Novel covalent triazine frameworks incorporating thiophene moiety for enhanced photocatalytic hydrogen production

Run Xu, Jianchao Zhang, Manman He, Bin Pan, Lianwei Liu, Guangquan Zhang, Rui Sun, Yuxuan Zhang, KeWei Song, Debin Kong, Lin WangJournal of Fuel Chemistry and Technology 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have developed a series of thiophene-based Covalent Triazine Frameworks (CTFs) using a mild synthesis route to create precise molecular-level "Donor-Acceptor" (D-A) junctions. By tuning the electronic structure with thiophene units, they achieved a remarkable photocatalytic hydrogen production rate of 15,650 μmol/(g·h), significantly outperforming traditional organic photocatalysts.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Photocatalytic water splitting—using sunlight to generate hydrogen—is a "holy grail" of clean energy. Covalent Triazine Frameworks (CTFs) are promising candidates for this task because they are stable, porous, and highly conjugated.

However, two major hurdles remain:

  1. Harsh Synthesis: Traditional CTFs are typically made via high-temperature ionic thermal synthesis. These extreme conditions often destroy the material's ability to respond to light (photoresponsiveness).
  2. Inefficient Charge Separation: In many organic polymers, the electrons and "holes" generated by light recombine too quickly before they can drive a chemical reaction.

The authors address these by using a mild "amidine polycondensation" method and designing a D-A architecture to pull charges apart more effectively.

Methods

The team synthesized three distinct CTFs: CTF-PP (the control), CTF-PTP (one thiophene unit), and CTF-TPT (two thiophene units).

  • Mild Synthesis: Instead of high heat, they used amidine polycondensation at moderate temperatures (up to 150 °C), which preserves the delicate electronic properties of the organic monomers.
  • Molecular Engineering: They strategically inserted thiophene moieties (electron donors) into the triazine-based skeleton (electron acceptor). This creates an internal electric field at the molecular level that "pumps" electrons away from holes.
  • Characterization & Simulation: The materials were analyzed using a suite of techniques including XRD, XPS, and SEM. Crucially, they used Density Functional Theory (DFT) calculations (via the MS Dmol3 module) to map out the HOMO and LUMO energy levels, confirming that their molecular design worked as intended.

Datasets

As an experimental chemistry paper, the primary "dataset" consists of the physical and chemical measurements of the three synthesized frameworks. The authors also benchmarked their results against a collection of 30+ previously reported organic photocatalysts (including various COFs and CTFs) to demonstrate that their CTF-TPT is among the top performers in the field.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Power of the D-A Junction: The study confirms that the thiophene moiety acts as an effective electron donor while the triazine unit acts as an acceptor. This D-A setup doesn't just improve charge separation; it systematically narrows the optical bandgap (from 2.55 eV in CTF-PP down to 2.16 eV in CTF-TPT), allowing the material to harvest more of the visible light spectrum.
  • Electronic Structure vs. Surface Area: Interestingly, CTF-TPT had the lowest specific surface area (128.83 m²/g) among the three but the highest hydrogen production. This suggests that for these materials, electronic tuning and charge carrier lifetime are more critical than raw porosity.
  • Extended Carrier Lifetimes: Using time-resolved fluorescence spectroscopy, the authors showed that the average lifetime of photo-generated carriers increased from 1.68 ns (CTF-PP) to 2.25 ns (CTF-TPT). Those extra picoseconds are vital for allowing electrons to migrate to the surface and reduce water to hydrogen.

Key Results

  • Hydrogen Production: CTF-TPT reached a peak rate of 15,650 μmol/(g·h). For comparison, the control material (CTF-PP) without the thiophene donor produced only 6,172 μmol/(g·h).
  • Quantum Efficiency: The materials showed high stability, maintaining consistent hydrogen production over multiple 4-hour cycles (20 hours total).
  • Bandgap Tuning: The team successfully tuned the bandgap from 2.55 eV to 2.16 eV, shifting the absorption edge deeper into the visible light range.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors note that while hydrogen production (the reduction half-reaction) is highly efficient, the overall process is still limited by the slow kinetics of water oxidation (the "hole" side of the reaction). This was observed as transient "spikes" in the photo-current measurements, indicating that holes accumulate at the surface.

