Numerical and Experimental Investigation of Photovoltaic/Thermal Systems: Parameter Analysis and Determination of Optimum Flow

Yan Bin, Qiuxuan Wu, Xiaoni Chi, Chenxi Wu, Ping Luo, Yanbin Luo, Pingliang ZengSustainability 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper tackles the challenge of optimizing photovoltaic/thermal (PV/T) systems for maximum energy output by developing and validating a 3D numerical model. They identify key operating parameters and propose a dynamic flow control strategy that, through experimental validation, increases overall energy gain by 2.5% compared to fixed flow rates.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Photovoltaic (PV) cells convert sunlight into electricity, but a significant portion of absorbed solar energy is lost as heat, leading to reduced electrical efficiency and potentially shorter lifespans. Photovoltaic/thermal (PV/T) systems aim to mitigate this by simultaneously generating electricity and capturing waste heat for thermal applications. However, the performance of PV/T systems is highly sensitive to various operating parameters like solar radiation, ambient temperature, coolant inlet temperature, and coolant mass flow rate. Finding the optimal operating conditions, especially the coolant flow rate, is crucial for maximizing the combined electrical and thermal energy output. Previous research often studied these parameters in isolation or assumed constant conditions, failing to address the dynamic nature of real-world environments. This paper addresses the need for a comprehensive understanding of these parameter interactions and the development of a control strategy for optimal performance under varying conditions.

Methods

The researchers employed a two-pronged approach:

  • 3D Numerical Simulation: They developed a three-dimensional computational fluid dynamics (CFD) model to simulate the heat transfer and fluid flow within the PV/T system. This model incorporated detailed physics of fluid dynamics, heat transfer, and the thermophysical properties of each component of the PV/T module (glass cover, EVA, PV cell, Tedlar, absorber plate, and water pipes). The model used the finite volume method with specific schemes for pressure interpolation (PRESTO!) and pressure-velocity coupling (SIMPLE algorithm).
  • Experimental Validation: An experimental platform was constructed to test the numerical model's accuracy. This platform included four identical PV/T modules, a water tank, pumps, and various sensors to measure solar irradiance, ambient temperature, inlet/outlet water temperatures, PVT surface temperature, and flow rate.
  • Parameter Analysis and Optimization:
    • Parametric Studies: The numerical model was used to systematically investigate the impact of individual parameters (solar radiation, inlet temperature, ambient temperature, and mass flow rate) on electrical and thermal efficiency.
  • Orthogonal Experimental Design (OED) and ANOVA: To efficiently study the combined effects of multiple parameters and identify their significance, an L16 orthogonal array was designed. This allowed for a reduced number of experiments (16 instead of 256) to cover four parameters at four levels each. Analysis of Variance (ANOVA) was then used to quantify the influence of each parameter and their interactions on the overall efficiency.
  • Mathematical Modeling and Flow Control: Based on the OED and ANOVA results, a mathematical model for the overall efficiency was established using regression analysis. This model was then used to derive a coolant mass flow control formula designed to dynamically adjust the flow rate based on real-time environmental conditions to maximize thermoelectric efficiency.

Datasets

The study utilized experimental data collected from an outdoor PV/T system in Hangzhou, China, over a period from June 2021 to May 2022. This data served as the basis for validating the numerical model and for conducting comparative experiments on flow control strategies. No pre-existing public datasets were explicitly mentioned or used for training.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Dynamic Flow Control is Key: The most significant insight is that a fixed, optimal mass flow rate is insufficient for maximizing PV/T system performance across varying environmental conditions. A dynamic flow control strategy, informed by real-time weather data, is essential.
  • Ambient Temperature Dominates: ANOVA revealed that ambient temperature has the most significant impact on overall PV/T efficiency, followed by inlet temperature. This highlights the importance of considering the external environment in system design and operation.
  • Interactions Matter: The study emphasized that combinations of parameters, particularly inlet temperature with solar radiation and inlet temperature with mass flow rate, have a substantial influence on overall efficiency, underscoring the need for holistic analysis.
  • Diminishing Returns of High Flow: While increasing mass flow rate generally improves efficiency, the benefits plateau and eventually diminish at very high flow rates. This is attributed to water exiting the collector tubes before completing sufficient heat exchange, and also increases pump power consumption.
  • PV/T's Cooling Efficacy: The temperature distribution analysis showed that the PV/T surface temperature remained below 50 °C, demonstrating the system's effective cooling capabilities.

