Norm Growth and Stability Challenges in Localized Sequential Knowledge Editing

Akshat Gupta, Christine Fang, Atahan Ozdemir, Maochuan Lu, Ahmed Alaa, Thomas Hartvigsen, Gopala AnumanchipalliarXiv 2025 · OpenReview

Abstract

This study investigates the impact of localized updates to large language models (LLMs), specifically in the context of knowledge editing - a task aimed at incorporating or modifying specific facts without altering broader model capabilities. We first show that across different post-training interventions like continuous pre-training, full fine-tuning and LORA-based fine-tuning, the Frobenius norm of the updated matrices always increases. This increasing norm is especially detrimental for localized knowledge editing, where only a subset of matrices are updated in a model . We reveal a consistent phenomenon across various editing techniques, including fine-tuning, hypernetwork-based approaches, and locate-and-edit methods: the norm of the updated matrix invariably increases with successive updates. Such growth disrupts model balance, particularly when isolated matrices are updated while the rest of the model remains static, leading to potential instability and degradation of downstream performance. Upon deeper investigations of the intermediate activation vectors, we find that the norm of internal activations decreases and is accompanied by shifts in the subspaces occupied by these activations, which shows that these activation vectors now occupy completely different regions in the representation space compared to the unedited model. With our paper, we highlight the technical challenges with continuous and localized sequential knowledge editing and their implications for maintaining model stability and utility.

Introduction

As Large Language Models (LLMs) become foundational to information retrieval and reasoning, the ability to update their internal knowledge base—correcting errors or incorporating new facts—is critical. Localized knowledge editing techniques, such as ROME and MEMIT, offer a surgically precise alternative to expensive full-model retraining by modifying only specific "knowledge neurons," typically within MLP layers. However, these methods face a significant hurdle: sequential editing often leads to catastrophic model collapse. This study investigates the geometric and structural underpinnings of this instability, revealing a consistent "norm explosion" that disrupts the model's internal representation space.

The Universality of Weight Norm Growth

A central finding of this research is that the Frobenius norm of updated weight matrices increases across all common post-training interventions, including Continual Pre-training (CPT), Full Fine-Tuning (FFT), and LoRA-based fine-tuning. This suggests that the process of "learning" or "adapting" in neural networks is intrinsically linked to an increase in weight magnitude.

Weight norm growth during LoRA finetuning across different model layers.

As shown in Figure 1, the norms of various layers in the Magicoder model increase monotonically during LoRA finetuning. This trend is not isolated to parameter-efficient methods; standard training procedures exhibit similar behavior, as seen in Figure 2.

The Localized Update Trap

While norm growth is universal, its impact differs based on the scope of the update. In standard fine-tuning, norms grow across the entire model, maintaining a relative structural balance. In contrast, localized knowledge editing targets only a few layers while the rest of the model remains static. This creates a massive imbalance—a few "heavy" layers embedded within a "light" model architecture.

Weight norm growth during continual pre-training (CPT) for various model components.

Figure 2 illustrates this growth during continual pre-training. When such growth is restricted to a tiny subset of parameters, as in ROME or MEMIT, the resulting structural disparity triggers a cascade of internal failures. Models like MEND were found to collapse within 100 edits, while more resilient methods like ROME showed significant degradation in MMLU and GLUE scores after 500–1,000 updates.

Activation Dynamics and Model Collapse

The researchers discovered a paradoxical relationship: as the weight norms of edited layers increase, the norms of the activations they produce actually decrease. This "activation shrinkage" is accompanied by a significant geometric drift. By analyzing the residual stream, the study found that internal signals move into entirely different regions of the representation space.

Linear classifiers trained on unedited models fail to correctly identify layers after sequential editing, indicating that activations from different layers are "bleeding" into one another. For example, after 2,000 edits, activations from Layer 20 might be indistinguishable from those of Layer 5 to the rest of the network. This loss of internal "mapping" leads to the degradation of general reasoning capabilities observed across benchmarks like HellaSwag and MuTual.

Conclusion

The instability of sequential knowledge editing is rooted in the fundamental geometric shifts caused by localized weight updates. The monotonic growth of weight norms, while a natural part of learning, becomes destructive when isolated. Future work, such as the proposed ENCORE method, suggests that regularizing weight norms during the editing process may be the key to enabling stable, long-term sequential updates in LLMs.

Summary updated

Abstract

This study investigates the impact of localized updates to large language models (LLMs), specifically in the context of knowledge editing - a task aimed at incorporating or modifying specific facts without altering broader model capabilities. We first show that across different post-training interventions like continuous pre-training, full fine-tuning and LORA-based fine-tuning, the Frobenius norm of the updated matrices always increases. This increasing norm is especially detrimental for localized knowledge editing, where only a subset of matrices are updated in a model . We reveal a consistent phenomenon across various editing techniques, including fine-tuning, hypernetwork-based approaches, and locate-and-edit methods: the norm of the updated matrix invariably increases with successive updates. Such growth disrupts model balance, particularly when isolated matrices are updated while the rest of the model remains static, leading to potential instability and degradation of downstream performance. Upon deeper investigations of the intermediate activation vectors, we find that the norm of internal activations decreases and is accompanied by shifts in the subspaces occupied by these activations, which shows that these activation vectors now occupy completely different regions in the representation space compared to the unedited model. With our paper, we highlight the technical challenges with continuous and localized sequential knowledge editing and their implications for maintaining model stability and utility.
BibTeX
@misc{gupta2025norm,
  author = {Akshat Gupta and Christine Fang and Atahan Ozdemir and Maochuan Lu and Ahmed Alaa and Thomas Hartvigsen and Gopala Anumanchipalli},
  title = {{Norm Growth and Stability Challenges in Localized Sequential Knowledge Editing}},
  year = {2025},
  eprint = {2502.19416},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2502.19416},
}
Figure