Nuclearity in RST and signals of coherence relations

Debopam DasNAACL 2019

TL;DR

This paper investigates how the "nuclearity" of a discourse relation (whether it has a central nucleus or multiple equally important nuclei) affects how it's signaled, specifically by discourse markers (DMs). They found that multinuclear relations are more frequently signaled by DMs than mononuclear ones, suggesting that more complex relationships might require more explicit linguistic cues.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding how different parts of a text relate to each other is crucial for natural language understanding. Rhetorical Structure Theory (RST) provides a framework for this, categorizing relations based on the "nuclearity" of their spans: mononuclear relations have a central nucleus and a less important satellite, while multinuclear relations have multiple equally important nuclei. However, it's unclear how this nuclearity distinction impacts the linguistic signals used to mark these relations. Specifically, do multinuclear relations rely more on explicit markers like discourse markers (e.g., "but," "because") than mononuclear relations? This paper aims to bridge this gap by examining the relationship between RST nuclearity and the use of discourse markers.

Methods

The authors conducted a corpus study using two main resources:

  • RST Discourse Treebank (RST-DT): This corpus provides annotations of coherence relations within texts, including their nuclearity status.
  • RST Signalling Corpus (RST-SC): This corpus builds upon the RST-DT and annotates various linguistic signals that indicate these coherence relations, with a particular focus on discourse markers (DMs).

They analyzed the distribution of mononuclear and multinuclear relations within the RST-SC and examined which discourse markers are used to signal each type. They also looked at the syntactic categories of these DMs (coordinating vs. subordinating conjunctions) to see if there's a correlation with nuclearity.

Datasets

  • RST Discourse Treebank (RST-DT): Used for identifying coherence relations and their nuclearity.
  • RST Signalling Corpus (RST-SC): Used for analyzing the linguistic signals, particularly discourse markers, associated with these relations. The RST-SC is an expansion of the RST-DT.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Multinuclear relations are more DM-heavy: The most striking finding is that multinuclear relations are significantly more likely to be signaled by discourse markers than mononuclear relations. This suggests that the inherent complexity or symmetry of multinuclear relationships might necessitate more explicit linguistic cues for clarity.
  • DMs are not the only game in town: While DMs are important, the study reinforces that they are not the sole signal for coherence. A large majority of relations are signaled by other means, highlighting the multifaceted nature of discourse signaling.
  • Syntactic categories of DMs don't neatly map to nuclearity: The paper found no strong, consistent pattern where coordinating conjunctions exclusively signal multinuclear relations or subordinating conjunctions exclusively signal mononuclear ones. This suggests a more complex interplay between syntactic structure and discourse semantics.
  • The "strong nuclearity hypothesis" might be testable: The authors propose that the signaling patterns could potentially provide evidence for or against the "strong nuclearity hypothesis," which posits that relation properties should hold between the nuclei of text spans.

Key Results

  • Over 90% of relations (both mononuclear and multinuclear) are signaled by some linguistic cue.
  • Approximately 30% of multinuclear relations are signaled by discourse markers, compared to only about 15% of mononuclear relations.
  • The study identified common DMs for both mononuclear (e.g., "because" for Result, "if" for Condition) and multinuclear relations (e.g., "but" for Contrast, "and" for List).
  • While some DMs show associations with specific relation types (e.g., "if" with Condition), the relationship between DM syntactic categories (coordinating vs. subordinating conjunctions) and nuclearity was not straightforward. For instance, "while" can signal both mononuclear (Antithesis) and multinuclear (Contrast) relations.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Focus on DMs: The study acknowledges that its analysis is constrained to discourse markers, and a more comprehensive understanding would require investigating other signaling types like syntactic features, graphical signals, and reference features.
  • Complexity of Nuclearity Assignment: Determining nuclearity can be subjective, and the RST-DT's inclusion of a "both mono and multi" category reflects this difficulty.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest exploring how other relational signals interact with nuclearity, investigating the location of signals (within nucleus vs. satellite spans), and further testing the "strong nuclearity hypothesis" using signaling evidence. They also propose examining the role of syntactic structure and parallel constructions in signaling multinuclear relations.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{das2019nuclearity,
  author = {Debopam Das},
  title = {{Nuclearity in RST and signals of coherence relations}},
  booktitle = {Conference of the North American Chapter of the Association for Computational Linguistics},
  year = {2019},
}

Loading related content...

Figure