Numerical Simulation of Carbon Tetrachloride Pollution-Traceability in Groundwater System of an Industrial City

Benli Guo, Peng Yang, Yan Zhou, Hongjian Ai, Xiaodong Li, Rifei Kang, Youcheng LvSustainability 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper tackles the challenging problem of tracing carbon tetrachloride (CCL4) pollution in a complex industrial city's groundwater system. By integrating hydrochemical analysis, backward particle tracing (MODPATH), and forward solute transport simulations (MT3D), the researchers successfully identified historical pollution sources and their migration patterns, providing crucial data for remediation efforts.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Carbon tetrachloride (CCL4) is a toxic industrial chemical that poses significant risks to human health and the environment when it contaminates groundwater. In industrial areas, identifying the exact sources and historical pathways of such pollution is incredibly difficult due to complex hydrogeological conditions, the widespread use of chemicals, and often limited historical data. Traditional methods like single hydrochemical analysis are insufficient to pinpoint pollution origins. This paper addresses this critical knowledge gap by developing and applying a comprehensive, multi-faceted approach to trace CCL4 pollution in an industrial city in eastern China, aiming to pinpoint both the sources and the timeline of contamination.

Methods

The study employs a three-pronged approach to tackle the CCL4 traceability problem:

  1. Hydrochemical Analysis: Groundwater samples were analyzed using gas chromatography/mass spectrometry (GC/MS) to map the concentration fields of CCL4. This helped identify "hotspots" and screen monitoring wells that exceeded critical concentration levels (HF#1, DJ#19, DJ#7, SS#4, ZF#2, and DY#3).
  2. Backward Tracing (MODPATH): The MODPATH model was used to simulate particle movement backward in time (30 and 50 years) from the identified contaminated wells. This technique helps delineate "capture zones" – areas from which groundwater could have flowed to the monitoring wells. By overlaying historical factory distribution data onto these capture zones, potential polluting factories were identified.
  3. Forward Solute Transport Simulation (MT3D): Once potential pollution sources were hypothesized, MT3D was used to simulate the forward movement of CCL4 from these sources. This involved setting up two scenarios: one assuming pollution from the 1990s and another from the 1970s. The simulated concentration distributions were then compared with observed data to validate the source locations and understand pollutant transport characteristics in both the Quaternary and limestone aquifers.

The novelty lies in the combination of these methods. While MODPATH is standard for backward tracing and MT3D for forward simulation, their integrated application, particularly with historical factory data and detailed comparison against observed concentrations, provides a more robust and less uncertain traceability solution than using any single method alone.

Datasets

  • Groundwater Samples: 151 water samples were collected (68 dry season, 83 wet season) and analyzed for CCL4 concentration using GC/MS. Data from 2012 and 2016 were specifically highlighted.
  • Groundwater Level Data: Observed groundwater level data from three monitoring wells (ZXC, LZ, and QJC) were used for model calibration.
  • Historical Factory Distribution Data: Information on the location and operational periods of various factories (fertilizer plants, steelworks, machine-tool plants, textile mills, etc.) was crucial for identifying potential pollution sources.
  • Meteorological Data: Precipitation data was used for infiltration calculations.
  • Evaporation Data: Evaporation-pan experimental data was utilized.
  • Pumping Well Data: Monthly pumping volumes for agricultural irrigation were incorporated.

No new benchmark datasets were introduced; the study utilized existing field data and historical records.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Synergistic Power of Integrated Methods: The study strongly demonstrates that combining hydrochemical analysis, backward tracing, and forward simulation is far more effective for complex pollution source identification than relying on any single method. This is particularly true in areas with intricate hydrogeology and limited historical data.
  • Historical Factory Data is Key: The successful identification of pollution sources hinged on overlaying simulated capture zones with historical factory locations. This highlights the importance of archival industrial data for environmental investigations.
  • Layered Aquifer Dynamics: CCL4 transport differs significantly between the Quaternary and limestone aquifers, with faster migration observed in the limestone layer. This distinction is critical for predicting plume movement and designing remediation strategies.
  • Temporal Resolution Matters: Tracing pollution over 30 and 50-year periods revealed different potential sources and capture zones, underscoring the need for long-term historical analysis.
  • Uncertainty in Scarce Data: The paper acknowledges that limited historical observed data can lead to uncertainty in simulation results, particularly for older pollution events.

