Numerical Investigation of a Local Precise Reinforcement Method for Dynamic Stability of Rock Slope under Earthquakes Using Continuum–Discontinuum Element Method

Danqing Song, Wanpeng Shi, Chengwen Wang, Lihu Dong, He Xin, Enge Wu, Jianjun Zhao, Runhu LuSustainability 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a "local precise reinforcement" method for earthquake-prone rock slopes, using a sophisticated numerical simulation technique (CDEM). The study demonstrates that targeted reinforcement in specific high-risk areas (toe, crest, shallow surface) is as effective as full-slope reinforcement, offering a more economical and efficient approach to landslide prevention.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Landslides, particularly those triggered by earthquakes, pose a significant threat to infrastructure and human safety, especially in seismically active regions like China. Traditional slope reinforcement methods are often broad and costly, and their effectiveness can be limited if not precisely applied to the areas most vulnerable to seismic damage. There's a critical need for methods that can accurately identify these vulnerable zones and apply reinforcement in a targeted, efficient, and cost-effective manner. This paper addresses this by proposing and numerically validating a "local precise reinforcement" strategy.

Methods

The core of this research lies in the application of the Continuum-Discontinuum Element Method (CDEM). CDEM is a powerful numerical technique that bridges the gap between Finite Element Method (FEM) and Discrete Element Method (DEM). It allows for the simulation of both continuous material behavior (like intact rock) and discontinuous behavior (like fractures and interfaces), making it ideal for modeling the progressive failure of rock slopes under seismic loading.

The researchers established six numerical models of a high-steep anti-dip rock slope:

  1. Unreinforced: A baseline model to understand natural seismic response.
  2. Local Reinforcement (Toe): Reinforcement applied to the slope toe.
  3. Local Reinforcement (Shallow Surface): Reinforcement applied to the shallow slope surface.
  4. Local Reinforcement (Crest): Reinforcement applied to the slope crest.
  5. Local Reinforcement (Toe & Shallow Surface): Combined reinforcement at toe and shallow surface.
  6. Overall Reinforcement: Comprehensive reinforcement of the entire slope.

They simulated seismic loading (0.5g horizontal acceleration) and analyzed displacement, acceleration amplification (PGA/PGD), and crack development (equivalent crack ratio) across these models.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on a specific geological model of an anti-dip rock slope in Tibet, China, with parameters derived from basic geotechnical tests.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Dynamic Amplification Zones are Key: The study highlights that the slope toe, crest, and shallow surface experience the largest dynamic amplification effects during earthquakes. These are identified as the critical areas for targeted reinforcement.
  • The "Sweet Spot" for Reinforcement: Local precise reinforcement is not a "more is better" scenario. The research indicates that the optimal effect is achieved within the first three applications of local reinforcement. Beyond this, the reinforcement effect can actually worsen, suggesting a need for careful control of reinforcement intensity.
  • Local Precision Matches Global Performance: Remarkably, the study found that after three applications of local precise reinforcement, the slope's dynamic amplification effect, equivalent crack ratio, and mechanical energy become comparable to those of overall, comprehensive reinforcement. This is a major finding for cost-effectiveness.
  • CDEM's Power: The successful application of CDEM demonstrates its capability in simulating complex seismic-induced failure mechanisms and evaluating reinforcement strategies.

Key Results

  • The unreinforced slope (Case 1) experienced significant displacement, particularly at the toe.
  • Local reinforcement at the slope toe (Case 2) significantly reduced displacement compared to the unreinforced case.
  • Reinforcement at the crest (Case 4) and combined toe/shallow surface reinforcement (Case 5) showed varying degrees of effectiveness, with Case 5 showing a slight increase in displacement compared to Case 4, reinforcing the idea that excessive local reinforcement can be detrimental.
  • The displacement and damage characteristics of Case 4 (three local reinforcements) were found to be very similar to Case 6 (overall reinforcement).
  • The ratio of PGA and PGD for Case 6 was found to be less than or similar to that of local reinforcement models, suggesting local reinforcement can be equally effective.
  • The equivalent crack ratio analysis showed that local reinforcement is beneficial up to three applications, after which the effect diminishes.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited Reinforcement Types: The study primarily focused on "grouting reinforcement" by increasing cohesion. Future work could explore other reinforcement methods (e.g., piles, anchors) and their effectiveness with the local precise approach.
  • Single Case Study: The findings are based on a single, specific anti-dip rock slope. While representative, validation on a wider range of slope types and geological conditions would strengthen the conclusions.
  • Seismic Wave Simplification: The use of simple harmonic input for seismic waves, while avoiding conversion errors, might not fully capture the complex characteristics of real earthquake ground motions.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that this method can be applied to real-world engineering by integrating detailed field investigations, UAV surveys, and 3D geological modeling to precisely identify and reinforce critical areas. They emphasize the potential for improving the precision, reliability, and economy of slope deformation control.

Summary updated

Abstract

The slope reinforcement scheme has an important influence on the prevention and control of landslides. A reasonable reinforcement scheme can improve the reliability, economy and efficiency of landslide resistance. It is urgent to establish a local precise reinforcement method for landslides on the basis of clear process and the instability modes of landslides. Taking a high-steep anti-dip rock slope as an example, six numerical models are established by using the continuum–discontinuum element method (CDEM) to carry out seismic damage and dynamic analysis of slopes. By comparing the seismic response and damage characteristics of being unstrengthened, local precise reinforcement and overall reinforcement models, the applicability of the proposed local precise reinforcement method for the slopes is discussed. The results show that the determination of the dynamic amplifying effect and seismic damage characteristics of slopes is the primary prerequisite of the local precise reinforcement method. The dynamic amplification effect of the slope toe, crest and shallow slope surface are much larger, that is, they are the potential reinforcement areas. The local precision reinforcement times should be controlled within a certain number of times, and the slope after the first three times of the local reinforcement effect is the best. However, more than three times after the reinforcement effect it becomes worse. Moreover, the dynamic amplification effect, the equivalent crack ratio and the mechanical energy of the slope after three times of local precision reinforcement are similar to the overall reinforcement effect, which indicates that local precision reinforcement has good feasibility. This work can provide references for landslide disasters prevention and control.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{song2023numerical,
  author = {Danqing Song and Wanpeng Shi and Chengwen Wang and Lihu Dong and He Xin and Enge Wu and Jianjun Zhao and Runhu Lu},
  title = {{Numerical Investigation of a Local Precise Reinforcement Method for Dynamic Stability of Rock Slope under Earthquakes Using Continuum–Discontinuum Element Method}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/su15032490},
}
Figure