Numerical Investigation of Rock Breaking Mechanism With Supercritical Carbon Dioxide Jet by SPH-FEM Approach

Chun Yang, Jianhua Hu, Shaowei MaIEEE Access 2019 · DOI

Introduction

In the fields of petroleum and mining engineering, the efficiency of rock-breaking processes is a primary driver of operational success. While traditional methods such as mechanical drilling and high-pressure water jetting are industry standards, they often encounter performance plateaus or present environmental challenges. Supercritical carbon dioxide (SC-CO2)—a state where CO2 exhibits the density of a liquid and the diffusivity of a gas—has emerged as a transformative alternative. Its unique properties, including low viscosity and high density, make it an exceptionally potent medium for rock erosion.

Despite its potential, the physical mechanisms of SC-CO2 rock breaking remain difficult to observe. High-speed photography is frequently obscured by the rapid expansion of the CO2 jet and the resulting debris. Furthermore, traditional numerical models often struggle with the extreme deformations involved. This study addresses these gaps by introducing a hybrid numerical approach to simulate and analyze the interaction between SC-CO2 jets and rock formations.

Schematic of the experimental system used to validate the numerical model, showing the flow from CO2 storage to the rock sample.

The Hybrid SPH-FEM Approach

To accurately model the complex dynamics of a high-velocity jet hitting a solid target, the researchers employed a hybrid algorithm combining Smoothed Particle Hydrodynamics (SPH) and the Finite Element Method (FEM) within the LS-DYNA software environment.

  • SPH for Fluid Dynamics: The SC-CO2 jet is modeled using SPH, a meshless Lagrangian method. Unlike grid-based methods, SPH uses particles to represent the fluid, allowing it to handle the "drastic volume expansion" and splashing of the jet without the numerical instability caused by mesh distortion.
  • FEM for Structural Integrity: The rock sample and transport pipe are modeled using FEM. This method is computationally efficient and provides high accuracy for solid structures undergoing the stresses of impact.
  • Fluid-Solid Coupling: The interaction between the jet and the rock is managed through a coupling mechanism where SPH particles interact with FEM nodes at the boundary, facilitating the transfer of momentum and stress.

The thermodynamic behavior of the supercritical fluid was governed by the Peng-Robinson (P-R) equation of state, ensuring the simulation reflected real-world CO2 properties under high pressure and temperature.

The "Air Wedge Effect": A New Breaking Mechanism

The most significant discovery of this investigation is the "air wedge effect." Unlike water jets, which primarily erode rock through external impact and shear, the high diffusivity of SC-CO2 allows it to penetrate microscopic pores and cracks on the rock's surface.

Conceptual diagram illustrating the transition of CO2 into a supercritical state within the pipe before impacting the rock sample.

As the SC-CO2 seeps into these micro-fractures, it creates intense internal pressure that "wedges" the rock apart from the inside. This triggers tensile failure—a mode where rock is significantly weaker than in compression. This dual action of surface erosion and internal exfoliation leads to a much more rapid destruction of the rock material than traditional methods.

The study identified five distinct stages in the rock-breaking process:

  1. Stationary (0–6 µs): The jet makes initial contact; energy is absorbed without immediate fracture.
  2. Slowly Rising (6–35 µs): Initial failure begins at the impact zone's surface.
  3. Steep Rising (35–42 µs): The failure zone expands rapidly as the air wedge effect takes hold.
  4. Decreasing Rate (42–66 µs): The rate of failure slows as the jet's energy disperses into the growing cavity.
  5. Termination (>66 µs): The process stabilizes as the CO2 drains from the impact site.

Results and Validation

The simulation successfully replicated the physical phenomena observed in laboratory experiments. Notably, it captured the massive volume expansion of the CO2, which grew from 6.95 cm³ to 19 cm³ in just 66 microseconds. The resulting erosion cavities—typically inverted cone shapes with irregular, rough surfaces—closely matched the profiles of artificial rock samples used in physical tests.

Furthermore, the model revealed that while pressure stress is the primary driver of the initial impact, shear stress at the edges of the contact zone is responsible for the initial "compression-shear" failure that precedes the deeper tensile fracturing.

Conclusion and Future Directions

This research provides a robust framework for understanding the superior drilling performance of SC-CO2 jets. By identifying the air wedge effect, the study offers a theoretical basis for optimizing jet parameters in industrial applications.

However, the authors note that the current model assumes rock is an isotropic and continuous material. Real-world geological formations are heterogeneous, containing natural fractures and varying mineral compositions. Future work will focus on incorporating these complexities, such as multi-porosity and pre-existing bedding planes, to further refine the predictive power of the SPH-FEM model.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{yang2019numerical,
  author = {Chun Yang and Jianhua Hu and Shaowei Ma},
  title = {{Numerical Investigation of Rock Breaking Mechanism With Supercritical Carbon Dioxide Jet by SPH-FEM Approach}},
  journal = {IEEE Access},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1109/access.2019.2913172},
}
Figure