Key Results

  • Pollution Centers Identified: Two main CCL4 pollution centers were identified in the northeast and southwest of the study area, with a smaller regional center in the middle.
  • Potential Sources Identified:
    • 1990s: Textile mill, fertilizer plant, steelworks, and machine-tool plant were identified as potential sources.
  • 1970s: Chemical-fertilizer plant, fertilizer plant, steelworks, machine-tool plant, and cement mill were identified.
  • Specific Source Inferences: The textile mill (1990s), steelworks (1970s), and machine-tool plant (1970s and 1990s) were inferred as the most likely primary sources based on simulation comparisons.
  • Transport Speeds:
    • DY#3 area: ~130 m/year
    • ZF#2 area: ~30 m/year
    • HF#1-DJ#19-DJ#7-SS#4 region: ~50 m/year
  • Model Calibration: Simulated groundwater levels showed good agreement with observed data, with error coefficients within 10% for the tested wells.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Data Scarcity: The paper explicitly mentions that the lack of historical observed concentration data is a significant limitation, leading to uncertainty in the simulation results, especially for older pollution events.
  • Exact Source Location: While potential factories were identified, the precise location of pollutant leakage within these factories and the exact storage locations require further investigation.
  • Simplified Transport: The MODPATH model does not account for chemical reactions or biodegradation, which could influence actual pollutant behavior.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest further investigation into the exact us-time and pollution-storage location within factories. They also imply the need for more comprehensive historical data to reduce simulation uncertainties.

Summary updated

Abstract

Carbon Tetrachloride (CCL4) is a colorless, volatile, and toxic liquid. Once it pollutes groundwater, it will not only destroy the ecological environment but also negatively affect the functioning of the human liver. An industrial city in eastern China has been contaminated with carbon tetrachloride (CCL4). Due to the complex hydrogeological conditions, it is difficult to determine the pollution source by a single hydrochemical analysis. In order to solve the traceability problem, in this work we established a traceability system by combining hydrochemical analysis, backward tracing, and forward transport, and analyzed the pollution distribution, pollution-source location and pollution-transport characteristic in groundwater, which provided technical support for CCL4-pollution control of groundwater in this area. (1) Groundwater samples were analyzed using the gas chromatography/mass spectrometry method. Through the pollution concentration-field, we identified the location of the pollution center and the concentration value in the northeast and southwest, screening out the monitoring wells exceeding the criteria: HF#1, DJ#19, DJ#7, SS#4, ZF#2, and DY#3. (2) Backward tracing over the past 30 years and 50 years was conducted through MODPATH. Potential polluting factories were identified by comparing the capture area with the historical distribution of factories. (3) Forward solute-transport was performed at the location of these potentially polluted factories. The distribution characteristics of pollutants in limestone layers and the Quaternary layer were analyzed using a simulated concentration-field for August 2012 and October 2016. (4) Comparing the simulated concentration with the observed concentration, the source of CCL4 pollution was inferred to be the textile mill in the 1990s, the steelworks in the 1970s, and the machine-tool plant in the 1970s and 1990s. Based on the concentration–duration curve at the pollution source, the transport characteristics and the transport speed of the pollutants in the study area were analyzed. This work not only successfully found the location of CCL4-pollution sources, but also helped the local government to analyze the year of pollutant release and recognize the transport pattern of CCL4 in aquifers.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{guo2022numerical,
  author = {Benli Guo and Peng Yang and Yan Zhou and Hongjian Ai and Xiaodong Li and Rifei Kang and Youcheng Lv},
  title = {{Numerical Simulation of Carbon Tetrachloride Pollution-Traceability in Groundwater System of an Industrial City}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/su142316113},
}
Figure