures the general trends, the precise prediction of dewatering rates can be influenced by the specific spatial continuity of these layers, which may be affected near the main river channel. The study also notes that the influence of the "sealed box" effect of clay layers outweighs location-specific effects when considering total pumping rates. Future work could involve more detailed investigations into the spatial variability of clay layer properties and their impact on dewatering in different geological settings.

Summary updated

Abstract

Evaluating the influence of geologic features on dewatering efficiency, particularly within strata of varying permeability, is critical to optimizing dewatering designs for deep excavations. In river valley areas, river sedimentation results in a discontinuous distribution of relatively aquitard layers (clay layers). The evaluation and calculation of the distribution and permeability parameters for foundation pit dewatering are very important when on-site geological data are insufficient. For this purpose, the deep excavation pit on the right bank and floodplain of Chongjiang River is taken as an example in this article. A three-dimensional groundwater flow model was constructed using the Unstructured Grid (MODFLOW-USG) software package version 1. The model was carefully calibrated using hydrogeologic features and observed groundwater levels to ensure its reliability. The simulation results effectively reproduce actual dewatering processes. The study reveals the following findings: (1) Increased aquitard layers (clay layer) enhance the barrier effect, thereby improving dewatering efficiency. (2) Increased clay layer permeability and storage coefficients reduce dewatering efficiency, while the specific yield of the clay layer has less pronounced effects. (3) Due to the discontinuous nature of the clay layer, dewatering rates are higher when the clay layer is below the riverbed than when it is in the flow boundary area (foothills).
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2023numerical,
  author = {Jinguo Wang and Zhiheng Ma and Jiale Zeng and Zhou Chen and Guoqing Li},
  title = {{Numerical Study on the Influence of Aquitard Layer Distribution and Permeability Parameters on Foundation Pit Dewatering}},
  booktitle = {Water},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/w15213722},
}
Figure