Numerical Analysis of the Impact Factors on the Flow Fields in a Large Shallow Lake

Haifei Liu, Zhexian Zhu, Jingling Liu, Qiang LiuWater 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel Lattice Boltzmann Method (LBM) model to simulate water flow in Baihe Lake, a large shallow lake. The study quantifies the impact of key factors like farmland drainage, rainfall, wind, and vegetation on water dynamics, providing crucial insights for ecological restoration efforts.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Wetlands, and large shallow lakes within them, are vital for ecosystem health and water resources. However, many Chinese wetlands, including the Momoge Wetland where Baihe Lake is located, are experiencing significant shrinkage. Understanding the complex water flow dynamics within these lakes is essential for effective conservation and restoration. Previous studies often relied on traditional numerical methods or lacked the ability to fully incorporate factors like aquatic vegetation. This paper aims to fill this gap by developing and applying an advanced LBM model to analyze the influence of various environmental factors on Baihe Lake's hydrodynamics, offering a more comprehensive and nuanced understanding.

Methods

The core of this research is the application of the Lattice Boltzmann Method (LBM), a modern numerical technique for computational fluid dynamics. Specifically, the authors adapted the LBM for non-linear two-dimensional shallow water equations. This method models fluid flow by tracking the movement and collision of fictitious particles on a lattice.

Key methodological aspects include:

  • Shallow Water Equations: The study uses depth-averaged hydrodynamic equations derived from the incompressible Navier-Stokes equations, suitable for shallow lakes where horizontal scales are much larger than vertical ones.
  • Lattice Boltzmann Equation: The paper details the LBM equation, including its components like the lattice pattern, kinetic equation, and equilibrium distribution.
  • External Force Term Integration: A significant contribution is the incorporation of various external forces into the LBM framework. This includes:
  • Gravity and Bed Friction: Standard components of hydrodynamic models.
  • Wind Shear Stress: Modeled using air density and resistance coefficients.
  • Aquatic Vegetation Drag: A novel aspect, where rigid vegetation is treated as vertical cylinders, and its drag effect is quantified using a drag force coefficient and projected area. This is crucial for lakes like Baihe with significant vegetation.
  • Boundary and Initial Conditions: The model employs specific boundary conditions (constant velocity/depth at inlet, zero-gradient at outlet) and bounce-back schemes. Initial conditions are derived from field data.

Datasets

The study utilizes data from 2017 for Baihe Lake, including:

  • Farmland Drainage Data: Inflow rates from surrounding farmland for different periods (May-June and October-November).
  • Wind Speed Data: Average wind speed and direction for the same periods.
  • Vegetation Distribution Data: Obtained through geographic information systems and field investigations, detailing the presence and density of aquatic vegetation.
  • Rainfall Data: Monthly rainfall figures for July and September 2017.

The paper also references existing literature for parameters like Manning's coefficient and vegetation drag coefficients.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Farmland Drainage Dominance: The most significant factor influencing Baihe Lake's flow field is the drainage from surrounding farmland. Even a 30% variation in inflow can lead to a substantial ~24% variation in outflow. This highlights the critical importance of upstream land management for lake health.
  • Vegetation's Nuanced Role: While vegetation exerts a drag force, its impact on the overall flow field is less pronounced than farmland drainage or rainfall. However, its negative correlation with outflow velocity and seasonal variation means it cannot be ignored, especially in lakes with dense aquatic growth.
  • Seasonal Dynamics Matter: The study's scenario simulations for July (flood season) and September (dry season) reveal distinct flow characteristics. The flood season exhibits better water exchange, emphasizing the need for season-specific restoration strategies.
  • LBM's Suitability for Vegetated Lakes: The LBM, with its ability to incorporate complex drag forces from vegetation, proves to be a powerful tool for simulating flow in lakes like Baihe, which are characterized by significant aquatic plant life.

Key Results

  • Flow Velocity: The simulation revealed very low flow velocities in Baihe Lake, with the lowest reaching 0.016 m/s. The western region, far from the inlet, had an average velocity of about 0.0016 m/s.
  • Wind Speed Impact: A 30% fluctuation in wind speed resulted in an ~18.77% variation in outflow velocity and a ~22.16% variation in average lake velocity.
  • Inflow Discharge Impact: A 30% fluctuation in inflow discharge led to a ~24.11% variation in outflow velocity and a ~27.65% variation in average lake velocity.
  • Vegetation Density Impact: A 30% fluctuation in vegetation density resulted in a ~4.88% variation in outflow velocity and a ~3.72% variation in average lake velocity.
  • Rainfall Impact: A 30% fluctuation in rainfall led to a ~21.11% variation in outflow velocity and a ~20.44% variation in average lake velocity.
  • Scenario Simulations: In July, with high inflow and rainfall, the outflow rate was 0.54 m/s. In September, with reduced inflow and rainfall, the flow rate was significantly lower, demonstrating the seasonal differences.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Model Simplifications: The model uses a two-dimensional approach, which simplifies the vertical flow dynamics. While appropriate for shallow lakes, it might miss some finer details. The vegetation model treats it as rigid cylinders, which is a simplification of more complex plant structures.
  • Data Granularity: While field data was used, the temporal and spatial resolution of some input parameters (like rainfall and wind) might influence the precision of the simulations.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that future research could explore more complex vegetation models, investigate the impact of sediment transport, and extend the model to three dimensions for a more comprehensive analysis. Further studies could also focus on integrating these findings into practical ecological restoration plans.

Summary updated

Abstract

Wetland acts as an important part of climatic regulation, water purification, and biodiversity maintenance. As an integral part of wetlands, large shallow lakes play an essential role in protecting ecosystem diversity and providing water sources. Baihe Lake in the Momoge Wetland is one such example, so it is necessary to study the flow pattern characteristics of this lake under different conditions. A new model, based on the lattice Boltzmann method, was used to investigate the effects of different impact factors on flow fields, such as water discharge from surrounding farmland, rainfall, wind speed, and aquatic vegetation. Importantly, this study provides a hydrodynamic basis for local ecological protection and restoration work.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{liu2019numerical,
  author = {Haifei Liu and Zhexian Zhu and Jingling Liu and Qiang Liu},
  title = {{Numerical Analysis of the Impact Factors on the Flow Fields in a Large Shallow Lake}},
  booktitle = {Water},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.3390/w11010155},
}
Figure