Numerical Study of Local Scour around Tripod Foundation in Random Waves

Ruigeng Hu, Xiuhai Wang, Hongjun Liu, Da ChenJournal of Marine Science and Engineering 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a validated numerical model for simulating local scour around tripod foundations in random waves, revealing that the complex structure of tripods leads to more severe scour than single piles. A revised stochastic model is proposed to predict equilibrium scour depth, showing good agreement with numerical results when accounting for tripod-specific effects.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Offshore wind turbines (OWTs) are increasingly being deployed in deeper waters, where tripod foundations are a viable and stable option. However, the complex geometry of tripods, with a main column and multiple diagonal braces, significantly influences the surrounding hydrodynamic flow and can lead to localized scour. Existing scour prediction methods, often derived from studies on simpler monopile foundations, may underestimate the scour depth around tripods, potentially compromising the structural integrity and safety of OWTs. This paper aims to address this gap by numerically investigating the scour characteristics and developing a more accurate prediction model for tripod foundations in random wave conditions.

Methods

The researchers developed a comprehensive seabed-tripod-fluid numerical model. This model utilizes the Reynolds-Averaged Navier-Stokes (RANS) equations to describe fluid motion, coupled with the RNG k-ε turbulence model, which is known for its accuracy in near-wall flow simulations. To simulate the scour process, the model incorporates a sediment transport module that accounts for both bed load and suspended load. This module includes equations for entrainment and deposition of sediment particles, critical Shields parameter, and settling velocity.

The numerical model was validated against experimental data from previous studies on scour around single piles and tripod foundations. The study also performed a mesh sensitivity analysis to ensure the accuracy and reliability of the numerical results. Finally, a novel aspect of this work is the proposal of a revised stochastic model for predicting equilibrium scour depth. This revised model builds upon an existing stochastic model for single piles by incorporating a deviation term that accounts for the increased scour observed around tripods due to their complex geometry.

Datasets

The study utilized experimental data from previous research for model validation. Specifically, they compared their numerical results with:

  • Experimental data from Sumer and Fredsøe [7] for scour around piles in combined waves and currents.
  • Experimental data from Schendel et al. [33] for scour around monopiles induced by irregular waves and currents.

The numerical simulations were conducted using parameters derived from the Joint North Sea Wave Project (JONSWAP) wave spectrum, with eleven different test plans defined by varying parameters such as water depth, wave height, and wave period, as detailed in Table 1.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Tripod Geometry Amplifies Scour: The complex structure of tripod foundations, particularly the blockage effects of the main column and diagonal braces, leads to enhanced flow acceleration and increased turbulence intensity near the seabed. This, in turn, amplifies seabed shear stress, mobilizing more sediment and resulting in more severe scour compared to simpler structures like monopiles.
  • Scour Location: The maximum scour depth consistently occurs underneath the main column of the tripod, with the scour hole extending along the lower diagonal braces.
  • Gap Flow Contribution: The presence of a gap between the main column and the seabed can also contribute to the scour process, potentially facilitating flow and sediment transport.
  • Existing Models Underestimate Tripod Scour: Stochastic models developed for single piles tend to underestimate the equilibrium scour depth around tripods. This highlights the need for tripod-specific prediction methods.
  • Revised Stochastic Model Shows Promise: By introducing a deviation term that accounts for the additional scour caused by tripod geometry, the revised stochastic model demonstrates improved agreement with numerical and experimental results, particularly when using a specific parameter (n=20) representing the higher-order wave influence.

Key Results

  • The developed seabed-tripod-fluid numerical model accurately depicts the scour process and flow field around tripods, showing good agreement with experimental data (maximum error of approximately 30% in scour depth prediction).
  • The temporal development of scour shows rapid initial development followed by a slower growth phase, eventually stabilizing at an equilibrium scour depth.
  • The revised stochastic model, when adjusted with a deviation term, provides a better prediction of equilibrium scour depth for tripods in random waves, especially for n=20.
  • The study found that the Keulegan–Carpenter (KC) number is a dominant factor influencing scour depth, with higher KC values leading to greater equilibrium scour depths.

Limitations and Future Work

  • KC Number Range: The validation of the revised stochastic model is currently limited to relatively smaller KC conditions (KCrms,a < 4). The authors emphasize the need for more experimental data and numerical results to verify its adaptation for larger KC conditions (KCrms,a > 4).
  • Prototype Dimensions: The numerical model was established based on prototype dimensions with a relatively larger diameter, which might influence the scour behavior under smaller KC conditions.
  • Further Investigation: The authors suggest that future studies should further investigate the scour characteristics for this type of foundation, particularly focusing on anchoring the main column in the seabed and exploring the influence of the gap flow. Additional research is also recommended to refine the revised stochastic model for broader applicability.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this study, the local scour around tripods in random waves is numerically investigated. The seabed-tripod-fluid numerical model with an RNG k−ε turbulence model is built and validated. Following that, the scour characteristics and flow velocity distribution are analyzed using the present numerical model. Finally, a revised stochastic model is proposed to predict the equilibrium scour depth, Seq, around tripods in random waves. The results indicate that the present seabed-tripod-fluid numerical model is capable of depicting the scour process and of capturing the flow field around tripods with high accuracy. Due to the blockage effects of the main column and structural elements, there is enhanced flow acceleration underneath the main column and the lower diagonal braces, which increases the turbulence intensity and seabed shear stress, causing more particles to be mobilized and transported, resulting in more severe scour at the site. The revised stochastic model shows the best agreement with the numerical and experimental results when n = 20, but more experimental data and numerical results are still needed to verify the adaptation of the revised stochastic model for larger Keulegan–Carpenter (KC) number conditions (KCrms,a &gt; 4).
BibTeX
@article{hu2022numerical,
  author = {Ruigeng Hu and Xiuhai Wang and Hongjun Liu and Da Chen},
  title = {{Numerical Study of Local Scour around Tripod Foundation in Random Waves}},
  journal = {Journal of Marine Science and Engineering},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/jmse10040475},
}
Figure