Key Results

  • Model Validation: The numerical model showed reasonable consistency with experimental data, with average errors of 5.1% for thermal efficiency and 3.7% for electrical efficiency.
  • Solar Radiation Impact: Increasing solar radiation from 800 to 1000 W/m² led to a slower increase in thermal efficiency, indicating saturation effects. Electrical efficiency decreased as solar radiation increased due to higher cell temperatures.
  • Inlet Temperature Impact: Lowering the coolant inlet temperature significantly improved thermal gain and overall efficiency.
  • Mass Flow Rate Impact: Increasing mass flow rate from 60 to 320 L/h increased thermal efficiency by 8.24%. Electrical efficiency improved by 0.047% for every 40 L/h increase, but the rate of improvement slowed at higher flow rates.
  • ANOVA Findings: Ambient temperature was found to be the most influential factor on overall efficiency, followed by inlet temperature, mass flow rate, and solar radiation.
  • Flow Control Performance: The proposed dynamic flow control formula, when experimentally tested, resulted in a 2.5% increase in total energy gain compared to an optimal constant mass flow rate of 280 L/h.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Assumptions in the Model: The numerical model made several simplifying assumptions, including perfect contact between layers (ignoring thermal resistance), no dust/shadow effects, constant thermal physical properties, and non-compressed, turbulent fluid flow. These simplifications, while necessary for computational feasibility, might introduce some discrepancies with real-world scenarios.
  • Experimental Conditions: The experiments were conducted under typical summer conditions in Hangzhou. The performance of the dynamic flow control strategy might vary under different climatic conditions.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that the established mathematical model and flow control formula can be used to dynamically adjust the mass flow rate based on real-time weather conditions to improve thermoelectric efficiency. Further research could explore the application of this control strategy in different geographical locations and under a wider range of operating conditions. The investigation of other parameters, such as wind speed and humidity, could also provide a more complete understanding of PV/T system performance.

Summary updated

Abstract

The emergence of photovoltaic/thermal (PV/T) technology has effectively solved the problem of high temperature and low electrical efficiency of photovoltaic cells, and significantly improved the utilization rate of solar energy. At present, improving the thermoelectric performance of PV/T systems is a research hotspot. The effects of operating parameters such as inlet temperature, solar radiation, ambient temperature, and coolant mass flow rate, are investigated through numerical simulations. An experimental platform is built to verify the effectiveness of the three-dimensional numerical model. It is found that when the solar radiation changes from 800 W/m2 to 1000 W/m2, the increase rate in thermal efficiency will obviously slow down. When the coolant mass flow rate is increased from 60 to 320 L/h, the thermal efficiency is raised by 8.24%. For each 40 L/h increase in mass flow rate, the electrical efficiency increased by 0.047%. However, when the mass flow rate is too large, the increase in electrical and thermal efficiency gradually decreases. Orthogonal experiments and analysis of variance (ANOVA) are used to study the effects of each parameter and parameter combination on overall efficiency. The results show that ambient temperature has the greatest effect, followed by inlet temperature. Finally, the mathematical model of overall efficiency is established, and the coolant mass flow control formula is proposed. This formula can determine the optimal flow rate according to different environmental conditions, so that the system can operate under the optimal flow rate at all times and maximize the thermoelectric efficiency. Experimental results show that flow control increases the overall energy gain by 2.5% compared with the optimal constant mass flow.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{bin2022numerical,
  author = {Yan Bin and Qiuxuan Wu and Xiaoni Chi and Chenxi Wu and Ping Luo and Yanbin Luo and Pingliang Zeng},
  title = {{Numerical and Experimental Investigation of Photovoltaic/Thermal Systems: Parameter Analysis and Determination of Optimum Flow}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/su141610156},
}
Figure