Novel theoretical constraints for color-octet scalar models *

Li Cheng, Otto Eberhardt, Christopher W. MurphyChinese 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper tightens theoretical constraints on a specific extension of the Standard Model (SM) that includes a color-octet scalar. By applying unitarity and stability conditions at next-to-leading order, the authors significantly narrow down the possible parameter space for this model, offering crucial guidance for future experimental searches.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The Standard Model (SM) of particle physics has been incredibly successful, but it's widely believed to be incomplete. Physicists are actively searching for physics beyond the SM (BSM). One promising avenue is to extend the Higgs sector. The Two-Higgs-Doublet Model (2HDM) is a well-studied extension, and the Manohar-Wise (MW) model is another, which includes a color-octet scalar. This paper focuses on a hybrid model, the 2HDMW, which combines aspects of both the 2HDM and the MW model by introducing two color-singlet Higgs doublets and one color-octet Higgs doublet.

While these models offer exciting possibilities, they also introduce many new parameters. To make meaningful predictions and guide experimental searches (like those at the LHC), these parameters need to be constrained. Previous studies have imposed constraints based on unitarity and potential stability, but these were often at leading order (LO) in perturbation theory. This paper aims to provide more rigorous constraints by extending these calculations to next-to-leading order (NLO) and beyond, and by deriving new conditions for the stability of the scalar potential.

Methods

The core of this work involves applying theoretical consistency conditions to the scalar sector of the 2HDMW model. The key methods are:

  • Unitarity Bounds: The S-matrix, which describes the probabilities of particle interactions, must satisfy unitarity. This means that probabilities cannot exceed 1. When a combination of model parameters becomes too large, unitarity is violated, indicating that perturbation theory is breaking down. The authors calculate these unitarity bounds at both LO and NLO, and also introduce an "NLO+" criterion that includes some higher-order effects. They use a specific algorithm that leverages LO calculations and one-loop beta functions to approximate NLO unitarity.
  • Potential Stability (Boundedness from Below): For a theory to be physically meaningful, its potential energy must have a global minimum. This requires certain combinations of the scalar potential's coupling constants (the "quartic couplings") to be positive. The authors derive a set of necessary conditions for this "boundedness from below" for the 2HDMW, extending previous work done for the 2HDM.
  • Renormalization Group (RG) Evolution: The parameters of a quantum field theory change with the energy scale at which they are measured. The authors study how the quartic couplings evolve with energy using RG equations. This is crucial for ensuring that the theory remains stable and perturbative up to high energy scales (multi-TeV region).
  • HEPfit Package: The authors utilize the open-source HEPfit package, a tool designed for combining theoretical and experimental constraints in particle physics models. While they focus on theoretical constraints here, HEPfit provides an efficient framework for sampling the parameter space and evaluating these constraints.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical constraints derived from fundamental principles of quantum field theory, rather than experimental data fitting.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • NLO Unitarity is More Restrictive: While LO unitarity bounds are important, the NLO and NLO+ unitarity conditions are found to be significantly more restrictive, especially at higher energy scales. This means that the parameter space allowed by NLO calculations is smaller.
  • New Stability Conditions: The paper derives novel conditions for the stability of the scalar potential in the 2HDMW. These conditions are crucial for ensuring the physical viability of the model and are more comprehensive than previous ones.
  • RG Running Matters: The stability of the potential and the validity of perturbative unitarity are not just assessed at the electroweak scale but are also checked as parameters evolve to higher energy scales (up to 63 TeV). This running behavior can significantly shrink the allowed parameter space.
  • Color-Octet Scalar's Impact: The presence of the color-octet scalar introduces new quartic couplings and interactions, which have a substantial impact on the unitarity and stability constraints compared to simpler models like the 2HDM or MW model.
  • Mass Splitting Constraints: The theoretical constraints also lead to upper limits on the mass differences between different scalar particles in the model.

Key Results

  • The paper presents detailed comparisons of unitarity bounds (LO, NLO, NLO+) and stability criteria at the electroweak scale and at higher energy scales (1 TeV and 63 TeV).
  • They show that requiring stability up to 63 TeV leads to significantly tighter constraints on the quartic couplings, forcing them into a much smaller range. For example, some quartic couplings are limited to values between -1.8 and 2.2 in the 2HDMW for stability at 63 TeV.
  • The derived stability conditions for the potential are applied and shown to constrain most of the quartic couplings.
  • The authors provide upper limits on the mass splittings between neutral scalars, finding that higher stability scales favor smaller mass differences.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Experimental Constraints: The paper explicitly states that combining these theoretical constraints with experimental data is a crucial next step. The current work focuses solely on theoretical consistency.
  • CP Violation: The analysis is performed assuming CP-conserving phases in the 2HDM sector. Investigating the impact of CP-violating phases would be a natural extension.
  • Yukawa and Gauge Couplings: The RG evolution calculations for unitarity bounds primarily consider quartic couplings, neglecting contributions from Yukawa and gauge couplings. Including these would provide a more complete picture.
  • Completeness of Stability Conditions: While new conditions for potential stability are derived, the authors note that they are necessary but not always sufficient, particularly when considering more than two non-zero scalar fields.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that their publicly available HEPfit implementation could be used for future studies combining these theoretical constraints with experimental data. They also highlight the importance of exploring the impact of CP-violating phases and including all relevant couplings in RG evolution.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract We study the theoretical constraints on a model whose scalar sector contains one color octet and one or two color singlet SU (2) L doublets. To ensure unitarity of the theory, we constrain the parameters of the scalar potential for the first time at the next-to-leading order in perturbation theory. Moreover, we derive new conditions guaranteeing the stability of the potential. We employ the HEPfit package to extract viable parameter regions at the electroweak scale and test the stability of the renormalization group evolution up to the multi-TeV region. Furthermore, we set upper limits on the scalar mass splittings. All results are given for both cases with and without a second scalar color singlet.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{cheng2019novel,
  author = {Li Cheng and Otto Eberhardt and Christopher W. Murphy},
  title = {{Novel theoretical constraints for color-octet scalar models *}},
  booktitle = {Chinese},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1088/1674-1137/43/9/093101},
}
Figure