Novel approach to soft tissue regeneration: in vitro study of compound hyaluronic acid and horizontal platelet-rich fibrin combination

Yun Qiu, Kailun Shen, Hongjiang Wei, Yufeng Zhang, Yulan Wang, Yi BaiJournal of Applied Oral Science 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This study explores a novel biomaterial combination of compound hyaluronic acid (CHA) and horizontal platelet-rich fibrin (H-PRF) for enhanced soft tissue regeneration. The CHA-PRF gel demonstrated superior in vitro efficacy in promoting human gingival fibroblast (HGF) proliferation, collagen synthesis, and migration compared to either component alone, suggesting its potential as a regenerative agent for periodontal and peri-implant applications.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Soft tissue grafting is a common procedure in dentistry, used to improve gingival thickness, treat recession, and enhance aesthetics around natural teeth and implants. While autologous grafts (tissue taken from the patient) are effective, they come with drawbacks like limited donor sites, donor site pain, and complex surgical procedures. This has driven the search for biomaterial substitutes that can achieve similar or better regenerative outcomes with fewer complications. Platelet-rich fibrin (PRF) has emerged as a promising autologous biomaterial due to its fibrin scaffold, growth factors, and cells, but its regenerative capacity can be further improved. Hyaluronic acid (HA), a naturally occurring component of connective tissue, has also shown potential in promoting fibroblast proliferation and collagen formation. This paper addresses the need for more effective and less invasive soft tissue regeneration strategies by investigating the synergistic effects of combining CHA and a specific type of PRF (H-PRF).

Methods

The researchers developed a CHA-PRF gel by mixing compound hyaluronic acid (CHA) and liquid horizontal platelet-rich fibrin (H-PRF) at a 1:1 ratio. They then evaluated its effects on human gingival fibroblasts (HGFs) in vitro.

Key techniques employed include:

  • CCK-8 Assay: To assess cell viability and proliferation over time when HGFs were exposed to CHA, H-PRF, or the CHA-PRF gel.
  • qRT-PCR: To measure the gene expression levels of key proteins involved in collagen formation (COL1A1) and cell migration (FAK).
  • Immunofluorescence Microscopy: To visualize the expression and localization of COL1A1 and F-actin (a cytoskeletal protein crucial for cell migration) within the HGFs.
  • Scratch Wound-Healing Assay: To evaluate the migratory capacity of HGFs by observing how quickly they close a "wound" created in a cell monolayer.
  • Transwell Migration Assay: To quantitatively assess HGF migration by measuring the number of cells that move through a porous membrane towards a chemoattractant.
  • Coagulation Time Test: To determine how the addition of CHA affects the clotting time of H-PRF.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study utilized in vitro cell cultures and experimental assays.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Synergistic Effect: The combination of CHA and H-PRF (CHA-PRF) demonstrably enhances soft tissue regeneration compared to either component alone. This suggests a synergistic interaction rather than just additive effects.
  • Accelerated Coagulation: CHA significantly reduces the coagulation time of H-PRF, which could be beneficial for clinical application by speeding up the preparation process.
  • Enhanced Cell Viability and Proliferation: The CHA-PRF gel significantly boosted HGF proliferation, indicating a more favorable microenvironment for cell growth.
  • Boosted Collagen Production: Both CHA and H-PRF individually promoted collagen synthesis, but the CHA-PRF combination led to the highest expression of COL1A1 and increased fluorescence intensity, suggesting superior extracellular matrix formation.
  • Improved Cell Migration: The CHA-PRF group showed the most significant improvement in HGF migration, as evidenced by both scratch wound-healing and Transwell assays. This is crucial for wound closure and tissue repair.
  • Cytoskeletal Remodeling: The study highlights the role of FAK and F-actin in the observed cellular responses, suggesting that CHA-PRF influences the structural organization of HGFs, facilitating their movement and function.

Key Results

  • Coagulation Time: Pure liquid H-PRF had an average coagulation time of 71 minutes, while the CHA-PRF mixture reduced this to 46.7 minutes.
  • Cell Proliferation: The CHA-PRF group consistently showed the highest cell viability from Day 1 to Day 7, with significantly higher cell density compared to control, CHA, and H-PRF groups.
  • Collagen Formation: Gene expression analysis showed that COL1A1 expression was highest in the CHA-PRF group. Immunofluorescence confirmed the highest COL1A1 fluorescence intensity in this group.
  • Cell Migration: In the scratch wound-healing assay, the CHA-PRF group showed the most complete closure of the scratch at 24 hours. Transwell assays indicated a significant increase in cell numbers in the lower chamber for the CHA-PRF group at both 24 and 48 hours, with CHA alone showing no significant effect.
  • FAK Expression: The CHA-PRF group exhibited the highest FAK gene expression, suggesting enhanced migratory potential.

Limitations and Future Work

  • In Vitro Study: The findings are based on in vitro experiments using HGFs. Further in vivo studies are necessary to validate these results in a living organism and assess the efficacy and safety of CHA-PRF for periodontal and peri-implant soft tissue regeneration.
  • Mechanism of Action: While the study demonstrates the effects of CHA-PRF, a deeper understanding of the precise molecular mechanisms by which CHA interacts with H-PRF to elicit these responses could be explored further.
  • Clinical Translation: The paper suggests that CHA-PRF could be a candidate for clinical use, potentially avoiding surgery. Future work should focus on translating these findings into clinical applications, possibly as an injectable gel or in combination with existing grafting techniques.
  • Long-Term Effects: The study evaluated effects over several days. Investigating the long-term stability and regenerative capacity of CHA-PRF would be beneficial.

Summary updated

Abstract

The CHA-PRF group exhibited greater potential to promote soft tissue regeneration by inducing cell proliferation, collagen synthesis, and migration in HGFs than the pure CHA or H-PRF group. CHA-PRF can serve as a great candidate for use alone or in combination with autografts in periodontal or peri-implant soft tissue regeneration.
BibTeX
@article{qiu2024novel,
  author = {Yun Qiu and Kailun Shen and Hongjiang Wei and Yufeng Zhang and Yulan Wang and Yi Bai},
  title = {{Novel approach to soft tissue regeneration: in vitro study of compound hyaluronic acid and horizontal platelet-rich fibrin combination}},
  journal = {Journal of Applied Oral Science},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1590/1678-7757-2023-0294},
}
Figure