Normal histone modifications on the inactive X chromosome in ICF and Rett syndrome cells: implications for methyl-CpG binding proteins

Stanley M. Gartler, Kartik Varadarajan, Ping Luo, Theresa K. Canfield, Jeff Traynor, Uta Francke, R. Scott HansenBMC 2004 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates the relationship between DNA methylation and histone modifications on the inactive X chromosome. By examining cells with defects in DNA methylation (ICF syndrome) and a key methyl-CpG binding protein (Rett syndrome), the researchers found that the inactive X chromosome maintains its characteristic silenced histone modification patterns even without normal DNA methylation or MeCP2 function. This suggests that DNA methylation and methyl-CpG binding proteins may not be as critical for establishing these patterns as previously thought.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In mammals, one of the two X chromosomes in females is largely inactivated to ensure dosage compensation. This inactivation involves a complex interplay of epigenetic modifications, including DNA methylation and histone modifications, which collectively silence gene expression on the inactive X (Xi). While it's known that DNA methylation and histone modifications are linked, the precise order and necessity of these events, particularly in the context of X inactivation, remain unclear. Specifically, the role of methyl-CpG binding proteins, such as MeCP2, in recruiting histone-modifying enzymes to establish the silenced state on the Xi is a key question. This paper aims to disentangle these relationships by examining the Xi in cells with known defects in DNA methylation (ICF syndrome) and in cells lacking functional MeCP2 (Rett syndrome).

Methods

The researchers employed a combination of cytological and molecular techniques:

  • Cytological Analysis of Histone Modifications: They used immunofluorescence microscopy to visualize specific histone modifications (H3 and H4 acetylation, H3 K4 and K9 methylation) and the presence of macroH2A1 on the inactive X chromosome in interphase nuclei and metaphase spreads. The inactive X was identified by DAPI staining as the sex chromatin body. The absence of a particular histone modification on the Xi appeared as a "hole" or "gap" in the stained region.
  • Chromatin Immunoprecipitation (ChIP) Analysis: To confirm cytological findings at the gene level, allele-specific ChIP was performed on promoter regions of X-linked genes (e.g., AR, SYBL1). This technique uses antibodies to precipitate DNA-protein complexes associated with specific histone modifications. By using polymorphic markers (CAG repeat in AR, XhoI site in SYBL1), they could distinguish between the active (Xa) and inactive (Xi) X chromosomes and assess their respective histone modification patterns.
  • Cell Lines: The study utilized cell cultures from individuals with ICF syndrome (mutations in DNMT3B, leading to hypomethylation) and Rett syndrome (mutations in MECP2, affecting a methyl-CpG binding protein). Control normal cell lines were also used.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on analyzing existing cell lines from patients and normal individuals.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • DNA Methylation is Not Strictly Required for Xi Histone Silencing: The most striking finding is that ICF cells, which are globally hypomethylated on their inactive X, still exhibit the characteristic silenced histone modification patterns (e.g., hypoacetylation, specific methylation marks) on the Xi. This challenges the idea that DNA methylation is a prerequisite for establishing these silencing marks.
  • MeCP2 is Not Essential for Xi Histone Silencing: Similarly, Rett syndrome cells, deficient in the methyl-CpG binding protein MeCP2, also show normal histone modification patterns on the inactive X. This suggests that while MeCP2 might play a role in gene regulation, it's not the primary driver for establishing the broad histone modification landscape of the Xi.
  • Independent Pathways for X Chromosome Silencing: The results support a model where different epigenetic mechanisms (DNA methylation, histone modification, XIST RNA, chromatin structure) involved in X inactivation may operate, at least partially, independently.
  • Potential for Alternative Methyl-CpG Binding Proteins: While MeCP2's role is questioned, the paper acknowledges that other methyl-CpG binding proteins might still be involved in the Xi silencing complex.

Key Results

  • Cytological Evidence: In both ICF and Rett syndrome cells, the inactive X chromosome displayed histone modification patterns consistent with silencing, similar to normal cells. This was observed for H3 and H4 acetylation, H3 K4 and K9 methylation, and macroH2A1 localization.
  • ChIP Analysis: Allele-specific ChIP analysis of the AR and SYBL1 genes confirmed the cytological findings. In ICF cells, the inactive X alleles showed histone modification patterns indicative of silencing, despite significant hypomethylation of their CpG islands. Similarly, Rett syndrome cells exhibited normal Xi histone modification patterns.
  • Quantitative Data: While specific percentages are not the focus, the qualitative observations across multiple histone marks and genes consistently pointed to the preservation of Xi silencing marks in the mutant cell lines.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited Scope of Analysis: The study focused on specific histone modifications and a limited number of X-linked genes. It's possible that other histone modifications or genes not analyzed might be affected by DNA methylation or MeCP2.
  • "Hole" Artifact: The authors acknowledge that the "hole" observed in immunofluorescence staining might not perfectly represent the entire inactive X, and a small portion of the Xi might have been missed.
  • Other Methyl-CpG Binding Proteins: The study specifically investigated MeCP2. The role of other methyl-CpG binding proteins in Xi silencing remains an open question.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest that further investigation into the specific roles of different methyl-CpG binding proteins and a more comprehensive analysis of DNA methylation across various genomic regions on the Xi are warranted. They also propose that the X inactivation system, with its distinct epigenetic landscape, remains an excellent model for dissecting the complex interplay of epigenetic regulators.

Summary updated

Abstract

These data suggest that DNA methylation and the associated methyl-DNA binding proteins may not play a critical role in determining histone modification patterns on the mammalian inactive X chromosome at the sites analyzed.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{gartler2004normal,
  author = {Stanley M. Gartler and Kartik Varadarajan and Ping Luo and Theresa K. Canfield and Jeff Traynor and Uta Francke and R. Scott Hansen},
  title = {{Normal histone modifications on the inactive X chromosome in ICF and Rett syndrome cells: implications for methyl-CpG binding proteins}},
  booktitle = {BMC},
  year = {2004},
  doi = {10.1186/1741-7007-2-21},
}
Figure