TL;DR
This study develops and validates a high-resolution numerical model for storm surge inundation in the Jitimen estuary, China. By simulating various typhoon scenarios, the research identifies that typhoon landfall direction and local topography have a more significant impact on inundation extent and depth than landfall location or intensity, providing crucial insights for disaster preparedness in vulnerable estuarine regions.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Global climate change is exacerbating the frequency and intensity of extreme weather events, leading to a heightened risk of storm surges in coastal and estuarine areas. These surges pose a significant threat to infrastructure, economies, and the sustainable development of these regions. Accurately predicting storm surge inundation is therefore critical for effective disaster prevention and mitigation. While numerical models for storm surges exist, understanding the relative importance of various influencing factors (like typhoon characteristics and local topography) on inundation in specific, complex estuarine environments remains an active area of research. This paper aims to address this by investigating how different typhoon parameters affect storm surge inundation in the Jitimen estuary, a region prone to such events.
Methods
The researchers employed the ADCIRC (A (PARALLEL) Advanced Circulation Model For Oceanic, Coastal and Estuarine Waters), a well-established hydrodynamic model based on the finite element method. To capture the intricate details of the estuarine environment, a high-resolution, unstructured triangular grid was established, with land grid resolutions as fine as 30-40 meters. The model incorporates various physical processes, including advection, Coriolis force, wind stress, bottom friction, lateral viscosity, and tidal forcing.
To assess the impact of different factors, three sets of experimental scenarios were designed:
- Scheme A (Landfall Location): Varied the distance of the typhoon's landfall from the study area while keeping intensity and direction constant.
- Scheme B (Landfall Intensity): Varied the typhoon's central pressure (intensity) while keeping location and direction constant.
- Scheme C (Landfall Direction): Varied the direction of the typhoon's approach (west, northwest, north) while keeping location and intensity constant.
Crucially, for each scheme, the simulations were set up so that the total tide levels at the Sanzao tide gauge station were similar across the different scenarios within that scheme. This allowed for a more direct comparison of the inundation impacts stemming from the varied factor. The model was validated using historical data from super typhoons Hato (2017) and Mangkhut (2018).
Datasets
The study utilized several datasets:
- Typhoon Data: Historical typhoon track and intensity data from the China Meteorological Administration (CMA) for the Western North Pacific Basin (1949-2022). This was used to construct wind fields for driving the model.
- Tide Level Data: Hourly tide level data from the Sanzao tide gauge station in Guangdong Province.
- Water Depth Data: Bathymetry data with a spatial resolution of 2' for open sea areas and 25 m for the near-study area.
- Geographic Information Data:
- Digital Elevation Model (DEM) data with a 10 m spatial resolution for topography.
- Coastal seawall data with a 50 m spatial resolution.
These datasets were used for model setup, validation, and the subsequent numerical experiments.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Landfall Direction Dominates: The most striking finding is that the direction from which a typhoon makes landfall has a significantly greater impact on storm surge inundation than its location or intensity, especially in complex estuarine geometries.
- Topography Amplifies Directional Effects: The trumpet-like shape of the Jitimen estuary, facing south, interacts with the wind direction. Easterly winds (from westward landfall) are less conducive to surge accumulation than southeasterly or southerly winds (from northwestward or northward landfalls, respectively).
- Duration of High Tide is Key: The difference in inundation impact between landfall directions was strongly correlated with the duration of high tide levels (exceeding 3m), rather than just the peak tide level. Longer durations allow more water to accumulate in the estuary.
- Model Validation is Robust: The ADCIRC model, with its refined grid, demonstrated excellent performance in hindcasting storm surges from major typhoons, with errors in simulated storm surges and tide levels well within acceptable ranges.
- Foundation for Rapid Forecasting: The study's approach of creating scenarios and analyzing their impacts lays the groundwork for developing a storm surge inundation database, enabling faster forecasting than traditional real-time simulations.
Key Results
- Landfall Location & Intensity: When landfall direction was constant and peak tide levels were similar, varying typhoon landfall location or intensity resulted in less than 5% difference in inundation area and average depth. This indicates these factors have a relatively minor impact under these specific conditions.
- Landfall Direction: In contrast, when location and intensity were constant and peak tide levels were similar, changing the landfall direction led to substantial differences:
- Inundation areas were 16.8% (northwest) and 29.8% (north) larger than the westward landfall scenario.
- Average inundation depths were 5.8% (northwest) and 14.7% (north) greater than the westward landfall scenario.
- Model Performance: Simulated maximum storm surges for Hato and Mangkhut had errors of 3.2% and 5.0%, respectively. Simulated highest tide levels had errors of 1.2% and 2.4%.
Limitations and Future Work
- Focus on Specific Factors: While the study focused on landfall location, intensity, and direction, other factors like typhoon speed, astronomical tides, nearshore waves, and detailed nearshore topography were simplified or held constant. Future work could explore the interplay of these additional factors.
- Single Estuary Study: The findings are specific to the Jitimen estuary's unique topography. While the methodology is transferable, the quantitative impacts of different factors might vary in other estuarine systems.
- Database Development: The authors explicitly state the goal is to use these findings to build a lightweight storm surge inundation database for rapid forecasting. This is a clear direction for future work, enabling quicker decision-making during actual events.
- Refined Grids: The study highlights the importance of high-resolution grids. Future work could explore even finer grids or adaptive meshing techniques to capture localized inundation phenomena more precisely.
Summary updated