Numerical Simulation and Field Experimental Study of Combustion Characteristics of Hydrogen-Enriched Natural Gas

Chen Sun, Tiantian Wang, Pengtao Wang, Yi Zhang, Chong Cui, Yanghui Lu, Wei Liu, Yangxin ZhangProcesses 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates the combustion characteristics of hydrogen-enriched natural gas (HENG) in industrial boilers using both numerical simulations and field experiments. The findings show that adding hydrogen generally improves flame stability and expands combustion limits, but it also leads to a trade-off between boiler thermal efficiency and NOx emissions, suggesting careful optimization is needed for practical applications.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The global push for decarbonization is driving interest in hydrogen as a clean energy source. Hydrogen-enriched natural gas (HENG) offers a way to leverage existing natural gas infrastructure while reducing carbon emissions. However, integrating HENG into industrial applications like gas-fired boilers presents challenges. Specifically, while hydrogen can enhance flame propagation and stability, it can also lead to increased NOx emissions, which are subject to increasingly stringent regulations. Furthermore, understanding how HENG affects the overall performance, including thermal efficiency and heat loss, is crucial for its safe and efficient adoption. This paper aims to bridge the gap between theoretical combustion characteristics and practical boiler performance by combining detailed numerical simulations with real-world field tests on a commercial boiler.

Methods

The study employed a two-pronged approach:

  • Numerical Simulation: The researchers used Ansys Chemkin Pro with the FFCM-1 chemical kinetic mechanism to simulate the combustion characteristics of HENG. They specifically investigated:
  • Laminar Flame Propagation Speed (S₁): Modeled using the PREMIX model to understand how quickly the flame front moves.
  • Extinction Strain Rate (Kext): Modeled using the OPPDIF model (quasi-one-dimensional counterflow premixed flame model) to assess flame stability and resistance to blowout.
  • Flammability Limits: Calculated to determine the range of fuel-air mixtures that can sustain combustion.
  • Field Experimental Study: A 2 t/h gas-fired steam boiler (WNS2-1.25-Q) was used for on-site testing. The experiments focused on evaluating:
  • Boiler Thermal Efficiency: Measured using positive and negative balance methods.
  • Heat Loss: Analyzed through exhaust heat loss and cooling heat loss.
  • Pollutant Emissions: Specifically NOx, CO, and SO2, measured using a Testo 350 flue gas analyzer.
  • Chemical Reactor Network (CRN) Modeling: A CRN model, combining a Perfectly Stirred Reactor (PSR) and Plug Flow Reactors (PFRs), was developed in Chemkin Pro to simulate pollutant emissions and thermodynamic characteristics, offering a faster alternative to 3D CFD.

Datasets

Not explicitly discussed as "datasets" in the traditional machine learning sense. The study utilized:

  • Published Experimental Data: For validation of numerical models (e.g., Refs. [5, 6] for laminar flame speed, Ref. [26] for extinction strain rate).
  • Fuel Composition Data: Provided for natural gas and HENG mixtures used in the experiments (Table 6).
  • Instrument Accuracy Data: Detailed specifications for the measuring instruments used in the field tests (Table 7).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Hydrogen Boosts Flame Speed and Stability: Adding hydrogen to natural gas significantly increases the laminar flame propagation speed and the extinction strain rate, making the flame more robust and less prone to extinguishing, especially in fuel-lean conditions. This is a key enabler for stable combustion with HENG.
  • Expanded Combustion Limits: Hydrogen addition broadens the flammability limits of natural gas, allowing for stable combustion over a wider range of fuel-air mixtures, including leaner conditions. This is crucial for achieving lower emissions.
  • The NOx-Efficiency Trade-off is Real: The field tests revealed a critical trade-off: while increasing hydrogen content and excess air can help reduce NOx emissions by lowering peak combustion temperatures, it simultaneously leads to a decrease in the boiler's overall thermal efficiency. This is primarily due to increased exhaust heat losses.
  • Numerical Models Align with Reality: The numerical simulations (PREMIX, OPPDIF, and CRN models) showed good agreement with the experimental results, validating their predictive capabilities for HENG combustion characteristics and boiler performance.

Key Results

  • Laminar Flame Speed: Increased monotonically with hydrogen blending ratio (0-25%), showing a 20-32% increase depending on the equivalence ratio.
  • Extinction Strain Rate: Increased monotonically with hydrogen blending ratio (0-25%), showing a 50-81% increase.
  • Field Tests (0-10% H₂):
    • Thermal Efficiency: Decreased slightly from 88.95% to 87.22% across three test cases.
  • NOx Emissions: Decreased from 118 mg/m³ to 112 mg/m³ as hydrogen increased from 0% to 9.7%, but then increased to 125 mg/m³ at 10.1% hydrogen.
  • Modeling Results (0-30% H₂):
    • Thermal Efficiency: Decreased from 88.66% to 87.67%.
  • NOx Emissions: Decreased from 128 mg/m³ to 91 mg/m³.
  • Excess Air Ratio: Increased from 1.23 to 1.37.
  • Theoretical Combustion Temperature: Decreased from 1712 °C to 1597 °C.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited Hydrogen Blending Ratio in Field Tests: The field experiments were conducted with relatively low hydrogen blending ratios (up to ~10%). While modeling extended this to 30%, further experimental validation at higher ratios would be beneficial.
  • Trade-off Management: The study highlights the trade-off between NOx reduction and thermal efficiency. Future work could focus on developing control strategies and burner designs that optimize this balance, potentially through advanced combustion control or heat recovery systems.
  • Long-term Stability: While the study mentions verifying combustion stability for long periods, the detailed results of such long-term operation are not presented. Future research could explore the long-term operational impacts of HENG.
  • Broader Range of Boiler Types: The study focused on a specific type of gas-fired steam boiler. Investigating HENG combustion in other industrial boiler configurations would broaden the applicability of the findings.

Summary updated

Abstract

For the safe and efficient utilization of hydrogen-enriched natural gas combustion in industrial gas-fired boilers, the present study adopted a combination of numerical simulation and field tests to investigate its adaptability. Firstly, the combustion characteristics of hydrogen-enriched natural gas with different hydrogen blending ratios and equivalence ratios were evaluated by using the Chemkin Pro platform. Secondly, a field experimental study was carried out based on the WNS2-1.25-Q gas-fired boiler to investigate the boiler’s thermal efficiency, heat loss, and pollutant emissions after hydrogen addition. The results show that at the same equivalence ratio, with the hydrogen blending ratio increasing from 0% to 25%, the laminar flame propagation speed of the fuel increases, the extinction strain rate rises, and the combustion limit expands. The laminar flame propagation speed of premixed methane/air gas reaches the maximum value when the equivalence ratio is 1.0, and the combustion intensity of the flame is the highest at this time. In the field tests, as the hydrogen blending ratio increases from 0% to nearly 10% with the increasing excess air ratio, the boiler’s thermal efficiency decreases as well as the NOx emission. This indicates that there exists a tradeoff between the boiler thermal efficiency and NOx emission in practice.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{sun2024numerical,
  author = {Chen Sun and Tiantian Wang and Pengtao Wang and Yi Zhang and Chong Cui and Yanghui Lu and Wei Liu and Yangxin Zhang and Yang Zhang and Yangxin Zhang and Yang Zhang and Yang Zhang},
  title = {{Numerical Simulation and Field Experimental Study of Combustion Characteristics of Hydrogen-Enriched Natural Gas}},
  booktitle = {Processes},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3390/pr12071325},
}
Figure