Abstract: The sunset diagram of $\lambda\phi^4$ theory is evaluated numerically in a cutoff scheme, revealing a nonzero finite term in accordance with dimensional regularization (DR) results, contrary to previously published calculations. This finding dramatically reduces the critical couplings for symmetry breaking in the two-loop effective potential, bringing theoretical predictions closer to physically intuitive values.
Introduction
In quantum field theory (QFT), the calculation of loop diagrams is fundamental to understanding particle interactions. However, these calculations often yield divergent results that require regularization. While Dimensional Regularization (DR) is the standard due to its preservation of gauge invariance, cutoff regularization—where integration is capped at a high-energy scale $\Lambda$—remains physically intuitive, particularly in effective field theories.
A persistent challenge in cutoff regularization is the evaluation of multiloop diagrams, such as the "sunset" diagram. Previous landmark studies, including those by Jackiw, omitted a specific finite constant ($C$) in their cutoff calculations, often assuming it to be zero. This paper re-evaluates this assumption, investigating how the inclusion of this constant affects the "critical coupling" ($\lambda_{cr}$), the interaction strength required to trigger dynamical symmetry breaking.
Numerical Methodology
To isolate the finite part of the divergent sunset integral, we employed a hybrid analytical-numerical approach. First, we applied mass differentiation with respect to the mass parameter ($M$) to remove aggressive power-law divergences ($\Lambda^2$), leaving only logarithmic divergences and finite terms.
We performed the first loop integration analytically to reduce complexity, followed by a numerical solution for the remaining one-dimensional integral. Because the integrand becomes exceptionally steep near the origin, we implemented a variable step-size strategy. This approach uses significantly smaller steps near the origin and larger steps in the asymptotic regime to maintain high precision without excessive computational cost.
The Discovery of the Finite Term
Our numerical analysis demonstrates that the finite constant $C$ in the cutoff scheme is not zero, but rather lies approximately between $4$ and $4.3$. This finding is significant because it aligns the cutoff scheme more closely with the results obtained through DR. While DR is mathematically elegant, it relies on implicit subtractions; our results suggest that cutoff regularization can provide a more transparent view of these finite contributions, which is especially valuable in contexts like nucleon interaction effective theories.
Impact on Critical Couplings
The inclusion of the finite term $C \approx 4$ leads to a major revision of the critical coupling constants required for dynamical symmetry breaking. In the Jackiw scheme, the critical coupling $\lambda_{cr}$ dropped from a previous value of $6.5797$ to $2.7181$. Similarly, the stability threshold ($\hat{\lambda}_{cr}$) plummeted from $10.698$ to $2.8967$.
These revised values are more physically intuitive. Physicists generally expect critical couplings to be closer to unity; our results move the theory away from the "very large coupling" regime (around 10) and into a more reasonable range (around 2–3).
Conclusion
By identifying and calculating the previously overlooked finite term in the sunset diagram, we have shown that dynamical symmetry breaking in $\lambda\phi^4$ theory occurs at significantly lower coupling strengths than previously thought. This work demonstrates that high-precision results for divergent multiloop diagrams can be achieved through smart subtraction and variable-step numerical integration, providing a robust alternative to purely analytical methods in complex regularization schemes.
Summary updated