Numerical Analysis on Passage and Blockage Behaviors of Fine Particles through an Orifice Consists of Coarse Particles

Masahiro Fukuda, Jun Suzuki, Hideki Kawai, Hiroshi NogamiISIJ 2015 · DOI

Abstract

Stable operation under low reducing agent rate conditions in blast furnaces is essential for reducing carbon emissions. However, these conditions generate significant amounts of fine powders, such as fine coke and unburnt pulverized coal. Accumulation of these powders in the packed bed deteriorates permeability and can cause operational failure. This study investigates the microscopic mechanics of powder flow and accumulation using Discrete Element Method (DEM) simulations. By modeling a simplified orifice consisting of three spherical coarse particles, the researchers tracked powder trajectories and identified the triggers for blockage. The results reveal that blockage is often initiated by a small number of particles forming a bridge, and that particle properties like diameter ratio and damping significantly influence passage behavior.

Introduction

The transition to greener steelmaking involves "low reducing agent rate" operations in blast furnaces. While environmentally beneficial, this approach increases the generation of fine powders within the furnace's packed bed. If these powders clog the gaps between larger materials, the furnace's permeability is compromised, hindering the flow of gases and liquids. Understanding the transition from free flow to catastrophic blockage is critical for maintaining operational stability. This research shifts the focus from macroscopic fluid dynamics to the microscopic mechanical interactions that govern individual particle passage and bridging.

Methodology: The Simplified Orifice Model

To isolate the mechanical drivers of blockage, the researchers employed the Discrete Element Method (DEM). This numerical technique tracks the individual trajectory and rotation of every particle, accounting for contact forces, friction, and energy dissipation.

The complex geometry of a blast furnace packed bed was simplified into a representative "orifice" model. This model consists of three coarse spherical particles (4.48 mm in diameter) arranged in an equilateral triangle, creating a narrow central opening.

Figure 1: The simplified orifice model consisting of three coarse particles in an equilateral triangle arrangement.

Fine powder particles, with diameters ranging from 0.448 to 0.596 mm, were dropped through this orifice under gravity. The simulation utilized a Voigt model—a combination of springs, dashpots, and sliders—to represent physical interactions. The study used physical properties based on glass beads (density of 2450 kg/m³, Young’s modulus of 71.3 GPa). Notably, gas flow was excluded from this stage of the study to focus purely on the mechanical "bridging" effect between particles.

Results and Discussion

The simulations provided a detailed look at how individual collisions lead to system-wide blockage, revealing that the process is often non-linear and highly sensitive to initial conditions.

The "Few-Particle" Trigger

A primary finding is that blockage does not require a gradual buildup of material. Instead, it is often triggered by just two or three particles entering the narrowest part of the orifice simultaneously. These particles form a stable "bridge" that then traps subsequent particles, leading to a rapid, catastrophic accumulation.

Figure 5: Simulation data showing the sudden spike in the number of particles within the orifice, indicating the initiation of a blockage.

Influence of Particle Properties

  • Diameter Ratio: The frequency of blockage peaks at a powder-to-coarse particle diameter ratio of approximately 0.11. This represents a balance: smaller particles pass too easily to bridge, while much larger particles are fed at lower frequencies (under constant mass flow), reducing the chance of simultaneous arrival at the gap.
  • Damping and Bounciness: The damping coefficient, representing energy loss during collisions, is critical. Particles with low damping (high "bounciness") are less likely to settle into a bridge. Conversely, high damping causes particles to lose kinetic energy quickly, making them more prone to stagnation and blockage.
  • Collision Dynamics: Successful passage is not a direct fall. Most particles take 2 to 3 times longer than free-fall time to clear the orifice, experiencing between 10 and 20 collisions. Particles that eventually contribute to a blockage often undergo significantly more collisions (up to 80) as they lose velocity and stagnate.

Conclusion

This microscopic analysis demonstrates that the initiation of blockage in a packed bed is a highly sensitive mechanical event. While the current model successfully identifies the role of particle geometry and damping, it excludes the influence of upward gas flow. In a real blast furnace, gas drag would counteract gravity, potentially altering the collision frequencies and bridging thresholds. Future research will focus on integrating these mechanical findings with gas-powder multiphase flow models to provide more comprehensive predictions for blast furnace operations.

Summary updated

Abstract

Stable operation under low reducing agent rate condition of blast furnace is necessary to realize to contribute solution of global warming. Under low reducing agent rate operation, large amount of powder materials like fine coke and unburnt pulverize coal generate in the furnace. It is known that the heavy accumulation of these powders in the packed bed of blast furnace deteriorates the permeability, and cause operation trouble in extreme case. Thus it is important to understand the flow and accumulation behaviors of powder in packed bed. This paper discussed the powder motion in the packed bed through numerical simulation under simplified condition. A simplified packing structure, namely an orifice consisting of three spherical particles that touched each other and were in equilateral triangle arrangement, was picked out from the packed bed. The powder trajectories passing through this orifice were tracked by using the discrete element method. The simulation results showed that only a few powder particles initiated the blockage of the particle orifice. Additionally the effects of mechanical properties of the particles on the passage and the blockage behaviors were also revealed.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{fukuda2015numerical,
  author = {Masahiro Fukuda and Jun Suzuki and Hideki Kawai and Hiroshi Nogami},
  title = {{Numerical Analysis on Passage and Blockage Behaviors of Fine Particles through an Orifice Consists of Coarse Particles}},
  booktitle = {ISIJ},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.2355/isijinternational.55.1291},
}
Figure