Northern Hemisphere Urban Heat Stress and Associated Labor Hour Hazard from ERA5 Reanalysis

Shih‐Yu Lee, Shih‐Chun Candice Lung, Ping‐Gin Chiu, Wencheng Wang, I‐Chun Tsai, Thung-Hong LinInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study quantifies the increasing heat stress in Northern Hemisphere urban areas using ERA5 reanalysis data to calculate Wet-Bulb Globe Temperature (WBGT). It reveals a concerning trend of rising heat stress from 2015-2019, leading to significant potential reductions in labor hours, particularly in developing tropical regions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The world is warming, and with it, the intensity and frequency of heat stress are increasing. This poses a significant threat to human health, wildlife, and agriculture. While the general trend of rising temperatures is known, understanding the specific impacts of heat stress, especially in urban environments where a large portion of the global population resides, is crucial. Existing methods for assessing heat stress often rely on localized in-situ measurements, limiting their global or regional applicability. Furthermore, the economic and social implications of heat stress, particularly the reduction in labor capacity and its impact on outdoor workers, require detailed quantification. This paper aims to bridge this gap by providing a high-resolution, reanalysis-based assessment of urban heat stress and its direct consequence: reduced labor hours.

Methods

The core of this study lies in calculating the Wet-Bulb Globe Temperature (WBGT), a comprehensive metric that accounts for air temperature, humidity, wind speed, and radiation. The authors utilized the ERA5 reanalysis dataset, a high-resolution (0.25 x 0.25 degrees) global atmospheric dataset. They employed the Liljegren approach to calculate the outdoor WBGT*, which is a novel application of this method to a reanalysis product for urban-scale analysis. This approach involves calculating natural wet-bulb temperature (Tnwb) and globe temperature (Tg) from ERA5 variables like surface downward short-wave radiation, 2m temperature, dewpoint temperature, and wind components.

To translate WBGT into a measure of labor hazard, the study adapted the WBGT flag system, commonly used by military and occupational safety agencies. This system categorizes heat stress levels (no flag, yellow, red, black) and assigns corresponding rest times per hour for different work intensities. The researchers focused on heavy work (600 W)* to estimate the maximum potential reduction in labor capacity. They then aggregated these rest hours over the summer months (June-August) for selected urban areas.

Datasets

The primary dataset used in this study is the ERA5 reanalysis dataset, provided by the European Centre for Medium-Range Weather Forecasts. This dataset offers hourly atmospheric data at a spatial resolution of 0.25 x 0.25 degrees latitude and longitude. The study specifically utilized variables such as:

  • Surface downward short-wave radiation
  • 2 m near-surface temperature
  • 2 m dewpoint temperature
  • 10 m U and V wind components

The authors selected a list of metropolitan cities across Asia, Europe, and North America based on population counts, as detailed in Table 2. These cities were chosen to represent diverse geographical and climatic conditions.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • ERA5 as a powerful tool for urban heat stress analysis: The study demonstrates that high-resolution reanalysis data like ERA5 can effectively replace conventional in-situ measurements for assessing urban heat stress, enabling broader spatial and temporal coverage.
  • The 2015-2019 period saw a significant increase in heat stress: The research highlights a notable rise in heat stress across the Northern Hemisphere during the latter half of the decade, with tropical regions experiencing the most pronounced warming.
  • Urban labor hours are directly impacted by heat stress: The WBGT flag system, when applied to urban areas, reveals a tangible reduction in available labor hours, particularly in regions with high heat stress. This has direct economic and social consequences.
  • South and Southeast Asia are global hotspots for heat stress: These regions consistently show the highest levels of heat stress and consequently, the greatest potential for labor hour reduction, underscoring their vulnerability.
  • Regional variations in heat stress drivers: While global warming is the overarching driver, regional factors like aerosol effects and monsoon patterns play a significant role in modulating heat stress in areas like the Indo-Gangetic Plain.

Key Results

  • Continental Scale: A general increase in heat stress was observed across the Northern Hemisphere between 2010-2014 and 2015-2019. Tropical regions, particularly the northern Indian Peninsula, experienced the largest warming.
  • Urban Scale (Asia): Cities in South Asia, such as New Delhi, Karachi, and Dhaka, exhibited the highest accumulated rest hours (indicating significant heat stress) during the summer months. For instance, New Delhi accumulated approximately 1300 resting hours between 2010-2014, translating to about 170 minutes per day.
  • Urban Scale (Europe & North America): These regions generally experienced milder heat stress, with fewer accumulated resting hours compared to Asian cities.
  • Labor Hour Reduction: In some Asian cities, heat stress led to a potential reduction in labor hours by up to ~20%. This was particularly evident in the increase of "black flag" warnings (highest heat stress category) in the 2015-2019 period. For example, New Delhi and Kathmandu saw over 80% of their increased rest hours attributed to black-flag warnings.
  • Diurnal Variability: The study shows that the maximum WBGT* in cities like New Delhi reached critical thresholds earlier in the day and persisted later in the evening during the warmer years of the 2015-2019 period.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Urban Area Definition: The study defined metropolitan areas as a fixed grid size (200 km x 200 km), which might not perfectly capture the nuances of all urban extents.
  • Areal Averaging: Using areal averages for WBGT* calculation might lead to an underestimation of heat stress compared to point measurements, as it smooths out localized extreme conditions.
  • Work-Rest Cycle Application: The study used a standard for "heavy work" to estimate labor reduction. While this provides a benchmark, actual labor capacity reduction can vary based on specific job tasks, individual acclimatization, and available resources.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that reanalysis-product results, combined with model projections, can be valuable for urban planning and project designs to address future heat hazards. They also highlight the need for strategic adaptation measures that are locally dependent, considering the unique meteorological features of each climate zone. Further research could explore the impact of heat stress on different types of labor and investigate more localized urban planning strategies to mitigate these risks.

Summary updated

Abstract

Increasing surface air temperature is a fundamental characteristic of a warming world. Rising temperatures have potential impacts on human health through heat stress. One heat stress metric is the wet-bulb globe temperature, which takes into consideration the effects of radiation, humidity, and wind speed. It also has broad health and environmental implications. This study presents wet-bulb globe temperatures calculated from the fifth-generation European Centre for Medium-Range Weather Forecasts atmospheric reanalysis and combines it with health guidelines to assess heat stress variability and the potential for reduction in labor hours over the past decade on both the continental and urban scale. Compared to 2010-2014, there was a general increase in heat stress during the period from 2015 to 2019 throughout the northern hemisphere, with the largest warming found in tropical regions, especially in the northern part of the Indian Peninsula. On the urban scale, our results suggest that heat stress might have led to a reduction in labor hours by up to ~20% in some Asian cities subject to work-rest regulations. Extremes in heat stress can be explained by changes in radiation and circulation. The resultant threat is highest in developing countries in tropical areas where workers often have limited legal protection and healthcare. The effect of heat stress exposure is therefore a collective challenge with environmental, economic, and social implications.
BibTeX
@article{lee2022northern,
  author = {Shih‐Yu Lee and Shih‐Chun Candice Lung and Ping‐Gin Chiu and Wencheng Wang and I‐Chun Tsai and Thung-Hong Lin},
  title = {{Northern Hemisphere Urban Heat Stress and Associated Labor Hour Hazard from ERA5 Reanalysis}},
  journal = {International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/ijerph19138163},
}
Figure