Numerical simulation and in vitro experimental study of the hemodynamic performance of vena cava filters with helical forms

Yu Huang, Chao Li, Ming Liu, Ming Zhao, Ying ChenScientific 2024 · DOI

Abstract

Inferior vena cava filter (IVCF) implantation is a standard procedure to prevent acute pulmonary embolism (PE) by capturing migrating thrombi. However, conventional filters often face issues with thrombus accumulation and mechanical instability. This study proposes a novel generation of bio-inspired helical IVCFs designed to induce helical blood flow. Using ANSYS 2023 for fluid-structure interaction (FSI) simulations and in vitro bench testing, we evaluated four helical geometries. Results indicate that helical structures significantly increase wall shear stress (WSS), promoting clot dissolution while enhancing mechanical stability against the vessel wall. The Expansion Pattern Filter (EPF) emerged as the most balanced design, offering effective trapping with minimal risk of migration or vessel perforation.

Introduction

Pulmonary embolism (PE), typically resulting from deep vein thrombosis (DVT) in the lower limbs, remains a major cause of cardiovascular mortality. IVCFs act as a mechanical barrier to "catch" these clots. Traditional designs, however, present a "catch-22": dense filters capture small clots but risk total blockage, while sparse filters may allow dangerous emboli to pass. Furthermore, mechanical forces can cause filters to tilt, migrate, or puncture the vena cava.

Inspired by the natural helical flow in the human arterial system, this research investigates whether spiral filter geometries can induce a "tornado effect" to improve both hemodynamics and mechanical anchoring.

Methodology

The study utilized a dual-track approach combining computational modeling and physical testing:

  1. Numerical Simulation: High-fidelity FSI simulations were conducted using ANSYS 2023. Blood was modeled as a non-Newtonian fluid using the Carreau model to capture realistic flow behavior. Four distinct geometries were tested: EPF (Expansion Pattern), CPF (Conical Pattern), SPF (Shrink Pattern), and LPF (Linear Pattern control).
  2. In Vitro Experiments: ABS plastic filters were 3D-printed and tested in a transparent resin IVC model. A peristaltic pump simulated physiological flow, and various microemboli (nylon beads and plush balls) were introduced to measure trapping efficiency and device displacement.
Geometric parameters of the four helical IVCF designs and the anatomical IVC model used for simulation.

Hemodynamic and Mechanical Performance

The core innovation lies in the induction of helical flow dynamics. The simulations confirmed that helical structures successfully create swirling patterns, which increase Wall Shear Stress (WSS). This increased stress acts as a natural scouring mechanism, facilitating the "cleavage" or gradual dissolution of trapped clots.

Schematic representation of IVCF-induced helical flow patterns within the inferior vena cava.

Key Findings:

  • Stability vs. Trapping: The SPF was most effective at capturing 2mm particles due to its dense central rods but experienced higher drag. Conversely, the EPF provided the best mechanical stability, exhibiting the lowest drag force ($0.93 \times 10^{-3}$ N) and causing the least vessel deformation.
  • Bio-Inspired Safety: The curved contact surfaces of the helical designs distribute stress more uniformly. This reduces the risk of vessel wall perforation compared to the sharp struts of traditional filters.
  • Control Failure: In physical tests, the LPF control group failed entirely, dislodging under flow, which underscores the superior "grip" provided by helical architectures.

Conclusion

The study concludes that the Expansion Pattern Filter (EPF) offers the most optimal balance between hemodynamic performance and mechanical safety. While the SPF excels in capture efficiency, the EPF’s superior stability and reduced risk of vessel injury make it a more viable candidate for clinical application. Future work will focus on transitioning to pulsatile flow models and conducting in vivo studies to evaluate biological responses at the helical contact points.

Reference: Huang, Y.X., Li, Q., Liu, M. et al. Numerical simulation and in vitro experimental study of the hemodynamic performance of vena cava filters with helical forms. Sci Rep 14, 17903 (2024).

Summary updated

Abstract

Inferior vena cava filter (IVCF) implantation is a common method of thrombus capture. By implanting a filter in the inferior vena cava (IVC), microemboli can be effectively blocked from entering the pulmonary circulation, thereby avoiding acute pulmonary embolism (PE). Inspired by the helical flow effect in the human arterial system, we propose a helical retrievable IVCF, which, due to the presence of a helical structure inducing a helical flow pattern of blood in the region near the IVCF, can effectively avoid the deposition of microemboli in the vicinity of the IVCF while promoting the cleavage of the captured thrombus clot. It also reduces the risk of IVCF dislodging and slipping in the vessel because its shape expands in the radial direction, allowing its distal end to fit closely to the IVC wall, and because its contact structure with the inner IVC wall is curved, increasing the contact area and reducing the risk of the vessel wall being punctured by the IVCF support structure. We used ANSYS 2023 software to conduct unidirectional fluid-structure coupling simulation of four different forms of IVCF, combined with microthrombus capture experiments in vitro, to explore the impact of these four forms of IVCF on blood flow patterns and to evaluate the risk of IVCF perforation and IVCF dislocation. It can be seen from the numerical simulation results that the helical structure does have the function of inducing blood flow to undergo helical flow dynamics, and the increase in wall shear stress (WSS) brought about by this function can improve the situation of thrombosis accumulation to a certain extent. Meanwhile, the placement of IVCF will change the flow state of blood flow and lead to the deformation of blood vessels. In in vitro experiments, we found that the density of the helical support rod is a key factor affecting the thrombus trapping efficiency, and in addition, the contact area between the IVCF and the vessel wall has a major influence on the risk of IVCF displacement.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{huang2024numerical,
  author = {Yu Huang and Chao Li and Ming Liu and Ming Zhao and Ying Chen},
  title = {{Numerical simulation and in vitro experimental study of the hemodynamic performance of vena cava filters with helical forms}},
  booktitle = {Scientific},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1038/s41598-024-68925-3},
}
Figure