Numerical Investigations of Tribological Characteristics of Biomimetic-Textured Surfaces

Wang Cheng, Jianlin Cai, Gong Cheng, Jiaxu Wang, Dongxing TangSustainability 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper numerically investigates how biomimetic surface textures, inspired by snakeskin and sharkskin, can reduce friction and wear in rail transit systems. By simulating these textures within a mixed lubrication model, the study demonstrates their potential to improve energy efficiency and reduce emissions in trains.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Rail transportation, while environmentally friendly compared to other modes, faces significant energy consumption and environmental pollution challenges due to friction and wear in its mechanical components, particularly in bearings. Reducing this friction is crucial for energy savings and achieving carbon neutrality goals. While biomimetic surfaces have shown promise in other applications, there's a need for more in-depth numerical analysis of their tribological performance in the specific context of rail transit, especially under mixed lubrication conditions. This paper aims to fill this gap by numerically simulating and evaluating the effectiveness of snake- and sharkskin-inspired textures in reducing friction and wear.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-faceted numerical approach:

  • Surface Generation: They simulated biomimetic textures inspired by snakeskin (hexagonal protrusions) and sharkskin (bar-shaped protrusions with a secondary texture) using mathematical expressions. These simulations were then combined with realistic roughness profiles.
  • Tribological Modeling: A three-dimensional deterministic model for line-contact mixed elastohydrodynamic lubrication (EHL) was utilized. This model incorporates:
  • Transient Reynolds Equation: To capture the hydrodynamic pressure generated by the lubricant.
  • Load-Balance Equation: Ensuring the calculated pressure distribution supports the applied external load. The Greenwood and Tripp (GT) model was used for asperity contact pressure.
  • Transient Film Thickness Equation: Accounting for the normal distance between surfaces, initial contact geometry, elastic deformation, and wear depth.
  • Transient Wear Model: Based on Archard's theory to calculate wear volume and depth.
  • Simulation Procedure: The process involved generating the bionic surfaces in MATLAB, then inputting these into a Fortran-based mixed lubrication-wear model. The simulation progressed through steady-state calculations followed by transient analysis, iteratively updating film thickness and wear.
  • Verification: The model's effectiveness was validated by comparing its simulation results for snakeskin texture's friction coefficient against areal density with existing experimental data from Zhong et al. [20].

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on simulated surfaces and parameters derived from existing literature for material properties and experimental conditions.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Biomimicry for Efficiency: The core idea is that nature's designs (snake and shark skin) offer valuable blueprints for reducing friction and wear, directly translating to energy savings in mechanical systems like train bearings.
  • Texture Matters, But So Does Context: The effectiveness of these biomimetic textures is highly dependent on the operating conditions (speed, slide-to-roll ratio, contact type). What works well in one scenario might not in another.
  • Snakeskin's High-Speed Advantage: Under line-contact conditions, snakeskin-inspired textures show a significant reduction in friction and wear at higher speeds (above 1 m/s), suggesting their utility in operational phases of train movement.
  • Sharkskin's Superior Film Thickness: The sharkskin texture, with its additional bar-shaped protrusions, creates a more pronounced wedge effect, leading to larger average film thicknesses and lower contact load ratios compared to snakeskin under similar line-contact conditions. This indicates better lubrication performance.
  • Point Contact Challenges: For point-contact scenarios, the biomimetic textures, particularly sharkskin, showed less favorable results, sometimes even deteriorating performance. This highlights the importance of contact geometry.

Key Results

  • Line Contact:
    • At high speeds (e.g., >1 m/s), snakeskin textures reduced friction coefficient and wear volume compared to rough surfaces.
  • Sharkskin textures generally outperformed snakeskin in line contact, achieving larger film thicknesses and lower contact load ratios, leading to improved friction and wear properties, especially within a slide-to-roll ratio range of 0.8 to 1.6.
  • The sharkskin texture achieved its minimum friction coefficient at a slide-to-roll ratio of 1.2.
  • Point Contact:
    • Snakeskin textures showed a better effect at low speeds.
  • Sharkskin textures showed no improvement and even deteriorated surface properties under point-contact conditions, making them not recommended for such scenarios.
  • Model Validation: The numerical model's results for snakeskin texture's friction coefficient versus areal density showed good agreement with existing experimental data.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Fixed Loads: The current study focused on fixed loads. Future research should investigate the tribological properties under varying loads, as experienced in real train operation.
  • Limited Texture Types: Only two specific biomimetic textures (snakeskin and sharkskin) were studied. Exploring other bionic textures or multi-layer textures could yield further improvements.
  • Specific Conditions: The effectiveness of biomimetic textures is strongly tied to specific working and contact conditions. Identifying optimal conditions for each texture is crucial.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest exploring new textured surfaces and varying loads to further optimize energy saving and emission reduction in rail transit. Investigating multi-layer textures could also enhance performance.

Summary updated

Abstract

Rail transportation has dramatically improved travel convenience, but it has also led to environmental pollution and energy consumption issues. These challenges can be partially addressed by reducing friction loss in the mechanical transmission of rail systems. This paper examines the tribological properties of bionic-textured surfaces inspired by snake- and sharkskin. This study focuses on generating bionic textured surfaces with randomly distributed peaks through numerical simulation and connecting them to a transient Reynolds equation and friction fatigue model. The bionic surface wear lubrication model considers the lubricating film’s thickness and contact pressure obtained from the GT model. The results reveal that the existence of a bionic texture can reduce the friction coefficient and wear amount on the contact surface. The findings of this study not only offer a potential solution for reducing energy consumption and emissions in intelligent rail transit systems but also hold promise for providing further insights into the numerical simulation of bionic weaving and the investigation of tribological characteristics.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{cheng2023numerical,
  author = {Wang Cheng and Jianlin Cai and Gong Cheng and Jiaxu Wang and Dongxing Tang},
  title = {{Numerical Investigations of Tribological Characteristics of Biomimetic-Textured Surfaces}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/su151713054},
}
Figure