Null gravitational redshift by a Reissner–Nordström black hole in the strong field limit

Guansheng He, Chaohong Pan, Xia Zhou, Weijun Li, Lin LiThe European Physical Journal C 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a novel numerical method to calculate the gravitational redshift of light emitted from and received within the strong gravitational field of a Reissner-Nordström black hole. By developing exact null geodesic equations and a new integration technique, the authors enable the study of scenarios where both the light source and observer are close to the black hole, offering new avenues for testing gravity in extreme environments.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Gravitational redshift, the phenomenon where light loses energy (and thus shifts to lower frequencies) as it climbs out of a gravitational potential well, is a cornerstone prediction of General Relativity. While extensively tested in the weak-field solar system, understanding this effect in the strong-field regime near compact objects like black holes is crucial for probing gravity under extreme conditions. Traditionally, strong-field redshift studies assume the light receiver is infinitely far away, simplifying calculations. However, this paper tackles a more complex and realistic scenario: where both the light emitter and the receiver are located within the strong gravitational field of a Reissner-Nordström (RN) black hole. This presents a challenge because the positions of both the emitter and receiver might not be known simultaneously, complicating the calculation of the redshift.

Methods

The authors derive the exact null geodesic equations for light propagation in the Reissner-Nordström spacetime using harmonic coordinates. This is a foundational step, providing the precise mathematical description of light's path. The core innovation lies in a new numerical technique for integrating these geodesic equations. This technique addresses the challenge of unknown simultaneous positions by allowing the determination of one position (e.g., the emitter's) given the other (e.g., the observer's) and the light's trajectory. They achieve this by reversing the integration direction, effectively tracing the light path backward from the observer to the emitter. This approach is distinct from previous ray-tracing techniques used for Kerr black holes.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on theoretical calculations and numerical simulations based on the Reissner-Nordström metric, rather than observational datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Beyond the "Distant Observer": The paper moves beyond the traditional assumption of a distant observer, enabling the study of gravitational redshift in scenarios where both emitter and receiver are deep within a strong gravitational field. This is crucial for understanding phenomena near black holes and neutron stars.
  • Numerical Precision for Strong Fields: Developing exact geodesic equations and a robust numerical integration method is essential for accurately modeling light behavior in these extreme environments, where approximations might fail.
  • Potential for RN Black Hole Characterization: The study suggests that precise measurements of gravitational redshift could potentially constrain or even detect the electric charge of Reissner-Nordström black holes, offering a new observational probe for these objects.
  • Interdependence of Emitter and Receiver Positions: The work highlights that in strong-field scenarios, the gravitational redshift is not solely dependent on the emitter's position relative to the source but also on the receiver's position, and crucially, their relative positions along the null geodesic.

Key Results

The paper provides numerical calculations of the gravitational redshift ($Z_{RN}$) for both traditional (distant observer) and non-traditional (strong-field observer) scenarios in the Reissner-Nordström spacetime.

  • Magnitude of Redshift: The calculated redshift values in the strong-field regime are significantly larger than those observed in the weak-field solar system, underscoring the extreme nature of these environments.
  • Impact of Charge: Table 2 demonstrates that the electrical charge ($Q$) of the RN black hole has a measurable impact on the redshift, suggesting its potential detectability with high-precision instruments. Even a small charge ($Q = 0.01M$) shows a discernible effect.
  • Dependence on Positions: Tables 1, 3, and 4 illustrate how the redshift varies with the spatial positions of the emitter and receiver relative to the black hole's mass ($M$). The non-traditional scenario (Table 4) shows complex dependencies on the specific coordinates of both emitter and receiver.
  • Numerical Trajectories: Figure 2 visually represents the null trajectories of light in the strong field, illustrating the paths taken by photons under the influence of the RN black hole's gravity.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Static Emitter/Receiver Assumption: The current work assumes static emitters and receivers. Future work could extend this to include moving sources and observers, which is more realistic for astrophysical scenarios.
  • Harmonic Coordinates: While harmonic coordinates are used, exploring other coordinate systems might offer different computational advantages or insights.
  • Observational Feasibility: While the paper suggests potential for detecting the charge of RN black holes, the practical observational challenges of achieving the required precision in strong-field environments remain significant.
  • Generalization to Rotating Black Holes: The current study focuses on Reissner-Nordström black holes (non-rotating, charged). Extending the methodology to Kerr black holes (rotating, uncharged) or Kerr-Newman black holes (rotating, charged) would be a natural and important next step.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract The gravitational shift of electromagnetic frequency in the strong field limit is usually investigated under the common scenario, where the light receiver is far away from the central body while the emitter is in the strong-field region of the lens. In this paper, the gravitational frequency shift of light caused by a Reissner–Nordström (RN) black hole is studied numerically in the traditional strong-field scenario, as well as in the scenario where both the light emission and reception events happen in the strong-field region of the black hole. In order to obtain the numerical results of the gravitational redshift, we first derive the exact null equations of motion in the RN geometry in harmonic coordinates. For a given light observer, a new numerical technique is proposed in the integration of the geodesic equations to determine the spatial position of the emitter, considering the fact that their spatial positions are not always known simultaneously. Our work might be helpful to the related observations for probing strong gravity.
BibTeX
@article{he2020null,
  author = {Guansheng He and Chaohong Pan and Xia Zhou and Weijun Li and Lin Li},
  title = {{Null gravitational redshift by a Reissner–Nordström black hole in the strong field limit}},
  journal = {The European Physical Journal C},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1140/epjc/s10052-020-8085-5},
}

Loading related content...

Figure