Future research could focus on:

  1. Integrating these D-A CTFs with better oxygen-evolution co-catalysts to balance the reaction.
  2. Exploring the use of these frameworks for other solar-to-fuel applications, such as CO2 reduction or organic pollutant degradation.

Summary updated

Abstract

The increasing global demand for renewable and sustainable energy has made the development of clean and renewable energy sources crucial in addressing both global energy security and environmental challenges. Among all fuel options, hydrogen stands out due to its high energy density and emission of only water when burned, making it a highly regarded clean and promising alternative energy source. Moreover, the utilization of solar energy to produce hydrogen by efficient photolysis of water is a very promising strategy. Covalent triazine frameworks (CTFs) materials are a novel class of porous organic polymer materials that have garnered significant attention from researchers due to their exceptional characteristics, including high specific surface area, porosity, stability, and tunable active sites. In the realm of photocatalysis, CTFs exhibit remarkable light responsiveness owing to their planar π-conjugated structure and π-π stacking arrangement, which facilitate efficient charge carrier separation and migration within the material. The application of CTFs in the field of photocatalysis has received extensive attention. However, the reaction conditions for traditional high temperature ionic thermal synthesis of CTFs are harsh, which makes the material lose its photoresponsiveness. Consequently, the design and synthesis of CTF materials with exceptional photocatalytic properties remain highly challenging. The ideal photocatalyst should possess high light absorption capability and efficient carrier separation and transport efficiency. In order to enhance these properties, apart from altering the catalyst material, the incorporation of an electron donor-acceptor (D-A) junction is also a highly effective strategy. The D-A junction can precisely regulate the electron affinity between the D and A units at a molecular level to achieve charge separation and transfer. Moreover, the structural characteristics of the catalyst can significantly increase the number of active interfaces, thereby further enhancing its charge participation capability in the reaction. In CTFs materials, D-A structures also show extensive potential due to the excellent tunability of the CTFs skeleton structure. By adjusting the structure and proportion of D and A units, it becomes possible to modify the distribution position of LUMO and HOMO levels within the material, thereby accurately controlling the band structure and photoelectric properties at a molecular level. This precise control facilitates enhanced charge separation, transport, and ultimately leads to more efficient photocatalytic reactions. A novel CTFs was synthesized via amidine polycondensation under mild conditions, and D-A junctions were constructed at the molecular level through the controlled design of monomers to improve the photocatalytic hydrogen production. Herein, we successfully constructed three types of CTFs (CTF-PP, CTF-PTP and CTF-TPT). The photocatalytic hydrogen production activity of D-A type CTF-TPT with stronger electron donor capacity was as high as 15650 μmol/(g·h). The photocatalytic hydrogen production activity of CTF-PP without electron donor group was only 6172 μmol/(g·h). In addition, by means of electrochemical analysis and calculation, it has been determined that the thiophene moiety can serve as an effective electron donor unit, while the triazine moiety can function as an effective acceptor unit. Moreover, the incorporation of a donor-acceptor junction enables precise regulation of the bandgap position in CTFs at the molecular level, thereby facilitating charge separation and transport processes and ultimately enhancing photocatalytic performance.
BibTeX
@article{xu2025novel,
  author = {Run Xu and Jianchao Zhang and Manman He and Bin Pan and Lianwei Liu and Guangquan Zhang and Rui Sun and Yuxuan Zhang and KeWei Song and Debin Kong and Lin Wang},
  title = {{Novel covalent triazine frameworks incorporating thiophene moiety for enhanced photocatalytic hydrogen production}},
  journal = {Journal of Fuel Chemistry and Technology},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.3724/2097-213x.2024.jfct.0001},
}
Figure